Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Completed
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT05667376 |
| Other study ID # |
A01031120 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Completed |
| Phase |
N/A
|
| First received |
|
| Last updated |
|
| Start date |
January 1, 2021 |
| Est. completion date |
May 30, 2021 |
Study information
| Verified date |
October 2023 |
| Source |
Mansoura University |
| Contact |
n/a |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
|
| Study type |
Interventional
|
Clinical Trial Summary
Objectives: To evaluate the efficacy of curcumin gel as an adjunct to scaling and root
planing (SRP) on the salivary procalcitonin level in the treatment of periodontitis.
Materials and methods: seventy patients (n=70) were selected from the Department of Oral
Medicine and Periodontology, Faculty of Dentistry, Mansoura University, sixteen patients
(n=16) were excluded as eight patients (n=8) weren't met the inclusion criteria, and other
eight patients were divided into (n= 4) declined to participate with (n=4) were excluded due
to pregnancy and lactation. The participants fifty -four patients were classified into three
groups: group I (healthy individuals), group II (SRP group), and group III (curcumin gel
group). Patients in groups II and III included stage II grade A periodontitis. Patients in
group II were treated with SRP only while in group III curcumin gel was applied weekly for
four weeks after SRP had been completed. Clinical indices (plaque index (PI), gingival index
(GI), clinical attachment level (CAL), and probing depth (PD)) and saliva samples for
procalcitonin (PCT) assessment using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) test were
collected and measured at baseline and again after six weeks.
Description:
Study population The randomized controlled clinical trial included fifty-four participants
selected from the Department of Oral Medicine and Periodontology Outpatient Clinic, Faculty
of Dentistry, Mansoura University from January 2021 to May 2021. Thirty-six patients with
periodontitis (stage II grade A) and eighteen healthy volunteers (negative control group)
participated in the study.
A. Inclusion criteria for patient selection: The selected patients included:
1. Participants of both sexes between the ages of thirty to fifty -five years old
2. Participants with periodontitis (stage II grade A with PD of 3-5 mm and CAL of 3-4mm).
B. Exclusion criteria included:
1. Participants with known systemic diseases
2. Pregnant and lactating participants.
3. Tobacco (smoking/chewing).
4. History of antibiotic and periodontal therapy in the last 3 months.
5. Participants who weren't compliant with oral hygiene procedures.
Study Design: The selected patients will be divided into 3 groups:
Group 1 (study group): patients are to be treated with turmeric gel as an adjunct to Scaling
and root planing.
Group 2 (positive control group): patients are to be treated with only Scaling and root
planing.
Group 3 (negative control group): patients with clinically healthy gingiva.
3) Periodontal Assessment:
All these measurements will be assessed :
1. Plaque Index according to Silness P. Loe H 1964.
2. Gingival Bleeding Index according to Ainamo & Bay 1975.
3. Probing pocket depth (PPD) is measured from the free gingival margin to the base of the
pocket.
4. Clinical attachment level (CAL) is measured from the cement enamel junction to the base
of the pocket.
For all periodontitis patients, the Clinical assessment will be performed at baseline and 45
days after periodontal treatment ( either Scaling, root planning, and injection of gel or
Scaling and root planning alone ).
This study was conducted following guidelines regulating research work on human subjects of
the Faculty of Dentistry, Mansoura University, and the study protocol was reviewed and
approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Dentistry, Mansoura University,
Egypt. (Number: A01031120).
Sample size calculation Sample size calculation was based on mean superoxide dismutase (SOD)
after treatment between the study and control group retrieved from a previous study
(Elavarasu et al., 2016). Using G*power version 3.0.10 to calculate sample size based on the
effect size of 0.828, 2-tailed test, α error =0.05, d power = 90.0% the total calculated
sample size was 18 in each group at least.
Pretreatment period Participants were informed about the purpose of the study and screened
for eligibility. They also were informed about the treatment received and the steps done,
including non-surgical treatment and gel application with the associated risks, possible
effects, and other treatment options available. The participants understood this explanation
in broad terms according to the rules of the ethical committee of the Faculty of Dentistry,
Mansoura University. Additionally, they acknowledged that they would be required to attend
the periodic recall visits and that they are legally competent to give written informed
consent before performing any required steps.
Randomization and study groups The patients with periodontitis groups were randomly selected
into either group II or III using the coin toss method. Hence the study groups were
classified into three groups as follows, group I (negative control group): eighteen subjects
with clinically healthy gingiva were selected to participate in the study as a reference
group, and group II (positive control group): eighteen patients with periodontitis (stage II
grade A) were selected and treated with non-surgical periodontal therapy (SRP) only, and
group III (study group): eighteen patients with periodontitis (stage II grade A) were
selected and treated with SRP followed by curcumin gel application.
Saliva sample collection:
Saliva sample collection was accomplished using the swabbing method. It was performed by
introducing a cotton pad into the mouth at the orifices of major salivary glands. The
subjects were asked to chew the cotton pad to get soaked in the saliva. The saliva-soaked pad
was removed and placed in a sterile test tube (sterile Eppendorf tube) and centrifuged at
3000 rounds per minute (RPM) for approximately 10 minutes and then kept frozen at -20°c till
the time of analysis.
Procedures for curcumin gel preparation:
Curcumin Gel Preparation: The gel will be prepared in the Department of Pharmacology, Faculty
of Pharmacy, Mansoura University. Preparation of 2% curcumin gel by simple dispersion method
as shown: Formula to prepare 2%curcumin gel Ingredients Quantity Carpacol 2 gm Polymer (HPMC)
2 gm Curcumin 5 ml Propylene glycol 0.2 ml Sodium benzoate q.s Triethanolamine q.s. to make
100 ml Distilled water 2g
(HPMC =hydroxy propyl methyl cellulose ; q.s.=quantity sufficient) Carbopol 940 will be
soaked in purified water containing 0.2% w/v sodium benzoate overnight. Using tissue
homogenizer hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) solution will be mixed in propylene glycol.
0. 2 mg of curcumin (Sigma, St. Lo, USA) will be transferred into HPMC solution and
homogenized. This drug solution will be transferred to a carbopol solution and homogenized.
Triethanolamine will be added in a quantity sufficient (q.s.) to neutralize the pH. Then,
distilled water will be added to make q.s. to 100 ml. The gel will be stored at ambient
temperature. The prepared gel will be tested for microbial growth by incubation for 24 hours.
If no microbial growth will be observed, the final preparation will then be transferred into
glass containers and will be stored in the refrigerator (temperature ranging from 2-10°C and
80-85% humidity)
SRP procedures:
At the beginning of treatment, the periodontitis patients were treated with SRP using both
special tipped ultrasonic scalers and manual Gracey curettes until a smooth tooth/root
surface was achieved. The SRP procedure was repeated once again (if necessary) and
instructions were given to the patients to maintain good oral hygiene measures during the
treatment period. Brushing and flossing techniques were taught to all participants using
patient education videos and demonstrated on study models. No antibiotics or mouthwashes were
prescribed during treatment. All patients were recalled weekly during the study period (which
was carried out for six weeks) for reinforcement of oral hygiene measures and curcumin gel
application inside the only selected periodontal pockets of group III as it was applied
weekly for four weeks after completing SRP.
Curcumin Gel Application:
Following SRP procedures, only selected periodontal pockets (pockets diagnosed with stage II
grade A, PD of 3-5 mm, and CAL of 3-4mm) within group III were delivered with 2% curcumin gel
sub-gingivally using a disposable 2 ml syringe with a blunt needle (bent 130° at the shank).
The application of gel was initiated from the base of the pocket to ensure the gel reached
the whole pocket depth. This was accomplished by a plastic syringe with a flexible metal
needle with a large gauge (similar to those used for acid etchant application).
This procedure continued until the pocket was filled. Care was taken to apply the gel without
traumatizing or damaging the periodontal tissues. After insertion of the curcumin gel, the
region was secured with a cotton pack, and the patients were advised not to eat or drink for
at least two hours following gel administration. They were also advised not to brush the
treated areas or floss /use interproximal cleaning devices for at least twelve hours
postoperatively and to avoid eating hard and abrasive foods that could traumatize the
gingiva. The treatment was followed-up by weekly recalls after gel application for
reinforcement of oral hygiene measurements and subsequent gel reapplication. The curcumin gel
was applied weekly for four weeks after completing SRP.
Periodontal measurements ( plaque Index (PI ), gingival index (GI), probing depth (PD), and
clinical attachment level (CAL) were recorded at baseline for all groups and again six weeks
after periodontal treatment for both group II and group III using a periodontal probe as most
studies outcomes were assessed based on either short-term effects (studies with a 2-weeks
follow-up, acceptability range ±3 days) or long-term effects (studies with a 4-weeks
follow-up, acceptability range ±3 days). Measurements were done by a blinded single examiner
(SE) who did not know the identity of the groups in which patients were included.
Intra-examiner reliability To achieve intra- examiner calibration, periodontal measurements
of 10 patients were performed twice within 2 days before randomized clinical trial (RCT)
conduction. Calibration was approved when measurements of PD and CAL in the two instances
were within a 1 mm variance in more than 90% of all measurements.
Laboratory assessment of PCT level The salivary samples were collected from all participants
at baseline and once more from both group II and group III after six weeks. The samples were
kept in sterile Eppendorf tubes, centrifuged at 3000 RPM for approximately 10 minutes, and
frozen at -20°c until the time of analysis by ELISA test to assess salivary PCT (according to
manufacturer instructions).
Statistical Assessment:
Data will be analyzed using SPSS (statistical package for social sciences) version 22.
Qualitative data will be presented as numbers and percentages, Quantitative data will be
tested for normality by the Shapiro-Wilk test and then described as mean and standard
deviation for normally distributed data and median and range for non-normally distributed.
The appropriate statistical test will be applied according to the data type with the
following suggested tests: Chi-Square for categorical variable. One Way ANOVA and
Kruskal-Wallis tests U test for continuous variables. Repeated Measures ANOVA and Freidman
tests for comparing pre, post, and follow-up readings. Pearson and spearman correlation will
be used to correlate between continuous variables
