Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

NCT number NCT03463603
Other study ID # H13-00617
Secondary ID
Status Completed
Phase N/A
First received February 5, 2018
Last updated March 12, 2018
Start date October 7, 2013
Est. completion date April 12, 2017

Study information

Verified date March 2018
Source University of British Columbia
Contact n/a
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Observational

Clinical Trial Summary

When doctors and nurses use accepted guidelines for quickly treating patients who come to the emergency department (ED) with a possible heart attack, patients do better. Research shows that there are racial-identity- and ethnicity-based differences in the symptoms these patients have, when and why they seek care, the treatments they receive, and how well they fare afterwards. There is also Canadian evidence that there may be racial-identity-based disparities in the care some patients receive, and it has been suggested that health professionals may unconsciously treat patients of different racial identities differently. But it is not known if there is racial-identity variation in the care given to Canadian patients with heart attack symptoms in the critical first hours after coming to an ED, or in their experiences of this care. The investigators collected information from the health records of patients who come to EDs with symptoms of heart attack. The investigators recorded events and times such as what provisional diagnosis was assigned to the patient, how often they received pain medication, how long until certain tests were performed and what treatments were offered. The investigators also collected information about things that might affect delivery of care, e.g., the number of doctors and nurses who were on duty. Participants also completed a short questionnaire about their reasons for coming to the hospital, how long they waited before coming and why, and what their experience in the ED was like. The investigators reviewed this information to see if there are racial-identity-based differences in the care received by patients with heart attack symptoms. The findings could identify important disparities, which could in turn inform future projects to correct these disparities, for example, education of health professionals about ethnic differences in ideas of health and illness.


Description:

The investigators conducted a prospective, observational study in which patients presenting to EDs who were subsequently diagnosed with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) or possible ACS were identified. The investigators collected data related to receiving the accepted standard of care for ACS patients. Information about the participants' initial symptoms, attribution of their symptoms, treatment-seeking choices, and perceptions of the care received in the ED was collected.

Setting and Sample: The investigators conducted the study at three sites: Hospital 1 is in an inner-city, quaternary care, university-affiliated hospital whose ED has approximately 71,000 patient visits annually, about 2,800 of which are patients with symptoms that are potentially due to myocardial ischemia. The medical and nursing staffing levels are staggered based on expected patient volumes, ranging from 15 to 18 registered nurses (RNs) and 1 to 6 physicians at a given time. There are also support staff, including licensed practical nurses, aides; clerks, ECG technicians, etc. There is a designated triage area, staffed continuously by at least one RN. Hospital 2's ED is in a large community hospital in a different health authority. It has 100,000 patient visits annually, approximately 6,500 of which are patients with potentially ischemic symptoms. The medical and nursing staffing levels are similar to the first site, ranging from 19 to 22 registered nurses (RNs) and 1 to 4 physicians at a given time. This site is in a community with a very high proportion of South Asian people (27.5%). Hospital 3 is also a community hospital with fewer ED visits annually, but similar nursing and medical staffing levels. This site is in a community with a very high proportion (52.5%) of people identifying as being of Chinese ancestry.

Procedures: Research assistants (RAs) fluent in English, Mandarin and Cantonese for the tertiary site and one fluent in English and Punjabi for the community site recruited participants.

Recruitment. The RAs identified potential participants, seven days per week, from one of three sources: (1) a list, obtained daily from the ED charge nurse, of all patients admitted to the hospital since the RA's last visit who were triaged with codes related to a possible ACS; (2) the current charge nurse, who identified any patient currently in the ED who met study criteria as signified by the ED physician ordering one of the following: (i) cardiology consult, (ii) cardiac computational tomography, or (iii) 2- or 6-hour repeat cardiac biomarker and ECG, followed by outpatient provocative stress testing; (3) a list, obtained from the stress-testing laboratory, of all patients who had been referred from the ED for urgent (within 48 hours) outpatient stress testing.

Recruitment occurred in the ED, the cardiology units (CCU or telemetry unit) and in the stress-testing laboratory. Potential participants were screened for general eligibility through discussion with the nurse or cardiology technologist. Those believed to be eligible were approached and invited to participate.

Data collection. Data regarding delivery of guideline-based care in the ED were collected from the health record (e.g., time to stretcher, time to ECG, time to first MD assessment, medications administered) and other processes (e.g., occurrence and timing of cardiology consultation, transfer from ED to a critical care area). Data regarding several patient-, environment- and system-related potential covariates were collected from the health record (e.g., mode of arrival at ED; language spoken; accompanied by family/friend; language ability of family/friend; symptoms reported) and ED staffing records (staffing levels). Data pertaining to the entire ED stay were captured.

Participants were asked to respond to a questionnaire, administered by the RA, regarding their decision to seek treatment and their perspectives on their ED care. Ethnicity, racial identity and other sociodemographic data were obtained during the interview.

For those admitted to the hospital, additional data regarding admission unit , procedures offered, refused and undergone, major adverse cardiac events, length of stay and final diagnosis were collected. For participants who were discharged from the ED with referral to outpatient stress testing, we tracked discharge diagnosis, attendance at, and interpretation of the test.

Measures: The primary outcome variable, door-to-ECG time, was defined as the time from triage to first ECG acquisition. The official triage time is the time entered by the triage nurse when the patient is initially evaluated. The time of the first ECG is an electronic time stamp appearing in the clinical information system, entered when the ECG is acquired.

The predictor variables ethnicity and racial identity were measured by self-report.

Other outcome variables and potential confounders:

1. Time intervals: Several time intervals were measured, based on the official triage time.

2. Location, nature and severity of reported symptoms: All symptoms reported by participant, as well as their intensity.

3. Acuity at time of triage: measured using the Canadian Triage and Acuity Score. The participants' presenting complaint was measured using the Canadian Emergency Department Information System standardised codes, in use at the study sites.

4. Other data: Mode of transport to hospital, accompanied versus alone, noted difficulty with English, presence of interpreter during care

5. Number and frequency of physician and nurse assessments/interventions.

6. Measured clinical parameters: All documented observations of ECG rhythm and vital signs.

7. Medications: Agent, dose, route and time of administration

8. Diagnostic testing: Timing and frequency of bloodwork and ECGs.

9. Consultation: Consultation of other medical services.

10. Patient Disposition.

11. Patient perspectives: Time of onset, type of symptoms, decisions to seek treatment and reasons for delaying; participants' perspectives on care in ED; other socio-demographic variables

12. Emergency department contextual factors: Staffing levels for each shift.

13. Post-ED care: Diagnostic tests and interventions offered and completed after leaving ED, e.g., referral for / offer of / consent to / receipt of angiogram, percutaneous coronary intervention or cardiac surgery; discharge diagnosis; length of hospital stay.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Completed
Enrollment 448
Est. completion date April 12, 2017
Est. primary completion date January 11, 2017
Accepts healthy volunteers
Gender All
Age group 20 Years and older
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria:

- 20 years of age or older

- presented to the ED and are either referred for immediate cardiology consultation or managed according to a standardized protocol for continued observation and referral for follow-up (whether ultimately admitted or not);

- hemodynamically stable and free of ischemic discomfort for at least one hour

- spoke English, Mandarin, Cantonese, Punjabi

- able to provide informed consent.

Exclusion Criteria:

• being cared for by any of the Emergency physicians (3) who were co-investigators

Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


Locations

Country Name City State
Canada Richmond Hospital Richmond British Columbia
Canada Surrey Memorial Hospital Surrey British Columbia
Canada St. Paul's Hospital Vancouver British Columbia

Sponsors (4)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
University of British Columbia Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR), Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada, Michael Smith Foundation for Health Research

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Canada, 

References & Publications (2)

Iacoe E, Ratner PA, Wong ST, Mackay MH. A cross-sectional study of ethnicity-based differences in treatment seeking for symptoms of acute coronary syndrome. Eur J Cardiovasc Nurs. 2017 Nov 1:1474515117741893. doi: 10.1177/1474515117741893. [Epub ahead of — View Citation

Mackay, M.H., Ratner, P.A., Scheuermeyer, F.X., Veenstra, G., Ramanathan, K.R., O'Sullivan, M.E., Grubisic, M., Murray, C., Humphries, K.H. (2017). Is racism a factor in emergency department care of patients with suspected acute coronary syndrome? Canadia

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary Door to ECG time from Emergency triage to first ECG acquisition from hour and minute of admission until the hour and minute of first documented ECG, up to 48 hours
Secondary Number of assessments by health professionals The number of assessments by physicians and nurses during the ED stay. from hour and minute of admission until the hour and minute of transfer to inpatient unit or discharge from Emergency Department, whichever comes first, up to 48 hours
Secondary Rate of being offered and consenting to coronary angiogram Rate of being offered and consenting to coronary angiogram among those having a diagnosis of acute coronary syndrome or myocardial infarction. from date of admission until the date of hospital discharge, up to 100 weeks
Secondary Rate of being offered and consenting to any revascularization procedure Rate of being offered and consenting to any revascularization procedure among those having coronary atherosclerotic lesions >/= 70% in any vessel from date of admission until the date of hospital discharge, up to 24 weeks
Secondary ethnic differences in treatment-seeking delay the time between symptom onset and the decision to seek medical help from hour and minute of first documented symptoms until the hour and minute of first documented help-seeking, up to 168 hours
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT05846893 - Drug-Coated Balloon vs. Drug-Eluting Stent for Clinical Outcomes in Patients With Large Coronary Artery Disease N/A
Recruiting NCT06013813 - Conventional vs. Distal Radial Access Outcomes in STEMI Patients Treated by PCI N/A
Recruiting NCT05412927 - AngelMed Guardian® System PMA Post Approval Study
Completed NCT02750579 - Early or Delayed Revascularization for Intermediate and High-risk Non ST-elevation Acute Coronary Syndromes? N/A
Completed NCT04102410 - Assessing Force-velocity Profile: an Innovative Approach to Optimize Cardiac Rehabilitation in Coronary Patients N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT03342131 - Serum Concentration of Wnt2 and Wnt4 in Patients With Acute Coronary Syndrome N/A
Recruiting NCT01218776 - International Survey of Acute Coronary Syndromes in Transitional Countries
Enrolling by invitation NCT04676100 - International CR Registry
Completed NCT03590535 - 5th Generation cTnT in ED ACS
Recruiting NCT05437900 - INSIGHTFUL-FFR Clinical Trial Phase 4
Completed NCT05551429 - Factors Related to Participation in Cardiac Rehabilitation in Patients With Acute Coronary Syndrome
Terminated NCT04316481 - IDE-ALERTS Continued Access Study N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT04475380 - Complex All-comers and Patients With Diabetes or Prediabetes, Treated With Xience Sierra Everolimus-eluting Stents
Not yet recruiting NCT04852146 - Electronic Feedback for Data Restitution and Valorization to the Emergency Teams in Aquitaine.
Active, not recruiting NCT02892903 - In the Management of Coronary Artery Disease, Does Routine Pressure Wire Assessment at the Time of Coronary Angiography Affect Management Strategy, Hospital Costs and Outcomes? N/A
Completed NCT04077229 - Piloting Text Messages to Promote Positive Affect and Physical Activity N/A
Completed NCT02944123 - Half Dose of Prasugrel and Ticagrelor in Acute Coronary Syndrome (HOPE-TAILOR) Phase 3
Not yet recruiting NCT02871622 - BMX Alpha Registry: a Post-market Registry of the BioMatrix Alpha TM N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT02922140 - The Impact of Pharmaceutical Care Practice on Patients in Cardiac Rehabilitation Unit N/A
Terminated NCT02620202 - Aiming Towards Evidence Based Interpretation of Cardiac Biomarkers in Patients Presenting With Chest Pain