Video Games Among People With Schizophrenia

Cognitive Function Clinical Trial

— GAME-S  

Official title:

The Impact of Video Gaming on Cognitive Functioning in People With Schizophrenia

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT03133143
• Other study ID #: HSEARS20161228002
• Status: Completed
• Phase: N/A
• Start date: May 16, 2019
• Est. completion date: December 31, 2021

Study information

• Verified date: May 2022
• Source: The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
• Contact: n/a
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Study type: Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

The investigators aim to establish a research project to test the impact of gaming by carrying out a digital gaming interventions, monitoring its cognitive and clinical outcomes, while concurrently performing a multimodal brain imaging experiment.

Description:

The effectiveness of the gaming intervention will be assessed using a controlled, controlled, single-blind clinical trial with a pragmatic, three-arm parallel-group design.

Interventions: Participants will be randomised into three groups: Cognitive training (intervention group, CogniFit, N=78), entertainment video gaming (active control group, SIMS4, N=78) and treatment as usual (a passive control group, N=78). The mechanism of CogniFit (intervention) lies on the evidence for computerised exercises focusing on auditory and verbal processing, which are likely to yield improved verbal learning and memory and activate reward systems of the brain that drive brain plasticity in adults with schizophrenia. SIMS4 game (active control) offers entertainment without any known cognitive or health-related outcome. The data collection, subject recruitment and training will be carried out in an outpatient psychiatric units or outpatient clinics, mental health associations, and residential homes in Hong Kong. The study is aimed for patients' diagnoses of schizophrenia.

Recruitment: An extended informed consent process will be used. The health service's medical records at the study site will be screened by the authority of the staff of the organisation. Patients will be screened to determine their eligibility for study participation. Eligible participant will first receive a short leaflet of the study from the staff or during a short information session organised for the participants to consider their availability. If an eligible patient shows interest, more detailed written and oral information will be shared.

After signing informed consent forms (two identical copies), baseline data with background information, Intelligence Quotient (IQ, if available) and MMSE will be collected to show evidence of the participants' capacity to give informed consent. Medication dosage [chlorpromazine equivalence] will be collected as some medications currently used in schizophrenia may affect the response to cognitive training strategies.

Recruitment will continue until the required sample size has been obtained.

Randomisation: After baseline data collection, the Trial Manager will be informed (by email, text message, WhatsApp) about a new participant and he/she will allocate the participant to one of the three arms based on a list of computer-generated random numbers provided by an external clinical trial randomisation service (blocks of 6 consecutive patients, a 1:1:1 ratio). Allocation will be masked to the outcome assessors, and the trial statistician, but it cannot be masked from the RAs who recruit the patients and the treatment staff working with the patients.

For neuroimaging assessment (EEG, fMRI, resting state), a sub-sample from our total sample will be randomised at baseline. Randomisation will be based on a list of computer-generated random numbers.

Power analysis and sample size: The investigators calculated the sample size based on (1) the number of actual pairwise tests to be made for the efficacy of the primary outcome and (2) the two-level modelling approach in the final data analysis, in which the type I error has been adjusted. The statistical efficiency will be ensured using the MANOVA method for multiple group comparison. First, given that video gaming is a fairly novel strategy, the investigators will base the sample size calculation (a priori) on a cognitive-efficacy meta-analysis for patients with schizophrenia showing and overall effect size (ES, Cohens' D) of 0.58 on verbal working memory (a primary outcome). Based on our hypothesis, the primary endpoints are the effects in verbal working memory at 3 and 6 months of cognitive training in the gaming group, in comparison with the other two groups: cognitive training vs. entertainment gaming, cognitive training vs. non-gaming control group. Four pairwise interactions between the contrast of the two comparisons and the two time points will be tested. For multiple comparison tests of four, for a type I error level of 5% (two-sided), an adjusted significant level should be = (1- (1- 0.05)4) /2 = 0.01274 /2 = 0.0064, and the corresponding z score for a one-sided test is 2.49. Given the effect size 0.58, assuming equal sample size of the three groups, with a statistical power of 0.8 and = 0.01274, the investigators require at least 198 subjects (66 per group) by applying the equation, 2(Z1- + Z1- /2)2 / ES2. According to a meta-analysis,40 the total sample size in previous cognitive training studies has typically been 50 (range 10-138).

Using evidence-based rationale for patient flow in this study, the investigators can assume that about 60% of patients that will be screened will not be eligible for the study due to age or lack of capacity to participate in the study. Based on the literature, about 45% of patients with schizophrenia will refuse to participate in the RCT studies, and 16% will drop-out during the course of intervention. Thus, the investigators need a total of 234 participants to be randomply allocated to three study groups, and 198 participants in follow-ups. Based on this knowledge, a total of 985 subjects need to be approached. The numbers are realistic given that the total number of patients with schizophrenia in our study sites is about 5,500, and the total number of schizophrenia patients in Hong Kong is 40,000.

Second, for neuroimaging assessment, a sub-sample of 126 participants from our total sample (N = 198) will need (63%) to be randomised at baseline. Randomisation will be based on a list of computer-generated random numbers. The investigators assume that 30% will drop-out between baseline and the 3-month follow-up assessment, which leave us with 29 patients in each group (totally 87 participants at baseline). The sample size will be appropriate for our neuroimaging assessment; the average number of participants in RCT studies assessing patient cognition or changes in brain structure has been about 20.

The investigators will also verify whether the interventions have been delivered as designed (intervention fidelity). Therefore, patient gaming logs (gaming frequency [number of gaming sessions per week], the length of each session [minutes], number of drop-outs) and patient gaming diaries including descriptions of possible strengths and limitations of the interventions will be analysed with the content analysis based on the data to be collected from patient diaries.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Completed
• Enrollment: 143
• Est. completion date: December 31, 2021
• Est. primary completion date: July 31, 2021
• Accepts healthy volunteers: No
• Gender: All
• Age group: 18 Years to 60 Years

Eligibility

Inclusion criteria:

• patients' diagnoses of schizophrenia (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual DSM-IV)

• able to speak Cantonese

• be unfamiliar with video games or at least non-active game players (play < 5h/week)

• have the ability to provide written informed consent

• be viewed as being able to safely take part and have the cognitive status deemed suitable for participation (assessed by a chief psychiatrist based on his/her clinical expertise)

Exclusion criteria:

• meeting diagnostic criteria for a current major depressive, manic or hypomanic episode (DSM-IV), or mental retardation

• having severe visual impairment

• being an active game player (i.e. gaming > 5 h/week)

• displaying a lack of ability to decide their own participation

• displaying substance abuse (other than nicotine dependence)

• having head injury, hemiplegia, or other neurological disorders

• having had an Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) in the past six months

• having a lack of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) compatibility (for example, patients with cardiac pacemakers, metallic implants, restless behaviour)

• pregnancy

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Cognitive Function
• Mental Disorders
• Psychotic Disorders
• Schizophrenia
• Schizophrenia and Disorders With Psychotic Features
• Schizophrenia Spectrum and Other Psychotic Disorders

Intervention

Behavioral:
• Cognifit
CogniFit is an Internet browser-based digital brain training program, to improve cognitive abilities based on a personalised brain training regimen. Participants are instructed to play all games assigned by cognifit from three categories (memory, spatial perception, and mental planning) during each training session. After playing the games in these three categories, they are free to choose which exercises they wish to play.
• SIMS 4 (Maxis, Inc)
The Sims 4 is a life simulation PC game. It is purely an entertainment game without known cognitive or health-related outcomes. Does not iclude high-intensity action and competition. This specific game and non-competitive games like it in general do not improve attention, working memory, or other cognitive abilities despite being engaging and fun.

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
Hong Kong	Comfort Rehabilitation Home	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Everbright Rehabilitation Centre	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Home of Treasure	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Kowloon Hospital	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Mental Health Association of Hong Kong	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Parklane Rehabilitation Home	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Richmond Fellowship of Hong Kong	Hong Kong
Hong Kong	Maxgrace Fuller House	Kowloon

Sponsors (8)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University	Kowloon Hospital, Hong Kong, Maxgrace Fuller House, Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital, Sichuan University, The Mental Health Association of Hong Kong, University of Helsinki, University of Turku

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Hong Kong, 

References & Publications (1)

Välimäki M, Yang M, Lam YTJ, Lantta T, Palva M, Palva S, Yee B, Yip SH, Yu KD, Chang HCC, Cheng PYI, Bressington D. The impact of video gaming on cognitive functioning of people with schizophrenia (GAME-S): study protocol of a randomised controlled trial. BMC Psychiatry. 2021 Jan 18;21(1):46. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-03031-y. — View Citation

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Primary	Verbal working memory function at 3-month and 6-month follow-ups	Measured by Letter-number-span task from Wechsler Memory Scale III (WMS III), simplified/traditional Chinese versions. The instrument includes the National Institute of Mental Health - Measurement and Treatment Research to Improve Cognition in Schizophrenia 50 battery (NIMH-MATRICS50).	3-month and 6-month follow-ups
Secondary	Cognitive functioning: speed of processing	A battery of cognitive tests: speed of processing [Trail Making Test A].	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Cognitive functioning: attention	A battery of cognitive tests: attention (serotonin transporter; SERT).	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Cognitive functioning: vigilance	A battery of cognitive tests: vigilance [SERT].	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Cognitive functioning: visuo-spatial working memory	A battery of cognitive tests: visuo-spatial working memory [Spatial span from WMS III].	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Cognitive functioning: reasoning	A battery of cognitive tests: reasoning [Wisconsin Card Sorting Task).	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Cognitive functioning: problem solving	A battery of cognitive tests: problem solving [Wisconsin Card Sorting Task).	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Social functioning: severity of social phobia	A Chinese version of Brief Social Phobia Scale (BSPS51) assessing severity of social phobia.	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Social functioning: treatment response in social phobia	A Chinese version of Brief Social Phobia Scale (BSPS51) assessing treatment response in social phobia.	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Experience of pleasure: anticipatory component	The 'temporal Experience of Pleasure Scale' (TEPS, Chinese version) covers the anticipatory component.	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Experience of pleasure: consummatory component	The 'temporal Experience of Pleasure Scale' (TEPS, Chinese version) covers the consummatory component.	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Self-efficacy	Chinese version of 'General Self-Efficacy Scale' (GSE) is a self-report measure of self-efficacy.	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Psychotic symptoms	The Chinese version of the Clinical Assessment Interview for Negative Symptoms (CAINS) administered by qualified psychiatrists in Hong Kong who have received proper training for this assessment tool.	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Anhedonia symptoms	Other symptoms, which might confound negative symptom presentation and need to be assessed include: 'The Calgary Depression Scale for Schizophrenia' (CDS-C), an observer-rated Likert-scale to measure depressive symptoms; The Simpson-Angus Rating Scale (SAS), the Barnes Akathisia Rating Scale (BARS), and the Abnormal Movement Involuntary Scale (AIMS).	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Avolition symptoms	Other symptoms, which might confound negative symptom presentation and need to be assessed include: 'The Calgary Depression Scale for Schizophrenia' (CDS-C), an observer-rated Likert-scale to measure depressive symptoms; The Simpson-Angus Rating Scale (SAS), the Barnes Akathisia Rating Scale (BARS), and the Abnormal Movement Involuntary Scale (AIMS).	Baseline, after intervention (three months) and at six months follow-up
Secondary	Neurocognition: the impact of gaming on brain functional networks (EEG/rsfMRI)	EEG/Resting states fMRI. The impact of gaming on brain functional networks can be revealed by recording neuronal activity with M/EEG during the execution of a working memory task and also during resting-state conditions, which reveal changes in spontaneous activities in the brain.	Baseline, after intervention (three months)
Secondary	Neurocognition: the impact of gaming on changes in neuronal dynamics (EEG/rsfMRI)	EEG/Resting states fMRI. The impact of gaming on changes in neuronal dynamics can be revealed by recording neuronal activity with M/EEG during the execution of a working memory task and also during resting-state conditions, which reveal changes in spontaneous activities in the brain.	Baseline, after intervention (three months)
Secondary	Neurocognition: the impact of gaming on brain functional networks (EEG/Structural magnetic resonance imaging)	Structural magnetic resonance imaging. The impact of gaming on brain functional networks can be revealed by recording neuronal activity with M/EEG during the execution of a working memory task and also during resting-state conditions, which reveal changes in spontaneous activities in the brain.	Baseline, after intervention (three months)
Secondary	Neurocognition: the impact of gaming on changes in neuronal dynamics (EEG/Structural magnetic resonance imaging)	Structural magnetic resonance imaging. The impact of gaming on changes in neuronal dynamics can be revealed by recording neuronal activity with M/EEG during the execution of a working memory task and also during resting-state conditions, which reveal changes in spontaneous activities in the brain.	Baseline, after intervention (three months)