Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

NCT number NCT05074199
Other study ID # 1195990
Secondary ID
Status Completed
Phase N/A
First received
Last updated
Start date February 26, 2018
Est. completion date September 1, 2021

Study information

Verified date September 2021
Source University of California, Davis
Contact n/a
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

The purpose of this study is to compare the cosmetic outcome of traditional straight-line (SL) linear closure to that of W plasty (a type of geometric broken-line cutaneous closure technique) for closure of post-auricular wounds resulting from harvest of full thickness skin grafts during Mohs micrographic surgery. The research team will use a split wound model, where half of the wound is repaired with a straight-line cutaneous closure and the other half is repaired with the W-plasty technique. Three-months post-surgery, the scar will be measured via the patient observer scar assessment scale (POSAS), a validated scar instrument. The scar width, and adverse events will also be recorded.


Description:

Optimizing the cosmetic appearance of surgical scars is an important element of cutaneous surgery, especially for procedures performed on conspicuous areas of the body such as the head and face. Multiple factors have been shown to affect the aesthetic outcome of scars resulting from cutaneous surgery including the amount of tension on the resultant surgical wound, suture technique and type of sutures used. The use of various wound closure techniques including linear straight-line (SL) and geometric broken-line closure techniques (Z-plasty, W-plasty) to achieve a superior cosmetic scar outcome, has been debated in the dermatology and plastic surgery literature with few studies comparing SL and broken-line closure techniques and mixed results as to which modality provides a superior cosmetic outcome [2]. A study of forehead donor site closure in in 31 undergoing a paramedian forehead flap procedure showed that W-plasty provided a superior cosmetic outcome over straight-line closure, however another study in 30 patients undergoing tempo-parietal facial flaps found that W-plasty resulted in an inferior cosmetic outcome compared to linear closure. In addition, a large national survey of over 800 lay public participants found that linear scars were perceived as more cosmetically favorable than zig-zag scars in three facial locations (temple, cheek and forehead). Currently, there are no studies comparing the two closure techniques in a split-scar design, which can ameliorate many potentially confounding individual patient factors that could affect scar outcome. Full-thickness skin grafts (FTSGs) are a commonly utilized reconstructive option in cutaneous surgery, and are typically harvested from behind the ear (postauricular) to close surgical defects on the head and face following surgical removal of both benign and malignant cutaneous tumors. This study aims to investigate whether the choice of straight-line linear closure versus a zig-zag broken line cutaneous closure technique (W-plasty) affects the cosmetic outcome of postauricular scars resulting from donor site closure following FTSG harvest. Additionally, skin lesions removed behind the ear present another opportunity to compare outcomes of these two techniques in an inconspicuous location.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Completed
Enrollment 50
Est. completion date September 1, 2021
Est. primary completion date August 31, 2021
Accepts healthy volunteers No
Gender All
Age group 18 Years and older
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria: - 18 years of age or older - Able to give informed consent themselves - Patient scheduled for cutaneous surgical procedure on the head or face for which a full thickness skin graft will be used as part of the reconstruction or has a lesion that will be excised in mastoid area of the neck, behind the ear. - Willing to return for follow up visit. Exclusion Criteria: - Wounds predicted to be less than 3 cm in size after closure. - Unable to understand written and oral English - Incarceration - Under 18 years of age - Pregnant Women

Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


Intervention

Procedure:
W-plasty/Linear closure
The patient's wound will be labeled A if it is on the left or superior side of the investigator and B if it is on the right or inferior side. A predetermined, concealed randomization number will be obtained from the RedCap randomization module, which will specify how side A is to be treated. Side B will be treated the opposite way as A. Side A will always be closed first. The side assigned to be closed in a traditional straight line (SL) will have the standing cutaneous deformity ("dog ear") excised in the standard manner using Burrow's triangles, resulting in an elliptical defect amenable to linear closure. The side assigned to be closed with W-plasty will have the dog ear excised in a zig-zag fashion consistent with the W plasty flap design. Both sides of the wound will receive subcuticular closure with interrupted subdermal sutures as is the standard of care, followed by a standard running cuticular closure with absorbable suture material.

Locations

Country Name City State
United States University of California, Davis Sacramento California

Sponsors (1)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
University of California, Davis

Country where clinical trial is conducted

United States, 

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary Patient Observer Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) scores The primary outcome is the difference in Patient Observer Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) scores between the halves of the wound (standard linear closure versus W-plasty). The POSAS instrument incorporates separate questionnaires for observers and patients. Each questionnaire contains six items with possible scores from 0-10 for a total maximum score of 60 on each component (patient and observer). 3-12 months
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT05583916 - Same Day Discharge for Video-Assisted Thoracoscopic Surgery (VATS) Lung Surgery N/A
Completed NCT04448041 - CRANE Feasibility Study: Nutritional Intervention for Patients Undergoing Cancer Surgery in Low- and Middle-Income Countries
Completed NCT03213314 - HepaT1ca: Quantifying Liver Health in Surgical Candidates for Liver Malignancies N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT05534490 - Surgery and Functionality in Older Adults N/A
Recruiting NCT04792983 - Cognition and the Immunology of Postoperative Outcomes
Terminated NCT04612491 - Pre-operative Consultation on Patient Anxiety and First-time Mohs Micrographic Surgery
Recruiting NCT06397287 - PROM Project Urology
Recruiting NCT04444544 - Quality of Life and High-Risk Abdominal Cancer Surgery
Completed NCT04204785 - Noise in the OR at Induction: Patient and Anesthesiologists Perceptions N/A
Completed NCT03432429 - Real Time Tissue Characterisation Using Mass Spectrometry REI-EXCISE iKnife Study
Completed NCT04176822 - Designing Animated Movie for Preoperative Period N/A
Recruiting NCT05370404 - Prescribing vs. Recommending Over-The-Counter (PROTECT) Analgesics for Patients With Postoperative Pain: N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT05467319 - Ferric Derisomaltose/Iron Isomaltoside and Outcomes in the Recovery of Gynecologic Oncology ERAS Phase 3
Recruiting NCT04602429 - Children's Acute Surgical Abdomen Programme
Completed NCT03124901 - Accuracy of Noninvasive Pulse Oximeter Measurement of Hemoglobin for Rainbow DCI Sensor N/A
Completed NCT04595695 - The Effect of Clear Masks in Improving Patient Relationships N/A
Recruiting NCT06103136 - Maestro 1.0 Post-Market Registry
Completed NCT05346588 - THRIVE Feasibility Trial Phase 3
Completed NCT04059328 - Novel Surgical Checklists for Gynecologic Laparoscopy in Haiti
Recruiting NCT03697278 - Monitoring Postoperative Patient-controlled Analgesia (PCA) N/A