Heat Stress Clinical Trial
Official title:
Limiting Factors for Wearing Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) in a Health Care Environment Evaluated in a Randomised Study: Source of Errors?
Pandemics and re-emerging diseases put pressure on the health care system to prepare for patient care and sample logistics requiring enhanced personnel protective equipment (PPE) for health care workers. We generated quantifiable data on ergonomics of PPE applicable in a health care setting by defining error rates and physically limiting factors due to PPE-induced restrictions. Nineteen study volunteers tested randomly allocated head- or full body-ventilated PPE suits equipped with powered-air-purifying-respirators and performed four different tests (two laboratory tutorials, a timed test of selective attention and a test investigating reaction time, mobility, speed and physical exercise) during 6 working hours at 22°C on one day and 4 working hours at 28°C on another day. Error rates and physical parameters (fluid loss, body temperature, heart rate) were determined and ergonomic-related parameters were assessed hourly using questionnaires. Depending on the PPE system the most restrictive factors were: reduced dexterity due to multiple glove layers, impaired visibility by flexible face shields and back pain related to the respirator of the fully ventilated suit. Heat stress and liquid loss were perceived as restrictive at a working temperature of 28°C but not 22°C.
In this randomized study following good clinical practice guidelines nineteen study
volunteers were recruited to wear one of two different types of randomly allocated PPE suits
(www.randomizer.at) and to perform four different tests six times at 22°C on one day and
four times at 28°C on another day in the local core facility clinical research center.
Study participants Recruiting was based on voluntary registration in response to a public
announcement. The study was subjected to the local ethical committee review (No. 23-321 ex
10/11) and all persons gave written informed consent according to the Helsinki Declaration.
Key lifestyle and medical parameters were documented for every subject. Exclusion criteria
were pregnancy, latex and polyvinyl chloride allergy, claustrophobia, hypotension, history
of vein thrombosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, epilepsy, cardiovascular and
pulmonary diseases, and infectious diseases. Ten male and nine female volunteers were
recruited, aged between 21 and 38 years with body-mass-indices from 17.2 to 32.5.
PPE suits Suit A: TychemR F overall whole-body (DuPont de Nemours and Company, 3M, Austria)
suit including socks with a reusable light hood VersafloTM S-655 (3M, Austria) and an
external 3M JupiterTM Powered Air Turbo Unit (3M Austria) providing head-only positive
pressure.
Suit B: 3MTM JS-series Typ 3 Chemical and Respiratory Protective Suit (CRPS, 3M, Austria)
with integrated respirator 3M Jupiter JP-ER-03 Powered Air Purifying Turbo (3M, Austria)
fixed as a rucksack generating whole-suit positive pressure.
With both suits, Sempercare surgical gloves (Sempermed, powder-free 150; Semperit, Austria)
as the first layer, Ansell Sol-Vex gloves 37-900 (Ansell, Medical GBU, VWR, Austria) as a
second layer and white rubber boots were worn. Gloves and boots were sealed to the suit
using adhesive tape. Tests I and II were performed in a mock-up glove box providing a third
layer of latex gloves.
Tests Four tests were repeatedly performed as well as an additional questionnaire on comfort
and general condition before the tests started and after every four-test-series. Test I
comprised correct assembly and position of coloured and numbered 2 mL tubes and screwcaps in
a storage device to test fine motor skills, concentration and error rate. Test II checked
the same skills in a different approach by pipetting different volumes of coloured water
into a 96-well microliter plate according to a given pattern. Test III "d2 Test of
Attention" is a timed test of selective attention and a standardized refinement of a visual
cancellation. In response to the discrimination of similar visual stimuli, the test measures
processing speed, rule compliance, and quality of performance, allowing estimation of
individual attention and concentration performance. Test IV investigated reaction time,
mobility, speed and physical exercise by tapping touch sensors directed by signs on a screen
(tapping test by talent-systems sportconsulting Gmbh, www.werthner.at). All subjects
performed the tests after randomisation (www.randomizer.at) of the starting exercise. For
example, subject one started with test I while subject two started with test II at the same
time. After ten minutes testing time and a five minute break, subject one carried on with
test II and subject two with test I. After a five minute break, subject one started with
test III while subject two performed test IV over a 10 minute period. Again after five
minutes break, subject one continued with test IV and subject two with test III. Subjects
documented their individual comfort and general condition in a structured questionnaire
before the tests started and after every series of tests. All four tests were repeated 6
times at 22°C (6 hours total working time) on the first test day and four times at 28°C (4
hours total working time) on the second test day. Limiting factors for working conditions
were ranked after every series from 1 to 10 on the questionnaire whereby ranking 10 was a
reason for terminating the study. Heart rate (HR) was measured with a wireless heart rate
monitor placed below the sternum directly on the skin (Garmin Forerunner 305) before and
after the test series (data used for statistical analysis) and additionally recorded during
the test series. Body temperature and body weight were measured as well as weight of the
respective PPE for calculating dehydration and evaluation of heat stress.
;
Allocation: Randomized, Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment, Masking: Open Label
Status | Clinical Trial | Phase | |
---|---|---|---|
Completed |
NCT05092854 -
The Effect of AMP Human Sodium Bicarbonate Lotion on Dehydrated Heat Stress
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT05601713 -
Mitigating Heat-induced Physiological Strain and Discomfort in Older Adults Via Lower Limb Immersion and Neck Cooling
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT05678738 -
Acquiring and Targeting Heat Exposures Necessary for Action
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT04985292 -
Does Probiotic Supplementation Prevent Kidney Injury During Strenuous Physical Exercise?
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT04650776 -
Non-invasive Prediction of Thermal Strain in Healthy Male Adults
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT06084494 -
Validation of Heat Stress Limit Values for the Athletic Performance
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT05622188 -
The Detection of Heat Stress by Assessing Individual Body Responses to Heat (Heat Strain) in Young and Healthy Non-athlete Participants
|
||
Completed |
NCT03815708 -
Heat Stress in Wheelchair Sports
|
||
Not yet recruiting |
NCT06389604 -
Preparing for Heat Waves - Enhancing Human Thermophysiological Resilience
|
N/A | |
Not yet recruiting |
NCT05274009 -
Protective Cooling Measures to Safeguard Elderly People From Dangerous Summer Heat
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT05753254 -
Effect on Markers of Cardiovascular, Reproductive and Cancer Risk From Firefighting Training
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT06442969 -
Implementing an Intervention to Reduce Heat Stress and Chemical Exposures
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT05921864 -
Study of Biomarkers of Heat Tolerance and Recovery During Ultra-endurance Exercise
|
||
Completed |
NCT04348630 -
Establishing Evidence-based Indoor Temperature Thresholds to Protect Health
|
N/A | |
Not yet recruiting |
NCT06442956 -
Effect of Rapid Heat Stress on Firefighters Musculoskeletal Injury Risk
|
N/A | |
Not yet recruiting |
NCT03234270 -
Changes in Aviators' Body Core Temperature Measurements at F-35
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT05963529 -
Validity of Humidity Ramp Protocols for Identifying Limits of Survivability in Heat-exposed Persons
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT05600452 -
Comparison of a Novel Condensed Heat Acclimation Programme With a Traditional Longer-term Heat Acclimation Programme
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT04353076 -
Physiological Responses in Young and Older Adults During a Prolonged Simulated Heatwave
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT04160741 -
Effects of Solar Radiation on Human Function and Cognition
|
N/A |