Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Recruiting

Administrative data

NCT number NCT05917574
Other study ID # UH:02990
Secondary ID
Status Recruiting
Phase
First received
Last updated
Start date June 14, 2023
Est. completion date April 30, 2025

Study information

Verified date December 2023
Source University of Hertfordshire
Contact Natalie A Pattison
Phone 07543220056
Email n.pattison@herts.ac.uk
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Observational

Clinical Trial Summary

Background: Staffing in intensive care units (ICU) has been in the spotlight since the pandemic. Having enough nurses to deliver safe, quality care in ICU is important. However, what the skill mix should be (how many should be qualified nurses or have an ICU qualification) is unclear. Very little research has been done to look at which nursing staff combinations and mix of skills works best in ICU to support patients (described as 'staffing models').Research shows that there is a link between the quality of nurse staffing and poor patient outcomes, including deaths. Aim: Our research plans to look at different staffing models across the UK. This study aims to examine new staffing models in ICU across six very different Trusts. This study will use a research technique called Realist Evaluation that examines what works best in different situations and help to understand why some things work for some people and not others. The design of this approach will help to better understand the use of different staff ratios across different ICU settings. This study will examine what combinations of staff numbers and skills result in better patient care and improved survival rates. The aim is to produce a template that every ICU unit can use. To do this, this study will compare staffing levels with how well patients recover, and seek to understand the decisions behind staffing combinations. Methods: This study will: 1. carry out a national survey to understand the different staff models being used, comparing this against the current national standard (n=294 ICUs in the UK including Scotland) 2. observe how people at work in 6 hospitals (called ethnography), watching how they make decisions around staffing and the effect on patients. The investigators will also conduct interviews (30 interviews plus 30 ethnographic observations) to understand staffing decisions. 3. look at ICU staffing patterns and models, and linked patient outcomes (such as whether people survive ICU) over 3 years (2019-2023) in those hospitals, including with a very different combination of staffing). The investigators will then carry out some mathematical calculations to understand the best possible staffing combinations, and how this varies.


Description:

Background: Optimising deployment of the scarce nursing workforce in the intensive care unit (ICU) is paramount for patient safety, and staff wellbeing. ICU staffing models are determined by National Health Service (NHS) service specification, with 1:1 patient to registered nurse (RN) ratios for the highest acuity patients. A rapid expansion of ICU capacity during COVID19 led to adoption of alternative models, using more support staff, non-ICU qualified nurses and other professionals, reaching up to 70% at surge. The strengths, weaknesses, costs and effects of these models, and benefits of retaining them, remain uncertain. Lower nurse-staffing levels, and high workload, have been associated with adverse outcomes for patients, staff and organisations although ICU-specific evidence is limited. Studies focus on levels of RNs, contributing little to understanding consequences of changes retained post-COVID, or to guiding adoption of alternative staffing models. It is unclear how changes in staffing or specific models affect various outcomes. Aim: To identify the key components of an optimal nurse staffing model for deployment in ICU. Objectives/Methods: Guided by a realist framework, the investigators propose to interlink workstreams (WS) over 2 years to allow cross-fertilisation of ideas/hypotheses and inform emerging programme theories. 1. To identify and describe organisation of models, exploring intended mechanisms and outcomes for how different models work, the investigators will conduct: - a UK survey (WS 1) of all 294 ICUs in England/Wales/Northern Ireland (NI)/Scotland that will identify staffing models emerging/retained since COVID19, compared with United Kingdom (UK) service specifications. - a realist evaluation (WS 2, cross-cutting workstream) and detailed case studies involving six sites, and 30-40 interviews with: nurses/senior nurses; organisational leads; critical care network managers/commissioners; families/patients, to test emerging programme theories. Rapid ethnographies (n=30), will elucidate how staffing decisions are made. 2. To provide estimates of variability in demand for nursing staff and estimate associations between staffing patterns and patient outcomes, the investigators will: - use administrative e-roster (nurse staffing roster) data and patient data (WS 3) from the Intensive Care National Audit and Research Centre Case Mix Programme (2019-2023) to assess whether and how patient/staff outcomes vary with differing staff models between units/case study sites. 3. To develop simulation models to show the impact of models on capacity, cost and patient flow, the investigators will use simulation modelling (WS 4) to explore scenarios for different staffing policies given case mixes of case study units, swiftly and with no patient impact. Analysis: Data integration occurs across all workstreams in WS 5. Theories developed from WS2 case studies will be further tested against WS 3 observational data and inform WS 4 mathematical simulation models of ICU capacity, patient outcomes and patient flow, to inform emerging propositions for the realist evaluation programme theories as context-mechanism-outcome configurations.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Recruiting
Enrollment 80
Est. completion date April 30, 2025
Est. primary completion date January 30, 2025
Accepts healthy volunteers No
Gender All
Age group 18 Years and older
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria: Interviews with nursing staff - Registered Nurses who have worked in ICU for at least six months. Inclusion criteria: Interviews with nurse managers - Clinically-based nurse managers who have worked in ICU for at least one year. Inclusion criteria: Interviews with organisational leads - Organisational leads who have been working in their role and in the ICU field for at least one year. Inclusion criteria: Interviews with regional managers/commissioners • Regional managers/commissioners who have been working in their role and in the ICU field for at least one year. Inclusion criteria: Interviews with patients/families - Patient or family member over 18 years old. - Patients who have been in General ICU for at least 48 hours in the last 6 months. - Family members who have visited ICU for at least 20 mins on two days in the preceding 6 months. - Patient discharged from hospital at least 2 weeks prior to the interview. - Patient expected to be well enough, after hospital discharge, to attend the interview and to have capacity to consent. Exclusion Criteria: -

Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


Intervention

Other:
n/a (non-interventional)
Non-interventional (Realist Evaluation study)

Locations

Country Name City State
United Kingdom East and North Hertfordshire NHS Trust, Lister Hospital Stevenage

Sponsors (7)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
University of Hertfordshire Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, Intensive Care National Audit & Research Centre, London South Bank University, University of Exeter, University of Plymouth, University of Southampton

Country where clinical trial is conducted

United Kingdom, 

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary Death from all causes within 30 days of ICU admission Mortality 2019-2023
Secondary Discounted Quality-adjusted Life Year (QALYs) Quality-adjusted Life Years (QALYs) 2019-2023
Secondary Composite death/discharge to long term-care (LTC) Death/discharge to LTC 2019-2023
Secondary ICU-acquired infection ICU-acquired infection 2019-2023
Secondary Days of organ support in ICU Days of organ support in ICU (per organ) 2019-2023
Secondary Cost of ICU stay Cost of ICU and post-ICU stay (in hospital) 2019-2023
Secondary Staff absence Sickness and absence (and associated costs) 2019-2023
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT04551508 - Delirium Screening 3 Methods Study
Recruiting NCT06037928 - Plasma Sodium and Sodium Administration in the ICU
Completed NCT03671447 - Enhanced Recovery After Intensive Care (ERIC) N/A
Recruiting NCT03941002 - Continuous Evaluation of Diaphragm Function N/A
Recruiting NCT04674657 - Does Extra-Corporeal Membrane Oxygenation Alter Antiinfectives Therapy Pharmacokinetics in Critically Ill Patients
Completed NCT04239209 - Effect of Intensivist Communication on Surrogate Prognosis Interpretation N/A
Completed NCT05531305 - Longitudinal Changes in Muscle Mass After Intensive Care N/A
Terminated NCT03335124 - The Effect of Vitamin C, Thiamine and Hydrocortisone on Clinical Course and Outcome in Patients With Severe Sepsis and Septic Shock Phase 4
Completed NCT02916004 - The Use of Nociception Flexion Reflex and Pupillary Dilatation Reflex in ICU Patients. N/A
Recruiting NCT05883137 - High-flow Nasal Oxygenation for Apnoeic Oxygenation During Intubation of the Critically Ill
Completed NCT04479254 - The Impact of IC-Guided Feeding Protocol on Clinical Outcomes in Critically Ill Patients (The IC-Study) N/A
Recruiting NCT04475666 - Replacing Protein Via Enteral Nutrition in Critically Ill Patients N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT04516395 - Optimizing Antibiotic Dosing Regimens for the Treatment of Infection Caused by Carbapenem Resistant Enterobacteriaceae N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT04538469 - Absent Visitors: The Wider Implications of COVID-19 on Non-COVID Cardiothoracic ICU Patients, Relatives and Staff
Withdrawn NCT04043091 - Coronary Angiography in Critically Ill Patients With Type II Myocardial Infarction N/A
Recruiting NCT02989051 - Fluid Restriction Keeps Children Dry Phase 2/Phase 3
Recruiting NCT02922998 - CD64 and Antibiotics in Human Sepsis N/A
Completed NCT03048487 - Protein Consumption in Critically Ill Patients
Completed NCT02899208 - Can an Actigraph be Used to Predict Physical Function in Intensive Care Patients? N/A
Recruiting NCT02163109 - Oxygen Consumption in Critical Illness