Lidocaine Lubricant in Pediatric Urethral Catheterization

Pain Clinical Trial

Official title:

Lidocaine Lubricant Use as an Anesthetic Agent in Emergency Room Urethral Catheterization

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT00596375
• Other study ID #: 06693
• Status: Completed
• Phase: N/A
• First received: January 8, 2008
• Last updated: January 16, 2008
• Start date: August 2006
• Est. completion date: March 2007

Study information

• Verified date: December 2007
• Source: Children's Healthcare of Atlanta
• Contact: n/a
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Health authority: United States: Institutional Review Board
• Study type: Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

In Emergency Departments (ED) across the nation there is renewed interest in finding ways to alleviate the pain and discomfort associated with many of the procedures that children must undergo. In a policy by the American Academy of Pediatrics, a nationally recognized advocate for children, physicians are urged to advocate for child-specific research in pain management and the effective use of pain medication to ensure compassionate and competent management of pain. (AAP Statement, 2001) Pediatric urethral catheterizations are one such procedure in which children experience significant pain.(11) In present care, children over 2 months of age do not routinely receive intervention for urethral catheterization related anxiety and pain, and, anecdotal reports suggest that most require physical restraint to complete the procedure. Lidocaine is an anesthetic agent that provides relief from pain during many commonly performed ED procedures. Intraurethral Lidocaine has been shown to decrease pain associated with urethral catheter placement in cystograms, however, Lidocaine is not routinely used for urethral catheterizations in the CHOA ED.

This study aims to investigate the potential use of Lidocaine as an anesthetic agent during urethral catheterization of children. Recently, two specific studies were performed investigating the use of Lidocaine to decrease discomfort associated with urethral catheterization. Using the strengths of both previously published studies, our study will use Lidocaine both topically and instilled into the urethra. Investigators plan to perform a prospective three-arm double-blinded randomized clinical trial investigating the effectiveness of Lidocaine jelly as a analgesic when used as a lubricant for urinary catheterization. Investigators aim to demonstrate that Lidocaine used as a lubricant anesthetic for urethral catheterization will provide a safe, time-efficient, and relatively easy way to decrease pediatric pain in the emergency department setting.

Description:

In Emergency Departments (ED) across the nation there is renewed interest in finding ways to alleviate the pain and discomfort associated with many of the procedures that children must undergo. Children's memory and reaction to negative experiences in the care of medical professionals has led to many changes in procedural pain management (4). One noxious procedure that continues to be performed in the ED without the use of anesthetic agents is urethral catheterization (11). In a policy by the American Academy of Pediatrics, a nationally recognized advocate for children, physicians are urged to advocate for child-specific research in pain management and the effective use of pain medication to ensure compassionate and competent management of pain. (AAP Statement, 2001)

Pediatric urethral catheterizations are one such procedure in which children experience significant pain. (11) The Children's Healthcare of Atlanta (CHOA) ED at Egleston performs an average of greater than 150 pediatric urethral catheterizations per month. This procedure is performed in most cases where children under 6 months of age present with unexplained fever. Also, divisional guidelines call for urethral catheterization for urinanalysis and urine culture on all uncircumcised boys under the age of 1 and all girls under the age of 2 who present with unexplained temperature above 39.5 degrees. In a previous Friends funded clinical trial, ED investigators studied sucrose use in children under 2 months of age which was shown to decrease urethral catheterization discomfort. As such, this has become routine care in the ED. (REF; for a review of sucrose for pediatric pain, see 6) In present care, children over 2 months of age do not routinely receive intervention for urethral catheterization related anxiety and pain, and, anecdotal reports suggest that most require physical restraint to complete the procedure.

Lidocaine is an anesthetic agent that provides relief from pain during many commonly performed ED procedures. Examples of present Lidocaine use in the ED are laceration repair, abscess drainage, and lumbar puncture. Given the anxiety, discomfort, and pain associated with urethral catheterizations (1, 2, 3, 4), Lidocaine has begun to be used clinically in this arena. Intraurethral Lidocaine has been shown to decrease pain associated with urethral catheter placement in cystograms, however, Lidocaine is not routinely used for catheter placement to obtain urine in the CHOA ED.

Recently, two specific studies were performed investigating the use of Lidocaine to decrease discomfort associated with urethral catheterization. The first published study supports the use of intraurethral Lidocaine for catheterization.(5) In this investigation, Lidocaine was repeatedly instilled into the urethra of ten 4- to 11-year-old patients for approximately 10 minutes prior to a scheduled cystogram. Patients in this study indicated significantly less pain with Lidocaine as a lubricant when compared to those who received sterile lubricant jelly. However, the placement of a catheter for cystogram requires the catheter to be in place for the duration of the procedure (10 to 15 minutes); whereas catheterization in the ED for urinalysis and urine culture requires catheter placement for a much shorter period of time. The second study, which compared Lidocaine to lubricant jelly used as a topical anesthetic prior to catheterization, found that preverbal patients experienced the same discomfort with or without Lidocaine when evaluated using Face-Legs-Activity-Cry-Consolability (FLACC) scoring.(11) Authors attempted to investigate Lidocaine topically placed at the urethral meatus to provide relief. Although the investigators did not achieve their goal of pain reduction using Lidocaine topically, they did find that the incidence of positive urine culture was similar in both the Lidocaine and placebo groups. Using the strengths of both previously published studies, our study will use Lidocaine both topically and instilled into the urethra.

Medical care professionals are increasing their attention to pain and comfort measures for children undergoing painful procedures in the ED. Pediatric urethral catheterization is one such area that remains unaddressed. The use of Lidocaine as an anesthetic in common ED procedures is well known. Investigation of Lidocaine use as an anesthetic lubricant has been reported twice previously in pediatric literature with contradicting results. After critical appraisal of these studies, our investigators conclude that additional investigation is warranted with the following characteristics: Lidocaine should be placed both topically and instilled into the urethra; Lidocaine should be compared to both routine care and placebo; methodology should include blinded observations; methodology should evaluate pain response utilizing numerous validated tools; and urine should be monitored to evaluate the biological effects of Lidocaine on urine culture results. Investigators aim to demonstrate that Lidocaine used as a lubricant anesthetic for urethral catheterization will provide a safe, time-efficient, and relatively easy way to decrease pediatric pain in the emergency department setting.

Specific Aims & Hypotheses

SA1: To study the potential use of Lidocaine as an anesthetic agent during urethral catheterization of children presenting to Pediatric Emergency Department.

H1: The use of Lidocaine jelly as a lubricant in urethral catheterizations in pediatric ED patients significantly decreases distress associated with this procedure.

SA2: To determine the average Lidocaine concentration present in urine obtained with Lidocaine jelly used as lubricant during urinary catheterization.

H2: Urine Lidocaine concentrations associated with routine urethral catheterization utilizing intraurethral Lidocaine installation will not approach known bacterial growth-limiting levels.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Completed
• Enrollment: 47
• Est. completion date: March 2007
• Accepts healthy volunteers: No
• Gender: Both
• Age group: 2 Months to 2 Years

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

• Febrile patients aged 2 months to 2 years receiving urethral catheterization to obtain sterile urine for microbiologic and chemistry testing will be eligible to participate. Our study will be limited to children presenting with fever secondary to an unknown source, as ED triage protocol requires the administration of non-steroidal analgesic to treat fever.

Exclusion Criteria:

• The physician determines the patient is in need of immediate treatment or catheterization

• Patients have a history of genitourinary abnormalities

• Patients have had a previous catheterization

• Primary caregiver has limited English proficiency

• Patients with a history of genitourinary abnormalities

• Patients with history of prior catheterization are excluded from enrollment

Study Design

Allocation: Randomized, Endpoint Classification: Efficacy Study, Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment, Masking: Double Blind (Subject, Caregiver, Investigator, Outcomes Assessor), Primary Purpose: Supportive Care

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Fevers
• Pain

Intervention

Procedure:
• Lubricant Instillation
Lubricant jelly instilled in urethra prior to catheterization

Drug:
• Lidocaine Lubricant
2% Lidocaine lubricant instillation prior to urethral catheterization

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
United States	Children's Healthcare of Atlanta	Atlanta	Georgia

Sponsors (2)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
Children's Healthcare of Atlanta	Emory University

Country where clinical trial is conducted

United States, 

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Primary	Modified Behavior Pain Scale		Procedure (approx. 6 minutes)	No
Secondary	Lidocaine Concentration		Procedure (approx. 6 minutes)	Yes
Secondary	Visual Analog Scale		Procedure (approx. 6 minutes)	No