Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

This study seeks to test a web-based decision support tool developed to enhance low-income women's ability to make informed decisions about tubal sterilization that align with their preferences, values and reproductive goals. Half of participants will receive usual care, while the other half will use the web-based decision aid plus usual care. The investigators hypothesize that compared to women who receive usual care alone, women randomized to the decision aid arm will have greater knowledge about sterilization and alternative options, lower decisional conflict, and will be more satisfied with their contraceptive decision at 3-month follow-up.


Clinical Trial Description

Female surgical sterilization is the second most commonly used contraceptive method in the US and is disproportionately used by low-income women and women of color. Whether the higher use of sterilization in these populations reflects inappropriate overutilization is unclear. On one hand, low-income and racial minority women frequently misunderstand the permanent nature of sterilization, are often unaware of reversible contraceptive alternatives, and commonly experience regret after the procedure- suggesting suboptimal decision making. On the other hand, there is evidence of substantial unmet demand for sterilization among low-income women, due to unique access barriers posed by Medicaid sterilization regulations, putting them at high risk for unintended pregnancy and the adverse health and social consequences associated with unintended pregnancy. Medicaid sterilization policy currently requires that all women requesting a federally-funded procedure complete a standardized consent form at least 30 days prior to sterilization. This policy was originally instituted in the 1970s to protect vulnerable women from coercive sterilization practices by attempting to ensure informed and voluntary consent. However, there is growing consensus that the policy is incapable of ensuring informed consent, and that the mandatory 30-waiting period impedes access to desired sterilization for many low-income women. The lack of a process that can ensure both informed consent and timely access for sterilization procedures hampers progress toward reproductive health equity for low-income women. This study seeks to test a novel, web-based decision support tool to support low-income women's ability to make informed and value-concordant decisions about surgical sterilization. A decision support tool may be particularly useful in the context of sterilization decisions because this is a preference-sensitive decision with permanent implications and because there is a high level of misunderstanding about sterilization and limited awareness of alternative options among women who have undergone the surgery, indicating critical gaps in the quality of pre-sterilization counseling. Furthermore, patient-provider interactions may be complicated by a broader social and historical context in which poor and minority women's reproductive choices have not always been valued. The study is a multi-site randomized controlled trial to test the effect of the decision aid plus usual care compared to usual care alone on decision quality among 350 racially-diverse, low-income pregnant women considering a post-partum sterilization procedure. Participant surveys will be utilized at three assessments points to evaluate outcomes. In addition to its potential clinical utility, this research also has important policy implications, as it can inform ongoing efforts to transform the current Medicaid policy by offering a decision aid that is able to ensure informed decision making in vulnerable populations, thereby allowing the investigators to ultimately replace the current Medicaid consent form with this scalable tool. Once there is a tool to safeguard women with an evidence-based process for ensuring informed consent, further progress can be made in potentially shortening or waiving the mandatory 30-day waiting period that has restricted access to desired sterilization for many low-income women. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT04097717
Study type Interventional
Source University of Pittsburgh
Contact
Status Completed
Phase N/A
Start date February 24, 2020
Completion date April 30, 2024

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT02577601 - Impact of Combined Hormonal Contraceptives on UPA Phase 4
Completed NCT03153644 - Improving Contraceptive Care for Women With Medical Conditions
Completed NCT04112095 - Adherence With Continuous-dose Oral Contraceptive: Evaluation of Self-Selection and Use Phase 3
Recruiting NCT05521646 - Implementing Best Practice Postpartum Contraceptive Services Through a Quality Improvement Initiative N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT04291001 - Ovarian Function With ENG Implant and UPA Use Early Phase 1
Completed NCT04568980 - Assessment of Contraceptive Safety and Effectiveness in Cystic Fibrosis
Completed NCT03438682 - Real World Effectiveness and Safety of Hysteroscopic (Essure®) Compared to Laparoscopic Sterilization
Active, not recruiting NCT01948882 - Evaluation of Safety and Effectiveness of the Essure (Model ESS505) Device to Prevent Pregnancy in Women N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT04997499 - Adolescent Subcutaneous (SQ) Injection Video Validation N/A
Recruiting NCT03589040 - Darunavir and Rilpivirine Interactions With Etonogestrel Contraceptive Implant Phase 2
Completed NCT04463680 - Rifampin and the Contraceptive Implant Phase 4
Completed NCT03154125 - Sayana® Press Extension Study Phase 3
Withdrawn NCT03725358 - A Cluster-RCT to Increase the Uptake of LARCs Among Adolescent Females and Young Women in Cameroon. N/A
Completed NCT02957630 - "E4/DRSP Endocrine Function, Metabolic Control and Hemostasis Study" Phase 1/Phase 2
Completed NCT02456584 - Pharmacodynamics and Pharmacokinetics Study of Existing DMPA Contraceptive Methods Phase 1
Completed NCT02718222 - Impact and Performance of Institutionalizing Immediate Post-partum IUD Services N/A
Recruiting NCT02121067 - LNG-IUS at 2 Weeks Postpartum Phase 4
Terminated NCT02169869 - Immediate Postplacental IUD Insertion N/A
Recruiting NCT02292056 - Medication Safety and Contraceptive Counseling for Reproductive Aged Women With Psychiatric Conditions N/A
Withdrawn NCT01930994 - Kenya Sino-implant (II) PK Study N/A