Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

The radial forearm free flap (RFFF) is widely used in head and neck reconstruction. Its thinness, pliability, pedicle length, and vessel size are particularly suited for oropharyngeal and oral cavity reconstruction. Concerns about aesthetic and functional morbidity at the donor site have given rise to various techniques of closing the donor site, two of which are the split-thickness skin graft (STSG), taken from the thigh, and the hatchet flap, which uses a local flap within the radial forearm. This RCT will determine whether retrospectively reported improvements to aesthetic and functional outcomes for STSG patients are greater compared to hatchet flap patients.


Clinical Trial Description

The radial forearm free flap (RFFF), introduced by Yang et al. in 1981, is widely used in head and neck reconstruction. Its thinness, pliability, pedicle length, and vessel size are particularly suited for oropharyngeal and oral cavity reconstruction. Since the survival rate of the RFFF has reached more than 95%, the clinical focus has gradually shifted to the postoperative quality of life, particularly in terms of donor site morbidity. Concerns about aesthetic and functional morbidity at the donor site have given rise to various techniques of closing the donor site of a RFFF. Many possibilities of donor site closures have been described, ranging from direct closure to skin grafting, tissue expansion, use of acellular dermal matrix and local flaps. Each of these techniques has its own advantages and drawbacks and the debate regarding the optimal method for closing the RFFF donor site continues. Split-thickness skin graft (STSG) is a very thin strip of skin that is typically taken from the upper thigh and is the most commonly used method to cover the forearm after taking the RFFF. Advantages of this technique include reducing the amount of tension that is on the forearm which may lead to a better scar and better mobility while disadvantages include the need of an additional scar on the thigh and possible mismatch of the color of the skin graft when compared to the forearm. Due to these potential limitations, surgeons have attempted to close the forearm directly by means of local flaps, which use nearby skin, soft tissue, and blood vessels to cover the forearm. The hatchet flap is a triangular local rotation flap, first described by Emmet in 1977, with a greater or lesser degree of advancement and with a back cut at the base of the flap through which it derives its vascular supply. This method may allow for quicker wound healing by primary intention and improved coverage of the tendons which should theoretically decrease donor site morbidity; however, since only tissue from the forearm is used this may lead to increased tension and therefore increased scar formation. Risks and complications for both types of closure are the same which include bleeding, infection, hypertrophic scars, tendon exposure, divot formation, irregular skin graft surface, prolonged wound healing, and loss of skin graft. There are only a few studies on the functional and visual outcomes of forearm closure after RFFF removal using the hatchet flap or similar local flaps, warranting the need for further studies on these closure techniques. It is hypothesized that donor site closure using the STSG flap will result in greater functional and aesthetic outcomes for the radial forearm donor site as measured by an improved scores to the 3 given questionnaires. Post-operative complication rates are also hypothesized to be lower for STSG flap closure when compared to hatchet flap closure. The literature currently remains in a state of clinical equipoise, and at the study site (Vancouver General Hospital) the STSG and hatchet flap are the two most common methods of donor site closure. Based on a retrospective data analysis at the study site, functional and patient-reported scar aesthetic outcomes were improved for STSG flap closure patients when compared to hatchet flap patients. As a retrospective analysis, objective assessments of the scar could not be performed, nor could the immediate post-operative outcomes be taken and compared over a consistent post-operative time frame schedule. This study aims to address this knowledge gap by conducting a parallel-group randomized controlled trial for the study site's two common donor site closure techniques, STSG and hatchet flap. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT05740033
Study type Interventional
Source University of British Columbia
Contact Eitan Prisman, MD, FRCSC
Phone 6048754126
Email eitan.prisman@ubc.ca
Status Recruiting
Phase N/A
Start date February 1, 2023
Completion date December 2024

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT06031337 - Salivary Expression of SOX7 in Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma: Diagnostic Accuracy Study
Completed NCT00158678 - IMRT Plus Cisplatin Versus Conventional Radiotherapy Plus Cisplatin in Stage III-IV HNSCC Phase 3
Completed NCT00933387 - A Study of Neoadjuvant Bio-C/T Followed by Concurrent Bio-R/T in High-risk Locally Advanced Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma Phase 2
Enrolling by invitation NCT05030597 - Exploring the Application Value of PET Molecular Imaging Targeting FAP in Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma N/A
Completed NCT03682562 - Diagnostic Accuracy of Salivary DNA Integrity Index in Oral Malignant and Premalignant Lesions
Recruiting NCT03684707 - Cancer Chemoprevention by Metformin Hydrochloride Compared to Placebo in Oral Potentially Malignant Lesions Phase 4
Recruiting NCT06130332 - Neoadjuvant Tirellizumab Combined With Chemotherapy for Early Oral Squamous Cell Carcinoma(HNC-SYSU-004) Phase 2
Recruiting NCT04372914 - Prevention of Oral DNA Damage by Black Raspberries N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT03529422 - Durvalumab With Radiotherapy for Adjuvant Treatment of Intermediate Risk SCCHN Phase 2
Recruiting NCT03686020 - Sensitivity and Specificity of Serum and Salivary CYFRA21-1 in the Detection of Malignant Transformation in Oral Potentially Malignant Mucosal Lesions (Diagnostic Accuracy Study)
Not yet recruiting NCT06060288 - Diagnostic Accuracy of Mobile Phone Imaging Compared to Conventional Clinical Examination for Oral Cancer Screening
Withdrawn NCT00951470 - Complete Decongestive Therapy (CDT) for Treatment of Head and Neck Lymphedema N/A
Completed NCT00964977 - Effectiveness of Adjuvant Radiotherapy in Small Oropharyngeal Squamous Cell Cancer and Single Lymph Node Metastasis. Phase 3
Completed NCT01418118 - Assessment of the Effects of Pressors on Graft Blood Flow After Free Tissue Transfer Surgery Phase 4
Active, not recruiting NCT00232960 - Postoperative Radiotherapy According to Molecular Analysis of Surgical Margins of Oral and Oropharyngeal SCC N/A
Recruiting NCT05429099 - Mandibular Reconstruction Preplanning (ViPMR) Phase 2/Phase 3
Completed NCT04614896 - Use of Ultrasound for Measuring Size of Oral Tongue Cancers N/A
Recruiting NCT03685409 - Cancer Chemoprevention by Metformin Hydrochloride in Oral Potentially Malignant Lesions Phase 3
Completed NCT00402779 - Erlotinib Prevention of Oral Cancer (EPOC) Phase 3
Recruiting NCT05153733 - Improved Implant for Reconstruction Purposes After Mandibular Resection N/A