Motivational, Affective and Performance Effects of Caffeine Supplementation

Caffeine Clinical Trial

Official title:

The Effects of Caffeine Supplementation on Motivation, Affect and Performance in Physical Exercise Tests: An Intervention Study

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Recruiting

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT06321861
• Other study ID #: Caffeine_motivation
• Status: Recruiting
• Phase: N/A
• Start date: January 19, 2024
• Est. completion date: May 1, 2024

Study information

• Verified date: March 2024
• Source: Jagiellonian University
• Contact: Ewa Szumowska
• Phone: +48504756394
• Email: ewa.szumowska[@]uj.edu.pl
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Study type: Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

The main objective of the study is to evaluate the influence of caffeine intake on participants' energetic arousal, affect, motivation to achieve a training goal, satisfaction with training, and the sense of agency during training. Consequently, participants will engage in three sessions: caffeine, placebo, and no substance (in counterbalanced order). During each session, their affective and motivational states will be assessed, along with the performance of a standardized physical exercise test. The investigators hypothesize that participants who consume caffeine (caffeine condition) will exhibit higher levels of energy and motivation compared to the other two groups. Additionally, they are expected to experience greater optimism and expectancy regarding their training goals and achieve better results in the physical exercise test.

A secondary aim of the study is to examine the impact of genetic variability on motivational and affective states of participants, as well as their performance in the physical exercise test after caffeine. The investigators will assess the CYP1A2 (-163C > A, rs762551; characterized such as "fast" (AA genotype) and "slow" caffeine metabolizers (C-carriers)) and ADORA2A (1976T > C; rs5751876; characterized by "high" (TT genotype) or "low" sensitivity to caffeine (C-carriers)).

Description:

Before participating in the study, participants will answer questions regarding their consumption of caffeinated beverages and the frequency of their workouts. They will also complete the Extreme Personality Scale measuring the tendency to pursue goals single-mindedly. Subsequently, they will be qualified for the study based on the questionnaire results and a brief interview.

The study will involve the manipulation of energization through the administration of caffeine. Participants will take part in a randomized, crossover, double-blind study, where they will perform three identical training sessions after consuming: a) caffeine at a dose of 3 mg/kg of body weight; b) a placebo; and c) under control conditions (i.e., without substance administration). Capsule consumption will occur 60 minutes before the start of the training. Caffeine and placebo capsules will not differ in size, shape, color, and taste.

As the effectiveness of caffeine use depends on the CYP1A2 (rs762551) and ADORA2 (rs5751876) gene polymorphisms, the study will also genotype these genes. The first gene is responsible for the rate of caffeine metabolism, determining whether people metabolize caffeine "fast" or "slow." The ADORA2A gene, encoding the adenosine A2A receptor, influences how "sensitive" people are to caffeine. DNA isolates obtained from oral epithelial cells collected from participants by qualified medical personnel will constitute the research material. Oral epithelial swabs will be collected directly from the participants into sterile tubes.

Before and after substance intake (and additionally after the exercise test) participants will assess their arousal using the University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology Mood Adjective Checklist. Additionally, after substance intake and before exercise, participants will answer questions about motivation, affect and expectancy regarding training. Subsequently, participants will undergo training, taking the form of a supervised standardized exercise test. After exercise, participants will assess their satisfaction and feelings after completing the training.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Recruiting
• Enrollment: 40
• Est. completion date: May 1, 2024
• Est. primary completion date: May 1, 2024
• Accepts healthy volunteers: Accepts Healthy Volunteers
• Gender: All
• Age group: 18 Years to 30 Years

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

• Age 18-30 years

• Caffeine consumption

• Engagement in physical activity.

Exclusion Criteria:

• Diagnosed cardiovascular, metabolic, gastrointestinal, or neurological diseases

• Taking medications or supplements that may affect test results

• Tobacco smoking

• Pregnancy

• Potential allergy to caffeine.

Participation in the study will be preceded by completing a health questionnaire and providing written consent. Additionally, exclusion from the study will occur upon the explicit request of the participant.

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Affect
• Caffeine
• Goals

Intervention

Dietary Supplement:
• Caffeine
Participants will take one caffeine pill. The dose of caffeine will be calculated based on participants' body mass (3mg/kg body mass). Caffeine will be provided in capsules containing the individual amount of caffeine and will be administered orally 60 min before the onset of the exercise protocol.
• Placebo
Participants will take one pill with no caffeine in it. The manufacturer of the caffeine capsules will also prepare identical placebo capsules filled out with a microcrystalline cellulose. Placebo will be administered orally 60 min before the onset of the exercise protocol.

Other:
• No substance
Participants will take no substance. They will just wait 60 minutes and then engage in the exercise protocol.

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
Poland	The Jerzy Kukuczka Academy of Physical Education in Katowice	Katowice

Sponsors (3)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
Jagiellonian University	The Jerzy Kukuczka Academy of Physical Education in Katowice, University School of Physical Education, Krakow, Poland

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Poland, 

References & Publications (2)

Matthews G; Jones DM, Chamberlain AG. Refining the measurement of mood: The UWIST mood adjective checklist. British Journal of Psychology, 1990, 81(1): 17-42.

Szumowska E, Molinario E, Jasko K, Hudiyana J, Firdiani NF, Penrod J, Jaume LC, Leander NP, Kreienkamp J, Agostini M, Gruszka A, Szumska I, Stelmaszynska D, Gola M, Altungy P, Gómez Á, Cacek J, & Kruglanski AW (2023). The Extreme Personality: Individual Differences in Proneness to Motivational Imbalance. Manuscript submitted for publication.

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Primary	Energetic arousal pre-test	Self-reported energetic arousal contrasting vigour with fatigue, measured with the energetic arousal sub-scale of the University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology Mood Adjective Checklist. The values range from 1-4; higher scores indicate greater energetic arousal.	Right before the intervention
Primary	Energetic arousal post-test	Self-reported energetic arousal measured with the energetic arousal sub-scale of the University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology Mood Adjective Checklist. The values range from 1-4; higher scores indicate greater energetic arousal. The change relative to the pre-test will be analyzed.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Optimism	Situational optimism (expectancy of positive outcomes) measured with 4 items were participants rate the extent to which they: 1) are positively oriented. 2) are full of optimism. 3) can achieve what I set out to do. 4) are capable of a lot. Responses are given on a 1-7 Likert scale. Higher scores indicate greater optimism. The mean of these items will be computed and the change relative to the pre-test will be analyzed.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Motivation	Motivation to accomplish one's training goals measured with a question where participants rate the extent to which they are motivated to achieve the best result in: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 Likert scale. Higher scores indicate greater motivation.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Determination	Determination to accomplish one's training goals measured with 4 items: 1) During training, everything else will become irrelevant for [the participant[. 2) [The participant] will put a lot of energy into the training. 3) [The participant] will do everything in their power to achieve the training goal. 4) [The participant] will reach the training goal even if it requires a great effort. 5) [The participant] will train despite fatigue. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 Likert scale. Higher scores indicate greater determination.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Relative outcome expectancy	Expectancy of the training results measured with a question: In relation to participants' typical result, what result do they expect in: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 scale anchored 1 = definitely worse than usual and 7 = definitely better than usual. Higher scores indicate more positive outcome expectations.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Success probability	Subjective probability of attaining the best result measured with a question: How likely do participants think it is that they will achieve the best result in: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 scale anchored 1 = completely unlikely and 7 = certain. Higher scores indicate greater probability of success.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Prospective effort	Participants' willingness to invest effort in the training measured with a question: How much effort are participants planning to invest in: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond on a 0-100% scale. Higher scores indicate greater willingness to invest effort.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Agency	Sense of agency measured with two questions: 1) Do participants feel in control over the outcome in..., 2) Do participants feel in control over their performance in... Participants respond to each question in relation to each test outcome: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Responses are given on 1-6 scale anchored 1 = no control and 7 = complete control. Higher scores indicate greater sense of agency.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Primary	Performance in the 1RM test	Participants' performance in the one-repetition maximum test in bench press [number of kg]	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition)
Primary	Performance in the bar velocity in the bench press test	Participants' performance in the bar velocity during 3 sets of 3 repetitions in the bench press exercise [m/s]	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition)
Primary	Performance in the strength-endurance test	Participants' performance in the strength-endurance test in bench press test (number of repetitions)	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition)
Primary	Performance in the countermovement jump test	Participants' performance in the countermovement jump test (number of cm)	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition)
Primary	Satisfaction with the results	Participants' satisfaction with their training results measured with a question: How satisfied are participants with their results in: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 scale anchored 1 = definitely unsatisfied to 7 = definitely satisfied. Higher scores indicate greater satisfaction with the results.	Immediately after the physical exercise test
Primary	Retrospective effort	Participants' assessment of effort invested in the training measured with a question: How much effort did participants invest in:1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond on a 0-100% scale. Higher scores indicate greater effort.	Immediately after the physical exercise test
Primary	Retrospective agency	Sense of agency measured with two questions: 1) Did participants feel in control over the outcome in..., 2) Did participants feel in control over their performance in... Participants respond to each question in relation to each test outcome: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Responses are given on 1-6 scale anchored 1 = no control and 7 = complete control. Higher scores indicate greater sense of agency.	Immediately after the physical exercise test
Secondary	Goal importance	Importance of the training goal measured with a question: How important is it for participants to achieve the best possible result in: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 scale anchored 1 = completely unimportant and 7 = extremely important. Higher scores indicate greater importance.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Secondary	Prospective difficulty	Perceived difficulty of the training goal measured with a question: How do participants assess the difficulty of: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants respond to each item on a 1-7 scale anchored 1 = definitely easy and 7 = definitely difficult. Higher scores indicate greater subjective difficulty.	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Secondary	Expected performance in the 1RM test	Participants' expected performance in the 1 RM test. Participants provide responses to the following questions: How much weight do participants think they will lift in the 1 RM test? (participants provide in kg)	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Secondary	Expected performance in the bar velocity in the bench press test	Participants' expected performance in the bar velocity in the bench press test. Participants provide a response to the following question: How much m/s. do participants expect to achieve in the bar velocity test? (participants provide the response in m/s)	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Secondary	Expected performance in the strength-endurance test	Participants' expected performance in the strength-endurance test. Participants provide a response to the following question: How many repetitions do participants think they will perform in the strength-endurance test? (participants provide the number of repetitions)	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Secondary	Expected performance in the countermovement jump test	Participants' expected performance in the countermovement jump test. Participants provide a response to the following question: How high do participants think they will jump? (participants provide in cm)	60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); before training
Secondary	Retrospective difficulty	Assessed difficulty of each training element: 1) one-repetition maximum bench press test, 2) bar velocity in the bench press test, 3) strength-endurance test, 4) countermovement jump. Participants rate each element twice (generally and in relation to their other trainings) on a 1-7 scale anchored 1 = very easy and 7 = very difficult. Higher scores indicate greater difficulty.	Immediately after the physical exercise test
Secondary	Energetic arousal post-training	Self-reported energetic arousal measured with the energetic arousal sub-scale of the University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology Mood Adjective Checklist. The values range from 1-4; higher scores indicate greater energetic arousal.	Immediately after the physical exercise test
Secondary	Perceived effect on agency	Assessed effect on the sense of agency measured with an item: To what extent do participants agree with the statement: Completing this workout made participants feel like they had control. Participants respond on 1-7 Likert scale. Higher scores indicate the greater perceived effect on agency.	Immediately after the physical exercise test
Secondary	Tense arousal	Self-reported tense arousal contrasting tension with relaxation, measured with the Tense Arousal subscale of the University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology Mood Adjective Checklist. The values range from 1-4; higher scores indicate greater energetic arousal.	Right before the intervention, then 60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); and immediately after the physical exercise test
Secondary	Hedonic tone	Self-reported hedonic tone contrasting pleasant with unpleasant moods, measured with the Hedonic Tone subscale of the University of Wales Institute of Science and Technology Mood Adjective Checklist. The values range from 1-4; higher scores indicate greater energetic arousal.	Right before the intervention, then 60 minutes after taking the capsule (waiting in the no-intervention condition); and immediately after the physical exercise test