Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

Difficulty completing everyday tasks is a primary reason for the high cost of care, loss of caregiver paid hours, and general caregiver burden associated with dementia. Electronic reminder applications hold promise as a low-cost solution to improve daily functioning, promote aging in place, and reduce caregiver burden and cost of care, particularly as older adults become more computer literate. There are many electronic reminders available for healthy individuals, but few have been developed to target the specific cognitive difficulties that impede completion of everyday tasks in people with dementia (i.e., premature decay of task goals, decreased motivation to perform tasks, distractibility, semantic knowledge degradation, etc.). Furthermore, there is a dearth of feasibility research on the fundamental efficacy and usability of reminder applications for people with dementia. This R21 proposal addresses these gaps with a feasibility study of the SmartPrompt, an enhanced electronic reminder aid designed for people with dementia that is used with an inexpensive smartphone. A diverse sample of older adults with mild dementia (N = 40) and their caregivers (N =40) will be trained to use the SmartPrompt and then asked to use the application to perform a target task (hydration, meals, or medication) twice per day in their homes for two weeks. Aim 1 will test the hypothesis that the SmartPrompt is effective at promoting everyday task completion (i.e., efficacy) relative to a one- week control period without the SmartPrompt. Using a single-group crossover design, efficacy outcomes will be obtained during the SmartPrompt and Control Conditions and will include participant and caregiver reports of task completion, caregiver report of burden, and participant report of frustration Aim 2 will investigate whether the SmartPrompt will be perceived favorably by participants and caregivers and the extent to which technical support is needed for its use (i.e., usability). Usability measures will be obtained from caregivers (report of technical problems, questionnaire), participants (questionnaire), the study team (training time, technical support required), and the smartphone (i.e., measures of smartphone use, response times to prompts). A third exploratory aim is to examine participant and caregiver features that are associated with efficacy and usability outcomes, including participant cognitive profile, participant/caregiver demographics, computer proficiency and self-efficacy, desire to change, etc. Results will be used to inform 1) a working model of barriers and facilitators for the use and efficacy of prompting applications that may be tested in future studies and 2) SmartPrompt design modifications for a future Phase II clinical trial.


Clinical Trial Description

The exorbitant health care costs associated with dementia relative to other illnesses are a significant concern in the US and other countries with aging populations. Difficulty completing everyday tasks is a primary reason for the high cost of care, loss of caregiver paid hours, and general caregiver burden. As older adults become more computer literate, assistive technologies hold promise as an inexpensive solution to improve daily functioning and ultimately promote aging in place, reduce caregiver burden, and reduce healthcare expenditures due to secondary health issues that arise when everyday tasks are neglected. Electronic reminder applications are a type of assistive technology that deliver cues to perform important daily activities (e.g., take medication). Electronic reminders are widely available, but, few of these applications have been designed specifically to 1) target the numerous cognitive difficulties that impede the recall and completion of everyday tasks in people with dementia (i.e., premature decay of task goals, decreased motivation to perform tasks, etc.); 2) circumvent the sensory/motor difficulties that older adults face when using technology (i.e., simple, user-friendly interface); and 3) be accessible at a low cost (i.e., easily integrated with consumer devices like smartphones). Additionally, there is a dearth of fundamental knowledge and quantitative data on the feasibility of electronic reminder applications for older adults with dementia. This revised R21 application (PAR-15-351/PAR-18-179) proposes a Stage I feasibility study that will address gaps in fundamental knowledge on the efficacy and usability of an electronic reminder aid for commercially available smartphones specifically designed for people with dementia. Aim 1 (efficacy): To investigate the hypothesis that a reminder application designed to target the specific cognitive impairments that preclude task completion in dementia and to circumvent sensory/motor challenges faced by many older adults (SmartPrompt) is efficacious for promoting everyday task completion. The SmartPrompt includes six features to address cognitive impairments that cause task failure in dementia: 1) reminder alert (prospective memory impairment); 2) choice to respond to reminder immediately or at a later time (distractibility); 3) instructions (semantic knowledge degradation); 4) persistent reminder until task is completed (poor monitoring); 5) activity logging via photos (episodic memory impairment); 6) gaming rewards for task completion (apathy). Diverse participants with mild dementia (N = 40) and their caregivers will be asked to track performance of a target task (medication, meals, or hydration) twice per day for two weeks. Using an AB/BA crossover design, participants will use the SmartPrompt for one of the two weeks (SmartPrompt Condition) and will perform the task as usual during the other week (Control condition; order counterbalanced across participants). Efficacy outcomes, including caregiver/participant daily logs of task completion and reports of caregiver burden and participant frustration, will be examined using repeated-measures analyses comparing the Control vs. SmartPrompt Conditions. Aim 2 (usability)- To evaluate the usability of the SmartPrompt using measures obtained from caregivers, participants with dementia, the study team, and the study smartphone. The investigators expect that the design features of the SmartPrompt will be perceived favorably by participants and will require minimal technical support from the study team and caregivers during the one-week SmartPrompt testing period. The investigators also expect that the structure and support embedded in the SmartPrompt application design will lead to favorable caregiver and participant usability ratings relative to published standards. All technical problems reported by the participant and/or caregiver will be logged and analyzed by the study team for future design modifications. Metrics obtained directly from the smartphone (e.g., response times to reminder alarms) also will be evaluated as objective measures of usability. Exploratory Aim: To examine participant and caregiver features that are associated with SmartPrompt efficacy/usability. Features of primary interest include participant sex, level of education, level and type of cognitive/functional impairment, caregiver and participant computer literacy/self-efficacy, and desire to change. The investigators will recruit a diverse older adult sample and administer measures of cognition, performance-based testing of everyday function, and questionnaires on mood/anxiety, computer literacy/proficiency/self-efficacy, and desire for behavior change. Bivariate correlations and multiple regression analyses will be performed with participant/caregiver features as predictors and efficacy/usability outcomes as the dependent variables. Results of this aim will be used to 1) develop a working framework of barriers and facilitators for the efficacy and usability of electronic reminder applications that will be tested in future studies and 2) inform modifications of the SmartPrompt training protocol and/or design for a future Phase II clinical trial. Considering the limited success of pharmaceutical treatments for dementia, there has been surprisingly little rigorous research on the potential to leverage relatively simple assistive technologies to improve daily functioning for people with dementia. Even relatively modest improvements in daily function could have a host of positive downstream effects, including increased autonomy and quality of life and improved health for people with dementia and reduced cost of care and reduced burden for caregivers. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT04313582
Study type Interventional
Source Temple University
Contact Tania Giovannetti, PhD
Phone 2152044296
Email tgio@temple.edu
Status Recruiting
Phase N/A
Start date March 13, 2020
Completion date April 1, 2023

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT05686486 - Gentle Gymnastics and Relationship Between Family Caregivers and Residents With Dementia in Nursing Homes N/A
Terminated NCT05451693 - Outreach-ER: A Dementia Care Intervention Program
Recruiting NCT05820919 - Enhancing Sleep Quality for Nursing Home Residents With Dementia - R33 Phase N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT06040294 - Dementia and Disability Simulation for College Nursing Students' Senior Activity Facilitation Skills N/A
Completed NCT05114187 - An Internet-Based Education Program for Care Partners of People Living With Dementia N/A
Recruiting NCT06322121 - Vascular Aspects in Dementia: Part 2
Active, not recruiting NCT03676881 - Longitudinal Validation of a Computerized Cognitive Battery (Cognigram) in the Diagnosis of Mild Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer's Disease
Completed NCT04426838 - Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia for the Dementia Caregiving Dyad N/A
Recruiting NCT03462485 - Pilot Study of the Effects of Playing Golf on People With Dementia N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT03677284 - Managing Time With Dementia: Effects of Time Assistive Products in People With Dementia N/A
Completed NCT03849937 - Changing Talk Online (CHATO) Study N/A
Recruiting NCT06284213 - Biomarkers for Vascular Contributions to Cognitive Impairment and Dementia Consortium
Recruiting NCT05579236 - Cortical Disarray Measurement in Mild Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer's Disease
Completed NCT05080777 - Pilot Pragmatic Clinical Trial to Embed Tele-Savvy Into Health Care Systems N/A
Completed NCT04571697 - A Study of Comparing Rates of Dementia and Alzheimer's Disease in Participants Initiating Methotrexate Versus Those Initiating Anti-tumor Necrosis Factor (TNF)-Alpha Therapy
Completed NCT03583879 - Using Gait Robotics to Improve Symptoms of Parkinson's Disease N/A
Recruiting NCT06033066 - Financial Incentives and Recruitment to the APT Webstudy N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT05204940 - Longitudinal Observational Biomarker Study
Recruiting NCT05684783 - Dementia Champions in Homecare
Completed NCT03147222 - Function Focused Care: Fracture Care at Home N/A