Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

The OPALS Pediatric Study will examine the incremental impact of introducing a prehospital full advanced life support in pediatric patients.


Clinical Trial Description

Background: Pediatric patients constitute a significant proportion of all ambulance transports by emergency medical services (EMS) with the most common conditions being trauma, respiratory distress, and seizures. Cardiopulmonary arrest is a less common condition but has a mortality rate in children in excess of 98%. Very little evidence is available regarding the effectiveness of prehospital interventions for children. Canadian communities require guidance as to whether their local EMS services should implement full advanced life support (ALS) measures for pediatric patients. This proposal builds upon the Adult OPALS Study, the largest controlled out-of-hospital study ever conducted worldwide, which is evaluating the impact of ALS programs in multiple Ontario cities on 35,000 adult patients.

Objectives: The goal of the Pediatric OPALS Study is to evaluate the benefit of introducing a prehospital program of full ALS measures (intubation and intravenous drug therapy) on the outcomes of critically ill and injured pediatric patients. Specific objectives are to determine the impact of this ALS program on mortality, other clinical outcomes, morbidity (quality of life), EMS response intervals, and cost-effectiveness for these critical conditions: a) Respiratory distress and obstruction, b) Seizure, c) Major trauma, and d) Cardio-pulmonary arrest. We hypothesize, for each of the four patient populations separately, that in the Intervention period: i) Mortality will be reduced (primary hypothesis); ii) Other Clinical Measures will be improved for other clinical outcomes, ED interventions, admission rates, and lengths of stay; iii) Quality of Life of survivors will be improved for both generic and disease-specific measures; iv) Response Time Intervals will not be increased; and, v) Economic Evaluation will reveal that the costs and effects are distributed more favourably.

Methods: The Pediatric OPALS Study will incorporate a before-after design with the unit of study being all eligible patients seen during each of two distinct 36-month periods in 17 Ontario cities. During the baseline Control (Before) Period (1992-1998), the study cities provided BLS-D level of care with first-responder firefighters and Primary Care Paramedics. During the Intervention (After) Period (1998-2002), the study cities provided a full pre-hospital ALS program. The study population is all patients under the age of 16 years who were treated out-of-hospital for any of these four conditions: a) Respiratory Distress or Obstruction, defined as patients with a chief complaint of shortness of breath, respiratory arrest, or airway obstruction; b) Seizure, defined as patients having suffered a generalized convulsion; c) Major Trauma, defined as patients with injuries caused by any mechanism and associated with an Injury Severity Score (ISS) more than 12; d) Cardiopulmonary Arrest, defined as patients with absence of a detectable pulse, unresponsiveness, and apnea. The study intervention was implemented during the "Run-in" period, immediately prior to the Intervention period, and entails a program of pre-hospital ALS care provided by EMS: a) Endotracheal Intubation, b) Intravenous therapy, and c) Administration of intravenous drugs. Study cities had to meet four strict performance criteria. Data will be obtained by electronic or hard copy means from the following sources: Ambulance Call Reports, Fire Medical Reports, Base Hospital Reviews, Ambulance Response Information System, Hospital Records, Ontario Trauma Registry, and Follow-up Interviews. The primary outcome measure will be mortality. Secondary outcomes include a) Other Clinical Measures (Other Survival, Need for Interventions in the ED, Admission, Lengths of Stay), b) Generic Quality of Life (HUI3), c) Disease-specific Quality of Life (CPC, FIM), d) Response Time Intervals, and g) Direct Costs. The primary data analysis will test the hypothesis that mortality discharge will be improved when comparing the after period to the before period by chi-square analysis techniques. Stepwise logistic regression analysis will be performed to control for the possible confounding effects of various indicators and to assess the effect of the study period on survival. The study will involve a total of 18,000 pediatric patients over 72 months.

Importance: This proposed study has a unique opportunity to evaluate the effectiveness of ALS interventions on the outcomes of critically ill and injured patients. Never again may there be such an opportunity to conduct a controlled evaluation of the impact of an ALS program in such a large population. The results of this study will be very important to health care planners in Canada and throughout the world. ;


Study Design

Allocation: Randomized, Intervention Model: Single Group Assignment, Primary Purpose: Treatment


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT00298532
Study type Interventional
Source Ottawa Hospital Research Institute
Contact
Status Completed
Phase N/A
Start date July 1992
Completion date January 2008

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT00021866 - Developmental Effects On Children Of Women Who Take Antiepileptic Drugs During Pregnancy N/A
Completed NCT01417507 - Natural History of Brain Function, Quality of Life, and Seizure Control in Patients With Brain Tumor Who Have Undergone Surgery N/A
Completed NCT01123746 - Utility of Laboratory Testing for Children With Seizure in Emergency Department N/A
Completed NCT02926703 - Lactate Compared to Creatine Kinase as Diagnostic Marker in Generalized Epileptic Seizure N/A
Completed NCT01796574 - Ketogenic Diet for Refractory Status Epilepticus N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT01436695 - Safety and Feasibility of Using Epicall for Monitoring Pre-seizure Biomarkers N/A
Recruiting NCT05746624 - Procedural Motor Memory in Long COVID-19 N/A
Terminated NCT02883712 - Study of Predictors of Response to Anti Epilepsy in Epilepsy
Completed NCT00880204 - Evaluation of Essential Surgical Skills-Emergency Maternal and Child Health Training N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT02694094 - Impact of Ketogenic Diets on Cardiovascular Health in Adults With Epilepsy
Completed NCT02426047 - Medium Chain Triglycerides as an Adjunct to the Modified Atkins Diet for Women With Catamenial Epilepsy N/A
Completed NCT01834482 - Modified Atkins Diet Plus KetoCal for Adult Epilepsy N/A
Completed NCT01744301 - Acid Suppressing Drug Seizure Epidemiology Study N/A
Completed NCT00946751 - To Demonstrate the Relative Bioavailability of Sandoz Inc. and UCB Pharma, Inc (Keppra) 750 mg Levetiracetam Tablets In Healthy Adults Volunteers Under Fasting Conditions Phase 1
Completed NCT01694524 - Nervous System Infections Among Patients With Febrile Seizure N/A
Terminated NCT01910129 - Neurostimulation to the Vagus Nerve for the Reduction in Frequency of Seizures Associated With Epilepsy N/A
Completed NCT01982812 - A Dose-Escalation, Safety and Feasibility Study of Enteral LVT for Seizure Control in Pediatric CM Phase 2
Completed NCT01660672 - Enteral Levetiracetam For Seizure Control In Pediatric Cerebral Malaria Phase 1/Phase 2
Completed NCT00285285 - Point of Care Device Use in the Pediatric Emergency Department N/A
Completed NCT01801072 - Seizure Prophylaxis in Aneurysm Repair Phase 4