An Evaluation of Virtual Reality and Traditional Training in Basic Life Support Training

Virtual Reality Clinical Trial

— VR-BLS  

Official title:

Evaluation of Virtual Reality and Traditional Training in Basic Life Support Training: The Case of Paramedic Student Group

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT05798832
• Other study ID #: BursaU
• Status: Completed
• Phase: N/A
• Start date: May 5, 2022
• Est. completion date: October 10, 2022

Study information

• Verified date: April 2023
• Source: Bursa Uludag Universitesi
• Contact: n/a
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Study type: Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

type of study:A parallel-group trial design was used.

The main question[s] it aims to answer are:

1. HI; The "Basic Life Support Knowledge Assessment Form" score average of the students in the intervention group participating in the VR will be higher than the control group.

2. H1; The Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form score average of the students in the intervention group participating in the VR will be higher than the control group.

A. For the classical BLS training group; Traditional BLS VR Training will be held in the classroom environment for 45 minutes in the form of a lecture, the training session will be terminated after watching the video and answering questions. Trainings will be conducted by Derya ASLAN HUYAR in terms of standardization of trainings.

B.For VR BLS training group; After the introduction of VR in the VR hall, after the explanation of the basic concepts of BLS and the completion of the training through VR BLS scenarios, question-answer will be made and the session will be closed. Trainings will be conducted by Derya ASLAN HUYAR in terms of standardization of trainings.

Description:

An experimental and a pretest-posttest control group design method were applied in this regard.

Population and Sample: The population of the research consists of 89 paramedic students studying in the first grade of the Bursa Uludag University First and Emergency Aid Program in the spring semester of the 2021-2022 academic year.The sample size was determined by means of a power analysis.When the effect size of the difference in knowledge levels between the two groups at 80% power and 5% significance level is taken as 0.70, 34 participants in each group are required, with a total of 68 participants.They were randomly assigned to the experimental and control groups.Participants; Being a first-year paramedic student, not having received basic life support training, and voluntarily agreeing to participate in the study were determined as inclusion criteria.

The number of people to be sampled from the universe was determined by power analysis. When the effect size of the difference in knowledge levels between the two groups at 80% power and 5% significance level is taken as 0.70, 34 participants in each group are required, with a total of 68 participants.

Participants will be assigned to the experimental and control groups by randomization. Participants; Being a first-year paramedic student, not having received basic life support training, and voluntarily agreeing to participate in the study were determined as inclusion criteria.

Data Collection Tools Created by researchers; The "Descriptive Information Form" consists of 6 items. (Annex 6-5) "Basic Life Support Information Evaluation Form" was developed by Tank. This form, which consists of 10 multiple-choice questions, adapted according to the Critical Skills Descriptors of the Adult Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Automatic External Defibrillator Skills Test published by the American Heart Association; questions their level of knowledge about basic life support application. Each correct answer given by the student in the form will be evaluated as 1 point and the average score will be calculated. Students will be able to get a minimum of 0 and a maximum of 10 points (Appendix 6-5) "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" was developed by Tank , it consists of 20 items. This form is used to evaluate the participant's skill status during BLS practice. In the form containing the application steps, the student's ability to perform the application will be evaluated as 1 point for each correct step, and the average score will be calculated. The participant will be able to get a minimum of 0 and a maximum of 20 points at the end of the evaluation of the 20-item form. (Annex 6-5) Data Analysis: SPSS package program will be used.

Research Flow Process:

Basic Life Support (BLS) Virtual Reality (VR) and Basic Life Support Traditional Education Program Flow Process Steps

1. Pre-Training Evaluation Students randomly assigned to the VR and Classical education group; "Descriptive Information Form" and "Basic Life Support Information Evaluation Form" will be filled.

2. Education

1. For the classical BLS training group; Traditional BLS VR Training will be held in the classroom environment in the form of lectures for 45 minutes, and the training session will end after watching the video and question and answering. In terms of standardization of the trainings, the trainings will be given by Derya ASLAN HUYAR.

2. For the VR BLS training group; After the VR presentation in the VR hall, after the explanation of the basic concepts of BLS and the completion of the training on VR BLS scenarios, there will be a question and answer session and the session will be closed. In terms of standardization of the trainings, the trainings will be given by Derya ASLAN HUYAR.

3. Initial Evaluation After Training For practices, students will be divided into groups of 6 to 8 people.

1. Med-Sim Training simulator will be introduced by the Training Coach and BLS application steps will be demonstrated.

2. A BLS scenario will be given to the participants in the classical and VR BLS training groups. Then, each participant will perform the application steps on the Med-Sim simulation model. In the meantime, each participant will be evaluated in terms of skills by using the "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" by Derya ASLAN HUYAR and Yeliz ŞAPULU ALAKAN.

3. Participants in the Classical and VR BLS training groups will fill out the "Basic Life Support Information Evaluation Form" after the training.

4. Second Evaluation After Training One month after the training, just like in the phases applied in the first measurement; BLS scenario will be given to the participants in both classical and BLS training groups. Each participant will be evaluated in terms of skills by Derya ASLAN HUYAR and Yeliz ŞAPULU ALAKAN using the "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" while the participants are doing the application steps on the Med-Sim simulation model.

One month after the training, the participants in the Classic and VR BLS training groups will fill out the "Basic Life Support Information Evaluation Form" after the training.

5. Third Evaluation After Training Planned steps in other measurements will be followed in the same way. Three months after the training, the participants in the Classical and BLS training groups will be given a BLS scenario and asked to do the application steps on the Med-Sim simulation model. Meanwhile, each participant will be evaluated in terms of skills by using the "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" by Derya ASLAN HUYAR and Yeliz ŞAPULU ALAKAN while the participants are doing the application steps on the Med-Sim simulation model.

Three months after the training, the participants in the Classic and VR BLS training groups will fill out the "Basic Life Support Information Evaluation Form" after the training.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Completed
• Enrollment: 68
• Est. completion date: October 10, 2022
• Est. primary completion date: June 10, 2022
• Accepts healthy volunteers: No
• Gender: All
• Age group: N/A and older

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

• Being a first-year paramedic student,

• not having received basic life support training

• voluntarily agreeing to participate in the research,

Exclusion Criteria:

• have previous BLS training

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Basic Cardiac Life Support
• Education
• Virtual Reality

Intervention

Other:
• Virtually reality training group
BLS Training with VR
• Traditional training group
BLS Training with Traditional

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
Turkey	Bursa Uludag Üniversitesi	Bursa	Nilüfer

Sponsors (2)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
Bursa Uludag Universitesi	Uludag University

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Turkey, 

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Primary	before the intervention	Before the training of the experimental and control group participants, BLS knowledge was measured."Basic Life Support Information Evaluation Form" is organized according to the Adult Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Automatic External Defibrillator Skill steps published by the American Heart Association and consists of 10 multiple choice questions.; Each correct answer is 1 point. minimum 0, maximum 10 points can be scored.	via google form. Before the intervention
Secondary	immediately after the intervention,	The BLS knowledge level of the experimental and control groups was measured with the questionnaire.; In addition, the researchers gave each student an appointment individually so that the skill levels of both groups could be measured. "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" consists of 20 items. In the form containing the application steps, 1 point is taken for each correct step. The participant will be able to get a minimum of 0 and a maximum of 20 points.; The researchers asked the participants to apply the BLS steps on the BLS model. The researchers marked their observations as checklist. Each student was given feedback after the application.	via google form. it took a total of 2 weeks to complete the skill measurements of the control and experimental groups. Control group: May 16-20 experimental group may 23-27
Secondary	1st months after the intervention.	The BLS knowledge level of the experimental and control groups was measured with the questionnaire.; In addition, the researchers gave each student an appointment individually so that the skill levels of both groups could be measured. "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" consists of 20 items. In the form containing the application steps, 1 point is taken for each correct step. The participant will be able to get a minimum of 0 and a maximum of 20 points.; The researchers asked the participants to apply the BLS steps on the BLS model. The researchers marked their observations as checklist. Each student was given feedback after the application.	via google form. It took a total of 2 weeks to complete the skill measurements of the control and experimental groups. Control group: 20-24 June experimental group: 27 June 1 July
Secondary	3rd months after the intervention.	The BLS knowledge level of the experimental and control groups was measured with the questionnaire.; In addition, the researchers gave each student an appointment individually so that the skill levels of both groups could be measured. "Basic Life Support Application Evaluation Form" consists of 20 items. In the form containing the application steps, 1 point is taken for each correct step. The participant will be able to get a minimum of 0 and a maximum of 20 points.; The researchers asked the participants to apply the BLS steps on the BLS model. The researchers marked their observations as checklist. Each student was given feedback after the application.	via google form. Each student was given an appointment to assess the students' BLS skill level. It took a total of 2 weeks to complete the skill measurements of the control and experimental groups.19 -23 Sep.]