Multicenter Schroth Exercise Trial for Scoliosis

Scoliosis Clinical Trial

— MultiSETS  

Official title:

A Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial to Compare the Effect of Schroth Exercises to Standard Care on Curve Characteristics, Posture, and Quality Of Life in Adolescents With Idiopathic Scoliosis

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT01610908
• Other study ID #: Pro00043397
• Status: Completed
• Phase: N/A
• Start date: April 2011
• Est. completion date: December 30, 2020

Study information

• Verified date: May 2022
• Source: University of Alberta
• Contact: n/a
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Study type: Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

The primary aim of this multicenter randomized controlled trial is to compare the effect of a 6 month "Schroth exercise program combined with standard-of-care" to "standard-of-care alone" on scoliosis curve severity measured using the Cobb angle. Secondary aims include: 1. To determine the effect of Schroth exercises at 6 months on secondary outcomes including quality-of-life, spinal appearance, objective posture and spinal muscle endurance measurements. 2. To determine the efficacy of 6 months of Schroth therapy offered to control participants after completing 6 months in the standard-of care group (using subjects as their own controls) 3. To determine if the effects of the 6 months supervised Schroth exercise program can be maintained after supervised therapy is terminated. At Hopital Ste-Justine, the following secondary aims will be pursued to examine the preliminary evidence about the effect of Global Postural Re-education (to satisfy the local ethics committee request because Global Postural Re-education exercises were offered routinely to patients at that institution prior to the trial). A. To compare the effect and to quantify the treatment effect sizes of 6 months of "Global Postural Re-education exercises with North American standard Care consisting of only observation and bracing" to "Schroth exercises combined with North American standard care" and to "North American standard care alone" on scoliosis curve severity measured using the Cobb angle. B. To estimate the effect and quantify the treatment effect sizes of 6 months of "Global Postural Re-education exercises with North American standard Care" to "Schroth exercises combined with North American standard care" and to "North American standard care alone" on outcomes including quality-of-life, perceived spinal appearance, objective posture and spinal muscle endurance measurements. C. To determine if the effects of "Global Postural Re-education exercises with North American standard Care" can be maintained after discontinuing supervision. D. To estimate the feasibility of conducting a randomized trial focused on Global Postural Re-education exercises by quantifying enrollment rates, attendance at scheduled exercise sessions and compliance with the home exercises prescribed.

Description:

Multicenter Schroth Exercise Trial for Scoliosis (SETS study) Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis (AIS) is a progressive 3D deformity of the spine. It is the most common orthopedic condition in adolescents. Of those with curves larger than 10°, 90% are females. Scoliosis often results in chronic pain, poor posture, function, and self-image. Curves greater than 30° are braced or later surgically corrected. In Europe but not the Americas, small curves (<30°) are treated with exercises to prevent the need for bracing and moderate curves with bracing and exercises to prevent surgery. Bracing is uncomfortable and patients fear surgery. In contrast, exercises are generally well received. Schroth exercises are the most studied scoliosis exercises and have achieved very good outcomes. Schroth was the first exercise approach to offer formal certification training. No randomized controlled trial has focused on the Schroth method. Only 1 randomized controlled trial and only 3 prospective controlled studies with important methodological flaws were included in a recent review of the effect of all types of scoliosis exercises that found that exercises slowed the worsening of scoliosis. A randomized controlled trial on Schroth exercises is needed. Schroth exercises are asymmetric scoliosis-specific postural exercises and aim to improve the curve, posture, pain, function, and self-image. Schroth exercises target endurance and strength training of the abdominal, back, and leg muscles. Schroth exercises also aim to improve motor control of the posture by repeating corrective movements with progressively less feedback. Objectives: (1) To compare the effect of 6 month "of Schroth exercises combined with standard-of-care" to "standard-of-care alone" on scoliosis curve severity measured using the Cobb angle. Secondary aims include determining treatment effects on quality-of-life, spinal appearance, posture and spinal muscle endurance and monitoring if effect are maintained at long-term follow-ups. See above for objectives corresponding to the secondary analysis planned at Hopital Ste-Justine. Methodology: Participants: Two hundred fifty-eight females with AIS will be recruited for this study from our scoliosis clinic. Females 10-16 years old with curves 10° to 45°, and Risser less than or equal to 3 will be included. Patients who are planning surgery, have had surgery, worn a brace or to be discharged will be excluded. Procedures: Participants will be randomized to the standard-of-care group (observation of bracing if Boston brace criteria are met) or the Schroth exercise treatment group. (At hospital Ste-Justine, only because of the ethics committee requested we include a third trial arm, we will randomize an equal number of subjects to each of the three trial arms (Global Postural Re-education, Schroth and Standard care) using the a variable blocked randomization specific to this site. This implies recruiting an estimated additional 52 patients to be randomized to the Global Postural Re-education group.) Outcomes will be measured by evaluators blind to randomization status at baseline and at 3 and 6 month follow-ups. The primary outcome is the spinal curvature angle on radiograph at 6 months. Secondary outcomes analyzed at 3, and 6 months include radiographs (Cobb angle, rotation), Scoliosis Research Society-22r quality-of-life domain scores (self-image, function, pain), spinal appearance questionnaire domain scores, postural measures (surface topography), and Sørensen back muscle endurance. Radiographs and Scoliosis Research Society-22 measures from routine scoliosis clinic visits will also be obtained from the clinic database until discharged from routine care. Measurement properties of all measures are adequate. Standard-of-care subjects will be under observation or treated with bracing if they meet the Scoliosis Research Society bracing criteria for 6 months and then be offered the Schroth exercise treatment as a recruitment incentive necessary based on our pilot. Treated patients will receive supervised and standardized Schroth exercises combined with a home program in addition to standard of care for 6 months. Parents will be involved to enhance (and monitor) compliance. (At hôpital Ste-Justine only, one group will receive the 6-month supervised Global Postural Re-education intervention consisting of individual training sessions with a therapist combined with a home exercise program consisting of 1 or 2 exercises to perform twice weekly in addition the standard of care). Analyses: Linear mixed models will be used to assess differences in group changes from baseline, to 3 months and 6-month, and adjusting for relevant covariates (including age, and risk of progression). Expected findings: Schroth exercises will improve curve characteristics, quality of life, posture, pain, and muscular endurance in patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. The study team is integrated within the Edmonton scoliosis clinic, Montréal's Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Ste-Justine clinic and Calgary's Alberta Children Hospital Clinic. Research results can directly influence practice.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Completed
• Enrollment: 158
• Est. completion date: December 30, 2020
• Est. primary completion date: December 30, 2019
• Accepts healthy volunteers: No
• Gender: Female
• Age group: 10 Years to 16 Years

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

• adolescent idiopathic scoliosis
• Females
• 10° to 45° according to Cobb (scoliosis curve)
• with or without a brace
• ability to travel weekly to our lab
• skeletal maturity measured by Risser (0-3)

Exclusion Criteria:

• other type of scoliosis
• patients with curves > 50°
• surgical candidates
• patients who have had a corrective spinal surgery
• out-of town candidates, without possibility to travel to our lab

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Scoliosis

Intervention

Other:
• The Schroth exercises treatment
The Schroth approach consists of 3D scoliosis-specific exercises based on sensorimotor and kinesthetic principles. The goal of Schroth exercises is to teach patients to consciously maintain the correct posture in daily living activities in order to improve the curve, pain, and self-image. To achieve this goal, Schroth exercises focus on endurance and strength training of postural muscles. Schroth exercises also aim to improve posture motor control by repeating corrective movements with progressively less feedback and less passive support. Dosage: 5 individual 1-hour long sessions, continued with the daily 45 minutes home exercise program. In addition, patients are required to come weekly for 1-hour long group sessions over the span of 6 months.
• Global Postural Re-Education
The 6-month supervised Global Postural Re-education intervention involves active movements and postures aimed at realigning joints, stretching shortened muscles and enhancing the contraction of antagonist muscles, thus avoiding postural asymmetry. These postures imply an active participation of the patient. Global Postural Re-education includes eight therapeutic postures, lying, sitting or standing, held for 15/20 min. each. Variously combinations are used during sessions chosen on based on the amount of pain, load capacity, age of the patient, and muscle chains to be stretched. Static and dynamic functions are also employed for about five minutes each sessions to use the recovered flexibility in functional activities Dosage: Weekly individual 1-hour long sessions, with daily 15 minutes home exercise program over 6 months.

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
Canada	Alberta Children Hospital	Calgary	Alberta
Canada	University of Alberta, Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine, Dept. Physical Therapy	Edmonton	Alberta
Canada	CHU Ste-Justine	Montréal	Quebec

Sponsors (4)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
University of Alberta	Glenrose Foundation, Scoliosis Research Society, SickKids Foundation CIHR Institute of Human Development, Child and Youth Health

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Canada, 

References & Publications (16)

Parent EC, Ghaneei M*, Adeeb S, Schreiber S*, Moreau M, Hedden D, Hill D. (2016). Effects of Schroth exercises added to standard care in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) on marker-less surface topography asymmetry measurements: A randomized con

Parent EC, Schreiber S*, Moez EK, Preston S*, Hedden D, Moreau M, Hill D, Southon S, Watkins E*. (2016). Effects of Schroth exercises added to standard care in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) on surface topography parameters: A randomized cont

Parent EC, Schreiber S, Hedden D, Moreau M. The effect of a 6-month Schroth exercise program: a pilot study using subjects as their own controls. Scoliosis. 2013;8(Suppl 2):045.

Schreiber S**, Parent EC, Hill DL, Hedden DM, Moreau M, Southon S. (2018). How much change in the Cobb angle is needed for the patients to observe positive change in their backs following a Schroth intervention? In Abstract Book Program from XIII Internat

Schreiber S*, Parent E, Hill D, Hedden D, Moreau M, Southon S. (2017). Schroth Physiotherapeutic Scoliosis-Specific Exercises for Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis: How Many Patients Require Treatment To Prevent One Deterioration?. Book of abstracts of the

Schreiber S*, Parent E, Khodayari-Moez E, Hedden D, Hill D, Moreau M, Lou E, Watkins E*, Southon S. (2016). Schroth physiotherapeutic scoliosis-specific exercises improve Cobb angles in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis - A randomized controlled trial

Schreiber S*, Parent EC, Hedden DM, Hill DL Scoliosis and Spinal Disorders 2017 12(Suppl 1):17 O70. (2016). Minimal important differences in Scoliosis Research Society-22R, Spinal Appearance Questionnaire, Cobb angle and Biering-Sorensen back muscle endur

Schreiber S*, Parent EC, Moez EK, Hedden DM, Hill D, Moreau M, Lou E, Watkins EM*, Southon SC. (2016). The effect of Schroth exercises added to the standard of care on the Cobb angle in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis: An assessor and statistician b

Schreiber S, Parent E, Hedden D, Moreau MJ. Clinical Significance of The Effect of A Six-Months Schroth Exercise Intervention in Adolescents with Idiopathic Scoliosis. 2015 Annual Meeting Pediatric Orthopaedic Society of North America (POSNA), e-poster #1

Schreiber S, Parent E, Watkins E, Hedden D. An algorithm for determining scoliosis curve type according to Schroth. Scoliosis. 2012 Jan 27;7 Suppl 1:O53.

Schreiber S, Parent EC, Hedden DM, Moreau M, Hill D, Lou E. Effect of Schroth exercises on curve characteristics and clinical outcomes in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: protocol for a multicentre randomised controlled trial. J Physiother. 2014 Dec;60(4):234; discussion 234. doi: 10.1016/j.jphys.2014.08.005. Epub 2014 Oct 17. — View Citation

Schreiber S, Parent EC, Hedden DM, Moreau M, Hill D, Watkins EM. The effects of a 6-month Schroth intervention for Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis (AIS): preliminary analysis of an ongoing randomized controlled trial. Scoliosis. 2013;8(Suppl 2):O44.

Schreiber S, Parent EC, Hill DL, Hedden DM, Moreau MJ, Southon SC. Schroth physiotherapeutic scoliosis-specific exercises for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: how many patients require treatment to prevent one deterioration? - results from a randomized co — View Citation

Schreiber S, Parent EC, Khodayari Moez E, Hedden DM, Hill DL, Moreau M, Lou E, Watkins EM, Southon SC. Schroth Physiotherapeutic Scoliosis-Specific Exercises Added to the Standard of Care Lead to Better Cobb Angle Outcomes in Adolescents with Idiopathic Scoliosis - an Assessor and Statistician Blinded Randomized Controlled Trial. PLoS One. 2016 Dec 29;11(12):e0168746. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0168746. eCollection 2016. — View Citation

Schreiber S, Parent EC, Moez EK, Hedden DM, Hill D, Moreau MJ, Lou E, Watkins EM, Southon SC. The effect of Schroth exercises added to the standard of care on the quality of life and muscle endurance in adolescents with idiopathic scoliosis-an assessor and statistician blinded randomized controlled trial: "SOSORT 2015 Award Winner". Scoliosis. 2015 Sep 18;10:24. doi: 10.1186/s13013-015-0048-5. eCollection 2015. — View Citation

Watkins E, Bosnjak S, Parent E. Algorithms to prescribe Schroth exercises for each of four Schroth curve types. Scoliosis. 2012 Jan 27;7 Suppl 1:P22.

* Note: There are 16 references in all — Click here to view all references

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Primary	Change in Cobb angle	The angle from a posterior anterior full spine radiographs between the upper endplate of the upper end vertebra of the largest curve and the lower endplate of the lower end vertebra from the largest curve.	From baseline to 6 months
Secondary	Change in Vertebral rotation	Using a posterior-anterior radiograph and a semi-automated algorithm in Matlab the rotation of the most rotated vertebra in the curve will be extracted. The algorithm relies on the semi-automated identification of the position of the the pedicles vs the edges of the vertebral body.	Change from baseline to 6 months
Secondary	Change in Back muscle endurance	Using Sørensen back muscle endurance test, we record the time until fatigue to maintain the torso unsupported from the waist up horizontally against gravity with the arms crossed against the chest and the head and neck maintained aligned with the trunk. Leg are maintained firmly against the bed using gait belts tightened against a treatment table. The test stops if patients lose the ability to maintain the position after one reminder for good form or if they personally ask to stop because of pain or fatigue.	From baseline, to 3 months and to 6 months follow-ups
Secondary	Change in Scoliosis Research Society-22r questionnaire scores	The Scoliosis Research Society-22r questionnaire is available from SRS.org. It is a self-reported tools assessing self-image, function, pain, mental health with 5 questions each and satisfaction with care with 2 questions. A total score is also available based on all 22 questions.	From baseline, to 3 months and to 6 months follow-ups
Secondary	Change in Spinal Appearance Questionnaire scores	The Spinal Appearance Questionnaire measures patients' perception of their spinal deformity using standardized drawings and questions.; The new version of the Spinal Appearance Questionnaire containing 20 items will be used in this study, which addresses the following domains: General (items 9, 10, and 19), Curve (item 1), Prominence (items 2 and 3), Trunk shift (item 4 and 5), Waist (items 11, 12, and 13), Shoulders (items 6 and 16), Kyphosis (item 7), Chest (items 14 and 15) and Surgical scar (item 17). In scoring, we will use all domains, except Kyphosis and Surgical scar, because these domains are not relevant to the subjects in this study.	From baseline, to 3, and to 6 months
Secondary	Global rating of change relative to baseline	A 15-point global rating scale will be used to assess the patient's perceived change over time. The scale ranges from -7 (a very great deal worse) to +7 (a very great deal better).	at 3 and at 6 months
Secondary	Change in Self-efficacy	This questionnaire measures self-efficacy for overcoming barriers to physical activity (defined as corrective exercise activities) using 8 items rated from 1 (Disagree a lot) to 5 (Agree a lot).	From baseline, to 3 and to 6 months
Secondary	Change in numeric pain ratings and diagram	A scale from 0 (no pain) to 10 (worst imaginable pain) will assess current, best, worst pain intensity in the last 24 hours. A body pain diagram will help categorize the location of symptoms.	From baseline, to 3 and to 6 months
Secondary	Change in surface topography assessment of posture	Four Laser Scanners (Edmonton) and 4 optical scanners ( Montréal and Calgary) are used to capture full-torso scans. Subjects are positioned in a standard frame, and 18 reference points marked. Parameters are extracted by digitizing 15 landmarks. Parameters quantifying the external back surface deformity are: decompensation, cosmetic score (combines the shoulder angle, scapula angle and waist asymmetry), in the coronal plane, the deformity in the axial plane index, Hump Sum, trunk twist in the transverse plane and kyphotic and lumbar angles in the sagittal plane.; From full torso scans are: lateral deviation of centroid, and back surface rotation.	From baseline, to 3 and to 6 months