Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

Children with speech sound disorder show diminished accuracy and intelligibility in spoken communication and may thus be perceived as less capable or intelligent than peers, with negative consequences for both socioemotional and socioeconomic outcomes. While most speech errors resolve by the late school-age years, between 2-5% of speakers exhibit residual speech errors (RSE) that persist through adolescence or even adulthood, reflecting about 6 million cases in the US. Both affected children/families and speech-language pathologists (SLPs) have highlighted the critical need for research to identify more effective forms of treatment for children with RSE. In a series of single-case experimental studies, research has found that treatment incorporating technologically enhanced sensory feedback (visual-acoustic biofeedback, ultrasound biofeedback) can improve speech in individuals with RSE who have not responded to previous intervention. Further research is needed to understand heterogeneity across individuals in the magnitude of response to biofeedback treatment. The overall objective of this proposal is to conduct clinical research that will guide the evidence-based management of RSE while also providing novel insights into the sensorimotor underpinnings of speech. The central hypothesis is that individual deficit profiles will predict relative response to visual-acoustic vs ultrasound biofeedback. From the larger population of children with RSE evaluated as part of C-RESULTS-RCT (Correcting Residual Errors With Spectral, Ultrasound, Traditional Speech Therapy Randomized Controlled Trial), a subset of 8 children will be selected who show a deficit in one domain (auditory or somatosensory) and intact perception in the other. Single-case methods will be used to test the hypothesis that sensory deficit profiles differentially predict response to visual-acoustic vs ultrasound biofeedback.


Clinical Trial Description

Single-Case Randomization Component: At the group level, speakers with RSE show poorer auditory and oral somatosensory acuity than typically developing (TD) speakers, but individuals differ in the extent to which each sensory domain is impacted. The objective of this aim is to evaluate how distinct sensory profiles mediate relative response to different types of biofeedback, with the goal of optimizing treatment through personalized learning. This study will test the working hypothesis that visual-acoustic biofeedback will produce larger gains in children whose deficit primarily affects the specification of the auditory target, while ultrasound biofeedback will produce larger gains in children with a primary somatosensory deficit. The main approach to testing this hypothesis is to select, from the larger population of children with RSE evaluated as part of C-RESULTS-RCT, a subset of 8 children who show asymmetric sensory profiles (strong auditory and weak somatosensory acuity, or vice versa). These children will be enrolled in a single-case experimental design where individual treatment sessions are randomly assigned to feature visual-acoustic or ultrasound biofeedback. Participants will complete 20 hrs of treatment (10 days, 2 sessions per day) over a 5 week period. Acoustic measures will be used to evaluate /r/ production accuracy within each session. Randomization tests will be used to evaluate differences in accuracy between ultrasound and visual-acoustic biofeedback treatment conditions. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT03736213
Study type Interventional
Source New York University
Contact
Status Completed
Phase Phase 1
Start date March 1, 2019
Completion date February 1, 2022

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT04117360 - Orthognathic Speech Pathology: Phonetic Contrasts of Patients With Dental Discrepancies Pre- and Post-Treatment Analyses
Completed NCT04625062 - Comparing Traditional and Biofeedback Telepractice Treatment for Residual Speech Errors Phase 1
Completed NCT06075303 - Dynamic Assessment of Phonological Disorders N/A
Recruiting NCT05929859 - Intensive Speech Motor Chaining Treatment for Residual Speech Sound Disorders N/A
Recruiting NCT06366256 - Simplified Ultrasound Feedback for Speech Remediation N/A
Recruiting NCT03700151 - Efficacy of an Intervention for the Children With Severe Speech Sounds Disorders N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06416306 - Treatment Targets in Spanish and English Bilingual Speech Intervention Phase 1
Withdrawn NCT03972449 - Beatboxing and Residual Speech Errors N/A
Completed NCT03538925 - Building Sentences With Preschoolers Who Use AAC Phase 2
Withdrawn NCT03006744 - Sharing Books With Children N/A
Recruiting NCT05988515 - AI-Assisted Treatment for Residual Speech Sound Disorders N/A
Recruiting NCT03737318 - Correcting Residual Errors With Spectral, Ultrasound, Traditional Speech Therapy Phase 2
Completed NCT03663972 - Age-related Correlates of Treatment for Late-acquired Sounds N/A
Completed NCT03977701 - Manipulating Linguistic Complexity to Improve Child Language Treatment Outcomes N/A
Recruiting NCT04858035 - Auditory-Perceptual Training Via Telepractice Phase 1
Recruiting NCT04858022 - Visual Acoustic Biofeedback for RSE Via Telepractice Phase 2
Withdrawn NCT03972891 - Influence - Intervention Break - Children - Speech Sound Disorders N/A
Recruiting NCT04558541 - A Developmental Framework For Linking Phonological And Morpho-syntactic Sequential Pattern Rules In DLD: Production N/A
Recruiting NCT04531514 - A Framework For Linking Sequential Pattern Rules in DLD: Perception in Toddlers N/A
Recruiting NCT04996472 - A Framework For Linking Sequential Pattern Rules in DLD: Perception in Adults N/A