Outcomes of 36 vs 38 Hour Intervals From Ovulation Trigger To Oocyte Pick-Up:A Multi-Center Randomized Controlled Trial

Infertility Clinical Trial

Official title:

Does Time From Ovulation Trigger To Oocyte Pick-Up Affect Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection Outcomes? A Multi-Center Single-Blinded Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing 36 and 38 Hour Intervals

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Recruiting

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT05803655
• Other study ID #: 2021.267.IRB1.093
• Status: Recruiting
• Phase: N/A
• Start date: April 27, 2023
• Est. completion date: December 2025

Study information

• Verified date: April 2023
• Source: Koç University
• Contact: Engin Turkgeldi, Assoc.Prof.
• Phone: 00908502508250
• Email: engtur[@]gmail.com
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Study type: Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

Women who undergo assisted reproduction technology (ART) treatment will be eligible for this study. The goal of this randomized clinical trial is to compare the outcomes of ART treatment between women who have 36 and 38 hours interval between the administration of ovulation trigger (ovulation trigger medication initiates oocyte maturation and makes it possible for the egg to be collected by aspiration, during a procedure called oocyte pick-up, OPU) and OPU. The main questions it aims to answer are, does prolonging the trigger-OPU interval to 38-hours improve:

1. Primarily:

•Ratio of metaphase-2 oocytes to total number of follicles

2. Secondarily:

• Maturation rate

• Fertilization rate

• Blastulation rate

• Premature ovulation rate

• Positive pregnancy test rate

• Clinical pregnancy rate

• Live birth rate

compared to 36-hours interval?

Description:

1.0 STUDY POPULATION AND PATIENT SELECTION Women undergoing ART treatment at the participating centers will be invited to enroll in the study. Each patient will be able to participate only once with a single oocyte pick-up (OPU) cycle and embryos obtained from this cycle. Details of inclusion and exclusion criteria are described in the ''Eligibility'' section.

2.0 RANDOMIZATION METHOD AND ALLOCATION CONCEALMENT Couples who meet the study criteria will be informed about the study when they start treatment and will be given time to decide. On the day of ovulation trigger administration, patients who give written informed consent will be enrolled and randomized to one of the study groups (36 or 38 hours) by the nurse-in-charge. The patient will be instructed about the administration time by the nurse. Randomization information will not be shared with clinicians, laboratory team or other employees in the clinic throughout the study. The patient will also be asked not to share this information with anyone from the staff.

Randomization will be performed online in real time by a professional third-party company whose services meet international regulatory guidelines. The randomization sequence will be stratified by treatment center, female age group (18-27, 28-34, 35-37, 38-40, 41-42), anticipated embryo transfer day (day 3 and day 5), and plan to utilize preimplantation genetic testing for the embryos. Randomized blocks of varying size (4,6, or 8) will be created to ensure a similar number of patients among the study groups in each stratum during and at the end of the study.

3.0. TREATMENT PROTOCOLS The intervention in this study is the time between the ovulation trigger and the OPU procedure. Therefore, each clinic will apply their own routine treatments and make their own choices regarding the protocols/drugs/materials and/or procedures to be used.

3.1. Controlled Ovarian Hyperstimulation(COH) and Triggering of Oocyte maturation One of three protocols for COH can be applied according to the preference of the clinician: Antagonist protocol, progestin-primed ovarian stimulation, or agonist protocol.

Once the decision to trigger oocyte maturation is made, the nurse-in-charge will randomize the patient.

3.2. Oocyte collection(OPU) procedure On the day of OPU, the nurse-in-charge will confirm and note the time the patient administered the medication. She will then record the OPU start time and assess adherence to the protocol. The time of OPU will be based on the hour and minute when the first follicle was aspirated and recorded.

The total number of follicles larger than 10 mm on ultrasonography performed before OPU and the presence of premature ovulation signs will be recorded. The needle and solution routinely used by the clinic will be used for OPU. All follicles >10 millimeters in diameter will be aspirated.

3.3. Fertilization, Embryo Culture and Embryo Transfer All mature oocytes obtained by OPU will be fertilized by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). After fertilization, oocytes/embryos will be cultured according to the standard protocols of the center.

Embryo(s) will be transferred fresh or frozen-thawed at the clinician's discretion. Preparation for frozen-thawed embryo transfers will be performed as a natural, modified natural, or artificial cycle, again at the clinician's discretion.

Embryo transfers will be performed under ultrasonography guidance at the cleavage or blastocyst stage(day 3 or day 5) according to the clinician's preference and clinic protocol. One or two embryos will be transferred in accordance with the Ministry of Health regulations. Luteal phase support will be provided in accordance with the routine treatment of each clinic.

4. EVALUATION OF RESULTS Primary and secondary outcome measures are described in the ''Outcome Measures'' section.

5. DATA COLLECTION AND MANAGEMENT 5.1. Data Collection Study data will be entered daily into the electronic data collection (EDC) form of the study. EDC forms are filled online in real time and stored by a professional third-party company whose services will meet compliance certifications worldwide such as U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 11; The General Data Protection Regulation(GDPR) European Union(EU); International Conference on Harmonisation Good Clinical Practice (ICH GCP); The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, United States(HIPAA, US); the International Organization for Standardization(ISO) 27001; ISO 9001, and will align with Good Clinical Practice(GCP); Health Level 7,Fast Health Interoperability Resources(HL7 FHIR) and other regulatory guidelines.

Each quarter, a member of the study team will compare the consistency between the data entered in the clinic records and the EDC form. Preferably and if feasible, all actual files in the center and the EDC form will be compared; if this is not feasible, a part of the files (at least 50%) will be randomly selected and compared.

5.2. Data Collection Period The results will be evaluated after the information of the last included patient has been completed. At this point, all entries into the database will be confirmed as complete and only then will the randomization code be broken and the data analysis process will begin.

5.3. Electronic database, data entry and quality control An electronic database will be established to record the study data. This database will be maintained by an external organization capable of meeting the security, confidentiality, backup and quality standards to be defined. Study data will be entered daily into the study EDC form by authorized study coordinators and the database will be updated and backed up in real time. Only authorized persons will have access to the database, and each person will be authorized to see, see/write, or see/write/modify data according to their role. Data modification or deletion will require the approval of at least two authorized persons, and these changes will be tracked and justified.

Quality control will be performed quarterly during the study period. In each period, the original patient follow-up files of preferably all(or if this is not feasible, randomly selected one-half) of the participants accumulated at each center will be compared with the data in the database. The acceptable error rate is zero for the primary outcome measure and less than 5% for other variables. In any control, when the discrepancy between the original forms and the database in a center exceeds 5%, the original records of that center will be compared with all entries of that center in the database and data cleaning will be performed. In order to minimize data entry errors and omissions, mandatory fields to be filled in the electronic data collection form will be determined and the form will not be saved to the system without filling in these fields; similarly, the software will not allow entering a value other than the expected values for each parameter.

6. STATISTICAL EVALUATION 6.1. Sample Size Calculation Considering that the rate of metaphase-2 oocytes obtained per aspirated follicle during OPU in our clinic is 57%, calculations based on the hypothesis that an absolute 10% increase in this rate will be achieved with the intervention to be tried, it was revealed that a total of 770 patients should be randomized at 80% power and 5% alpha error level. Assuming that approximately 10% of patients would drop out of the study during follow-up, 850 patients would be randomized. Six centers will participate in the study and it is thought that this number will be reached in 1 year with the anticipated study tempo.

In the first two interim analyses, this sample size can be revised according to the efficacy data obtained in the study so far, provided that the same alpha error and statistical power rates are maintained.

6.2. Handling of Missing Data Patients with missing data will not be excluded from the analyses, but will be included in the intention-to-treat analysis. When there are patients with missing outcome measure data, sensitivity analysis will be performed to calculate how the results may change under different scenarios.

6.3. Statistical Analysis Plan Results will be evaluated primarily according to the intention-to-treat principle. Dropping out of follow-up will not mean dropping out of the study. The time between the time of administration of the drug used for oocyte maturation and OPU will be recorded as not occurring in accordance with the group to which the patient was randomized. Thirty minutes before and after the target (36 hours ± 30 minutes or 38 hours ± 30 minutes) will be considered to be within the protocol.

On the other hand, if for any reason, the time between drug administration-OPU does not comply with the protocol to which the patient was assigned according to the above criteria, the patient will not be excluded from the study; the time in question will be recorded in hours and minutes and included in the per-protocol analysis to be performed according to this time. Per protocol analysis will be performed according to one-hour time intervals.

Comparisons of continuous variables between groups will be made by t-test or Mann-Whitney U test according to the distribution characteristics of each variable, and comparisons of categorical variables will be made by chi-square and its derivatives.

The values of continuous variables in groups will be summarized with appropriate measures of central aggregation and dispersion, while the values of categorical variables will be expressed in absolute values and percentages.

Multivariable regression analysis will be performed for the effect of trigger-OPU time, female age, number of metaphase-2 oocytes microinjected, total number of embryos transferred on cumulative live birth.

6.3.1. Interim Analyses

Data for the primary and secondary outcome measures will be evaluated at 6-month intervals throughout the study period. The Peto-Haybittle stopping rule will be used in the interim analyses and a p < 0.01 for the primary outcome measure comparison will be required to stop the study early. The first interim analysis is planned to be performed when the first 80 patients are enrolled or 3 months later, whichever comes first.

7. SAFETY, ADVERSE EFFECTS AND RISKS Participants will be informed about the risks of the treatment and the expectation of success by providing an informed consent form for the study and an ART informed consent form.

The overall course of the study will be monitored at regular intervals by a Data and Safety Monitoring Board, including the rate of patient enrollment, compliance with the study protocol and the accumulated results. This safety board may recommend that the study be stopped early.

Study procedures are standard ART practice and no pharmaceutical agents or medical devices will be used outside of routine practice. Apart from the risks associated with ART itself, no additional medical risk or financial burden is expected to be associated with the study.

Serious adverse event(SAE) is defined as an event that causes death, threatens life, requires hospitalization or prolongs the duration of hospitalization, or causes permanent/significant incapacitation/disability. One of these is not expected to occur. A suspected unexpected serious adverse reaction(SUSAR) is defined as both an unexpected and serious adverse event. SAEs and SUSARs will be recorded and reported using SAE forms. If a SUSAR occurs, the form will be filled out immediately by the researcher and the Koç University Ethics Committee and the Data and Safety Monitoring Board will be informed immediately. The Ministry of Health will be informed within 7 days if the event is life-threatening and within 15 days if the event is not life-threatening.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Recruiting
• Enrollment: 850
• Est. completion date: December 2025
• Est. primary completion date: September 2024
• Accepts healthy volunteers: No
• Gender: Female
• Age group: 18 Years to 42 Years

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

• To undergo assisted reproductive technology (ART) treatment and planning to undergo embryo transfer procedure within 6 months of oocyte collection

• Female partner to be between 18-42 years old at the time of informed consent

• Both partners to consent to participate in the study and be legally eligible to give consent.

Exclusion Criteria:

• Female partner to have participated in the study previously.

• Female partner to have a body mass index of 35 kg/m2 or above.

• Female partner to have a systemic disease that may affect ART or pregnancy outcomes (e.g. antiphospholipid syndrome, severe liver dysfunction, diabetes mellitus, history of venous thrombosis, advanced renal or cardiac diseases).

• Presence of congenital uterine anomaly (1-Women whose uterine anomalies are surgically corrected are not excluded; 2- Arcuate uterus is not accepted as a congenital uterine anomaly).

• Presence of submucous or intramural fibroid that distorts the endometrial cavity.

• Diagnosis of stage 3 or 4 endometriosis in the female partner.

• Female partner planned to undergo double ovarian stimulation.

• Known karyotype anomaly in at least one of the partners.

• Diagnosis of azoospermia (no sperm cells in the ejaculate) in the male partner.

• History of recurrent implantation failure [defined according to the scoring system by Ata et al in 2021 available at https://bit.ly/3huVLOn (Ata B, Kalafat E, Somigliana E. A new definition of recurrent implantation failure on the basis of anticipated blastocyst aneuploidy rates across female age. Fertil Steril. 2021;116(5):1320-1327. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2021.06.045].

• History of recurrent pregnancy loss [defined as a history of 2 or more biochemical/clinical pregnancy losses, in accordance with the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology(ESHRE) Guideline on the management of recurrent pregnancy loss issued on 1 February 2023, available at https://www.eshre.eu/Guidelines-and-Legal/Guidelines/Recurrent-pregnancy-loss.aspx].

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Infertility
• IVF

Intervention

Other:
• 36-hour duration between ovulation triggering and oocyte pick-up procedure
36-hour duration between ovulation triggering and oocyte pick-up procedure
• 38-hour duration between ovulation triggering and oocyte pick-up procedure
38-hour duration between ovulation triggering and oocyte pick-up procedure

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
Turkey	Baskent University	Adana
Turkey	Ankara University	Ankara
Turkey	Hacettepe University	Ankara
Turkey	Uludag University	Bursa
Turkey	Bahceci Fulya IVF Centre	Istanbul
Turkey	Koc University	Istanbul
Turkey	VKF American Hospital	Istanbul

Sponsors (2)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
Koç University	Turkish Society of Reproductive Medicine

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Turkey, 

References & Publications (1)

Ata B, Kalafat E, Somigliana E. A new definition of recurrent implantation failure on the basis of anticipated blastocyst aneuploidy rates across female age. Fertil Steril. 2021 Nov;116(5):1320-1327. doi: 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2021.06.045. Epub 2021 Jul 28. — View Citation

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Other	Total oocyte number	Total number of oocytes after oocyte pick-up	1 day
Primary	Ratio of metaphase-2 oocytes to total number of follicles	Number of metaphase-2 oocytes / total number of follicles >10mm prior to oocyte pick-up procedure	1 day
Secondary	Maturation rate	Metaphase-2 oocyte number / total number of oocytes	2 days
Secondary	Fertilization rate	Number of two-pronuclei(2PN) embryos / number of metaphase 2 oocytes that underwent intracytoplasmic sperm injection	2 days
Secondary	Cleavage rate	Number of cleavage stage embryos/number of 2PN embryos	4 days
Secondary	Blastulation rate	Number of blastocyst stage embryos / number of 2PN embryos	7 days
Secondary	Premature ovulation rate	Number of premature ovulation cases (Defined as detection of ovulation by ultrasound prior to oocyte pick-up procedure) / number of women enrolled	1 day
Secondary	Positive Beta Human chorionic gonadotropin(Beta-hCG) test rate	Number of women with Positive serum Beta-hCG test (test will be performed 10 days after embryo transfer minimum) / total number of women enrolled	8 months
Secondary	Clinical pregnancy rate	Number of women with clinical pregnancy (defined as intrauterine pregnancy with positive fetal heart beat in transvaginal ultrasound exam) / total number of women enrolled	8 months
Secondary	Ongoing pregnancy rate	Number of women with pregnancy beyond 24th gestational week / total number of women enrolled	8 months
Secondary	Live birth rate	Number of women who deliver at least one live fetus beyond 24th gestational week / total number of women enrolled	17 months
Secondary	Miscarriage rate	Number of women negative fetal heart beat in transvaginal ultrasound exam before 24th gestational week / total number of women with clinical pregnancy	1 year
Secondary	Biochemical pregnancy rate	Number of women with no sign of pregnancy during transvaginal ultrasound exam performed after a minimum of 30 days following embryo transfer / total number of women with positive Beta-hCG test	1 year
Secondary	Ectopic pregnancy rate	Number of women with ectopic pregnancy / total number of women with positive Beta-hCG test	1 year

External Links

•   ESHRE Guideline on the management of recurrent pregnancy loss