Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Suspended
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT04005027 |
| Other study ID # |
LQT004291 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Suspended |
| Phase |
N/A
|
| First received |
|
| Last updated |
|
| Start date |
July 8, 2019 |
| Est. completion date |
September 1, 2023 |
Study information
| Verified date |
December 2021 |
| Source |
University of Sunderland |
| Contact |
n/a |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
|
| Study type |
Interventional
|
Clinical Trial Summary
Long QT syndrome (LQTS) is an inherited heart defect where the heart takes longer to recover
between beats. LQTS is a known condition predisposing young footballers to sudden cardiac
death (SDC). The existence of LQTS can be established by measuring the QT interval in an
electrocardiogram (ECG). Currently pre-participation cardiac screening is performed in young
athletes but players may only be screened at 16 years old using only a resting ECG, and a
medical check including a questionnaire on family and medical history. However, the
sensitivity and specificity of the screening to investigate underlying causes of SCD could be
improved with the addition of an exercise stress test or cardiopulmonary exercise test
(CPET). Certain abnormalities in the heart may only become apparent when the heart has been
stressed (e.g. via exercise). This is particularly important as in young athletes these
abnormal rhythms manifest during rest and recovery rather than at peak exercise. The CPET
measures changes in the ECG in response to exercise that increases in intensity in a
continuous manner until the participant cannot exercise any long. However, football is
characterised by high- intensity bouts of exercise interspersed with low-intensity bouts or
pauses. Therefore, the continuous test does not reflect the movement patterns of football and
may not stress the cardiovascular system in a similar manner. To address this, intermittent
graded exercise tests have been developed to reflect the intermittent movement pattern. As
yet there is limited evidence on whether there are any differences in ECG changes during
intermittent exercise. Specifically, it is not clear how an intermittent movement pattern
might affect the QT interval.
Description:
Long QT syndrome (LQTS) is an ion channelopathy which occurs in approximately 1 in every 2500
individuals. Symptoms include; syncope, seizures and sudden cardiac death (SCD). LQTS's
genetic defects culminate in delayed cardiac repolarization identified on a 12 lead
electrocardiogram (ECG) as a prolonged QT interval. Due to the dynamic nature of
channelopathies, some abnormalities could be missed with a resting ECG alone. In young
athletes cardiac arrhythmia's predisposing athletes to SCD do not usually occur at peak
exercise but during warm-up, recovery or periods of reduced exercise intensity (e.g. rest
phases in football games). Environments causing increase in body temperature, heat rate, and
autonomic status should therefore be included in the assessment of risk of SCD. Whilst the
use of cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET) is commonplace, the use of such an exercise
test is often performed using a continuous ramp or step procedure (e.g Bruce protocol).
However, during games play such as football, movements are not continuous but intermittent
characterised by rest phases and lower intensity periods of exercise. The primary aim of this
study is to assess the duration and dispersion of the QT interval during and immediately
following the performance of a continuous (CONT), and an intermittent (INT) maximal graded
exercise test in a group of young (< 16-18 yr) semi-professional soccer players. It is
anticipated that the INT graded exercise test will induce greater inter-individual
variability in the QT interval compared to the CONT trial.
The investigators aim to recruit approximately 50 players from Sunderland Foundation of Light
regional training centre (RTC) with a minimum sample size of 24. We will use a replicated
randomised repeated measures crossover design in which the participants will be randomised to
different sequences of four experimental conditions; two continuous graded exercise tests,
and two intermittent graded exercise tests, randomised using a Latin square counterbalanced
design. Participants will be required to perform all four exercise conditions at
approximately the same time of day (± 1 h) to control for within-athlete variation. Each
exercise condition will be separated by at least 72 h with all testing sessions complete
within a 2-4 week period. The following constraints will be placed on the participants to
improve the strength of the study design:
- Avoid strenuous physical activity for 48-72 h prior to testing.
- Avoid caffeine consumption for 4 h prior to testing and alcohol at least 12 h.
- Maintain normal hydration by drinking to thirst prior to testing.
- Consume a high carbohydrate meal 2 h prior to testing.
Exercise testing
Exercise will be performed in a temperature controlled physiology laboratory. Participants
will perform two graded exercise tests, repeated twice. The continuous graded exercise test
(CONT) will increase treadmill speed incrementally using three minute stage duration on a
motorised treadmill. The initial speed will be individualised designed to evoke a heart rate
around 40-50% of one's age predicted maximal heart rate using 206.9 - (0.67* age [yrs]). This
will be gauged from a 3 minute low intensity warm-up at the start. The speed will increase by
1 km.hr-1 every three minutes until volitional exhaustion. The gradient of the treadmill will
be set at 1 % to reflect energy expenditure of over-ground running. Gradient will only be
increased if the performer reaches the limits of their stride frequency and length and
therefore it would be inappropriate to continue to increase speed of the belt. The
intermittent graded exercise test (INT) will follow the same procedure. However, the speed
within each three minute exercise bout will vary every 30 s between the target speed, and a
complete pause for 30 s. The acceleration of the treadmill belt will be set to its maximum
capability. Participants will be familiarised with this acceleration to ensure safety.
Blood lactate
A post- exercise capillary blood lactate sample will be taken from the participants' finger-
tip of their non-dominant hand. The finger -tip will be punctured using a disposable lancet
to obtain the capillary blood sample. The small sample of blood is then collected and
analysed using a portable blood lactate analyser (Lactate Pro). The finger will be cleaned
using an alcohol swab to reduce infection. The researcher taking the blood will be wearing
appropriate personal protective equipment including latex-free gloves when obtaining the
blood. The blood measure is used as an end-point (among others) to confirm if maximal effort
has been performed.
Gas analysis Respiratory data will be recorded continuously throughout each exercise test
using an online breath by breath metabolic gas cart (Cortex, metamax). Certified standard
calibration gases of 16.4% O2 and 4.5% CO2 will be used (Cryoservice Ltd, Worcester, UK). The
turbine flow meter, used for the determination of V ̇E, will be calibrated with a 3 L syringe
(Cosmed Srl). Room temperature (°C), relative humidity (%) and barometric pressure (mmHg)
will recorded separately from a weather station. Rating of Perceived Exertion (RPE) (modified
category-ratio scale) (Foster et al., 2001) expressed as an arbitrary unit (AU) will obtained
in the final 15 s of each speed stage.
All breath-by-breath data will be processed using 30 s retrograde averages (Midgley et al.,
2007) obtained directly from the metamax software®, with the highest VO2 in the final stages
deemed to be VO2max (Midgley et al., 2007). The use of middle 5 of 7 breath averaging will be
used for assessment of submaximal data including the ventilatory threshold (Nichols et al
2015). VO2max will be deemed to be achieved if ≥2 of the following criteria are met (Keren et
al., 1980): a plateau in VO2 defined as a change of less than 0.2 L.min-1 despite an
increasing workload (Howley et al., 1995), a respiratory exchange ratio (RER) of >1.15, a
maximal heart rate (HRpeak) within ±10 beats.min-1 of the estimated HRpeak (206.9 - [0.67 x
age]), an RPE greater than 8 (Howley et al., 1995) and a 5 min post blood lactate of > 8 mM.
Echocardiography, Electrocardiography and QT interval analysis
A standard transthoracic echocardiogram (TTE) will be used to investigate the existence of
any structural cardiac abnormalities. An initial assessment will be performed on the first
visit to the laboratory lasting a minimum of 40-45 min. The screening will be carried out by
a qualified cardiac physiologist. A 5 minute resting, recovery and exercise 12 lead ECG will
be performed using the Mason- Likar set- up. The ECG will be recorded at a paper speed of 25
mm/s. The QT interval will be determined as the interval between the beginning of the Q or R
wave to the peak of the T wave, and the point where a tangent drawn along the maximum slope
of the descending limb of the T wave crosses the isoelectric TP baseline. The corrected QT
interval (QTc) will be calculated using an automated algorithm averaging across 3 beats for
each three minute stage, and 60 second recovery phases. We will use a number of different
formulas to assess the corrected QT (QTc);
Bazett's (QTc =QT/!RR), Fridericia (QTc=QT/[RR/1000]1/3), Framingham (QTc=QT+[0.154 *
{1000-RR}]) Hodges (QTc=QT+1.75 * [{60 000/RR}260])
