Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

The purpose of this study is to assess the utility of training in Breaking Bad News (BBN) skills. We hypothesize that given little or no formal training in breaking bad news, obstetric providers will benefit from a curriculum of teaching breaking bad news techniques, but will benefit more from a simulation teaching technique than from a lecture in breaking bad news techniques.

The investigators also hypothesize that providers who have undergone breaking bad news simulation will receive improved scores after the simulation debriefing compared to their pre-simulation scores, and their improvement with be greater than the control group.


Clinical Trial Description

The investigators' study is part of a planned educational initiative on breaking bad news communication skills, planned for house staff in the department of Obstetrics and Gynecology. All subjects will undergo both a baseline and post-education simulation. The investigators' study intervention is a personalized review and debriefing of the simulation, as compared with a conventional lecture in order to assess the best curriculum for teaching this skill set.

The investigators' study design will be described, consent obtained and consenting house staff will be randomized to participate in a simulation-based education session/debrief or to attend lecture. Randomization will be achieved using sequential opaque envelopes containing allocation cards, designating group assignment. A physician who is not involved in the study will randomly insert allocation cards into the envelopes and group assignment will be concealed until after enrollment is complete.

Subjects will be assigned a study number. The list of subject identifiers and study numbers will be kept separate from other study data, and destroyed after all phases of the study are complete. All other study data will have identifying information deleted, and will be stored in a password protected database.

The investigators plan to have subjects assess baseline characteristics and breaking bad news skills using a self-assessment tool. Subsequently all house staff will be evaluated on their management of breaking bad news through a baseline SP scenario, with assessments by physician-teachers as well as the SPs . These SPs are non-physicians, and do not have supervisory control over the study subjects. The physician-teachers are the co-investigators on this study: Drs. Chazotte, Dayal, Landsberger, Bernstein, Goffman, and Karkowsky.

After this baseline assessment, the intervention group will debrief their baseline simulation with a physician educator. The control group will instead undergo a conventional lecture about "Breaking Bad News" techniques. Finally, both groups will undergo a second simulation, which will be assessed by SPs and physician-teachers

After this step, subjects will fill out self-assessment tools on BBN. House staff who did not undergo the conventional curriculum will then attend the lecture; similarly, those subjects who were not in the intervention group will then have the opportunity to review their simulation in a personal debriefing session.

Six months after the study, we plan to have all subjects fill out a self-assessment form to assess if any long-term change to their BBN skills has been sustained.

SPs will be formally trained in the scenario and in their responses, as well as in standardized assessment of the subjects. ;


Study Design

Allocation: Randomized, Endpoint Classification: Efficacy Study, Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment, Masking: Double Blind (Subject, Investigator)


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT02168192
Study type Interventional
Source Montefiore Medical Center
Contact
Status Completed
Phase N/A
Start date November 2010
Completion date July 2013

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT05081635 - Consenso2_F1 Delphi Consensus Study on Post-graduate Medical Education Success and Failure and Its Influencing Factors
Recruiting NCT06092320 - Does Teaching Before or After Simulation Improve Learning? N/A
Recruiting NCT05436899 - A Pilot Study on Training Simulator Efficacy N/A
Completed NCT03758391 - Comparison of Learning in Traditional Versus "Flipped" Classrooms N/A
Completed NCT05078762 - Immersive Virtual Reality in Simulation-based Bronchoscopy Training N/A
Completed NCT05526365 - Idea Density in Exam Performance N/A
Completed NCT05043909 - The Effects of Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality Training System on Elderly Oral Care Skill for Oral Hygiene and Nursing Students N/A
Completed NCT05191589 - Haptic Devices Impact on Laparoscopic Simulators N/A
Completed NCT05585892 - Elaboration and Feedback for Clinical Reasoning Training N/A
Completed NCT05596305 - Outcomes of Anti Stigma Educational Intervention of Ungraduated Medical Students N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT06276049 - ChatGPT Helping Advance Training for Medical Students: A Study on Self-Directed Learning Enhancement N/A
Completed NCT02971735 - Cognitive Style and Mobile Technology in E-learning in Undergraduate Medical Education N/A
Completed NCT00466453 - Adapting Web-based Instruction to Baseline Knowledge of Physicians-in-training Phase 2/Phase 3
Recruiting NCT05169073 - Virtual Reality Training for Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy N/A
Completed NCT05393219 - Cardiac Biofeedback, Mindfulness, and Inner Resources Mobilization Interventions on Performances of Medical Students N/A
Recruiting NCT04375254 - Neuroscience-based Nomenclature (NbN) as a Teaching Tool
Completed NCT05834374 - Training for Transfer by Contextual Variation N/A
Completed NCT03863028 - Development and Validation of a Simulator-based Test in Transurethral Resection of Bladder Tumors
Completed NCT03471975 - Learning Direct Laryngoscopy Using a McGrath Video Laryngoscope as Direct Versus Indirect Laryngoscope N/A
Recruiting NCT06114433 - Three-dimensional Upper Gastrointestinal Tract Model N/A