Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Withdrawn

Administrative data

NCT number NCT02393326
Other study ID # 0644-14-HMO-CTIL
Secondary ID
Status Withdrawn
Phase N/A
First received March 9, 2015
Last updated March 12, 2018
Start date January 2018
Est. completion date January 2020

Study information

Verified date March 2018
Source Hadassah Medical Organization
Contact n/a
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

Objective: To compare success rates of biodentine partial pulpotomy versus formocresol pulpotomy treatment of pulpally exposed lower primary molars.

After caries removal resulted in a pulp exposure, the pulp at the exposed area is amputated to a depth of 2 mm. The wound surface is irrigated and dried. After homeostasis is obtained, an assistant drew lots to randomly allocate the case to either the biodentine partial pulpotomy (PP) or the formocresol pulpotomy (FP) group.

The follow-up for clinical and radiographic evaluation will be carried out at 6-month intervals.


Description:

- Prospective

- Study population: 100 patients.

- Study group: This study sample comprises mandibular primary molars from boys and girls aged between 3 and 7 years. The children have no systemic diseases according to the medical history supplied by the parents or guardians. The mandibular primary molars in this study are selected according to the following clinical and radiographic criteria. The clinical criteria: the presence of a deep carious lesion, sufficient tooth structure for restoration with a stainless steel crown, no history of spontaneous pain, tenderness to percussion or abnormal mobility, abscess, fistula, or swelling of the gingiva, and with cessation of bleeding after a 2 mm depth of the pulp at the area of the exposure was amputated. The radiographic criteria: a deep carious lesion in close proximity to the pulp without furcation or radicular pathology, obliteration of the pulp and root canal, or internal or external root resorption. Physiologic root resorption, while included in the criteria, could not be more than one-third of the root length.

- Clinical technique: All teeth will be treated under local anaesthesia with rubber dam isolation. After caries removal resulted in a pulp exposure, the pulp at the exposed area is amputated to a depth of 2 mm using a water-cooled high-speed handpiece with a #330 high-speed bur. The wound surface is irrigated with sterile saline solution and dried with cotton pellets to avoid clot formation. After homeostasis is obtained, an assistant drew lots to randomly allocate the case to either the PP or the FP treatment group. The child will not know which treatment is assigned to each tooth. For the PP group, biodentine is gently applied to the wound surface, and then covered with reinforced zinc oxide-eugenol (IRM_; Dentsply). For the FP group, coronal access is obtained using high-speed handpiece with a #330 high-speed bur with water spray to further expose the pulp chamber. Following removal of the coronal pulp and achievement of homeostasis, a cotton pellet moistened with formocresol (1: 5 Buckley's solution) is placed on the amputated pulp for 5 min. The pulp stumps is then covered by IRM. After PP or FP treatment, all teeth are restored with a stainless steel crown.

- Follow-up: the follow-up for clinical and radiographic evaluation will be carried out at 6-month intervals. Treatment is considered a clinical failure if one or more of the following signs are observed: pain, abscess or sinus opening, tenderness upon percussion, or abnormal tooth mobility. For radiographic evaluation, the treatment is rated as a failure when one or more of the following signs are present: furcation or periapical radiolucency, pathologic external root resorption, or internal resorption. The treatment is regarded successful if both the clinical and radiographic evaluation does not indicate any signs of failure.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Withdrawn
Enrollment 0
Est. completion date January 2020
Est. primary completion date January 2019
Accepts healthy volunteers Accepts Healthy Volunteers
Gender All
Age group 3 Years to 7 Years
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria:

- The clinical criteria: primary molar with a deep carious lesion

- Sufficient tooth structure for restoration with a stainless steel crown

- No history of spontaneous pain

- Tenderness to percussion or abnormal mobility

- Abscess, fistula, or swelling of the gingiva, and with cessation of bleeding after a 2 mm depth of the pulp at the area of the exposure was amputated.

- The radiographic criteria: a deep carious lesion in close proximity to the pulp without furcation or radicular pathology

- Obliteration of the pulp and root canal, or internal or external root resorption.

- Physiologic root resorption, while included in the criteria, could not be more than one-third of the root length.

Exclusion Criteria:

- The clinical criteria: history of spontaneous pain

- Tenderness to percussion or abnormal mobility

- Abscess, fistula, or swelling of the gingiva, no cessation of bleeding after a 2 mm depth of the pulp at the area of the exposure was amputated.

- The radiographic criteria: tooth with furcation or radicular pathology

- Obliteration of the pulp and root canal, or internal or external root resorption.

- Physiologic root resorption more than one-third of the root length.

Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


Intervention

Procedure:
partial pulpotomy with biodentine
After caries removal resulted in a pulp exposure, the pulp at the exposed area is amputated to a depth of 2 mm. The wound surface is irrigated and dried. After homeostasis is obtained, biodentine is gently applied to the wound surface, and then covered with reinforced zinc oxide-eugenol
Formocresol pulpotomy
Following removal of the coronal pulp and achievement of homeostasis, a cotton pellet moistened with formocresol (1: 5 Buckley's solution) is placed on the amputated pulp for 5 min. The pulp stumps is then covered by IRM.

Locations

Country Name City State
n/a

Sponsors (1)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
Hadassah Medical Organization

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary partial pulpotomy clinical success rate Treatment is considered a clinical failure if one or more of the following signs are observed: pain, abscess or sinus opening, tenderness upon percussion, or abnormal tooth mobility. The treatment is regarded successful if clinical evaluation does not indicate any signs of failure. 6-month intervals, up to 2 years. From date of randomization until the date of first documented failure or up to 24 months
Primary partial pulpotomy radiographic success rate For radiographic evaluation, the treatment is rated as a failure when one or more of the following signs are present: furcation or periapical radiolucency, pathologic external root resorption, or internal resorption. The treatment is regarded successful if radiographic evaluation does not indicate any signs of failure. 6-month intervals, up to 2 years. From date of randomization until the date of first documented failure or up to 24 months
Secondary Formocresol pulpotomy clinical success rate Treatment is considered a clinical failure if one or more of the following signs are observed: pain, abscess or sinus opening, tenderness upon percussion, or abnormal tooth mobility. The treatment is regarded successful if clinical evaluation does not indicate any signs of failure. 6-month intervals, up to 2 years. From date of randomization until the date of first documented failure or up to 24 months
Secondary Formocresol pulpotomy radiographic success rate For radiographic evaluation, the treatment is rated as a failure when one or more of the following signs are present: furcation or periapical radiolucency, pathologic external root resorption, or internal resorption. The treatment is regarded successful if radiographic evaluation does not indicate any signs of failure. 6-month intervals, up to 2 years. From date of randomization until the date of first documented failure or up to 24 months
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Withdrawn NCT01878851 - Characterization of Blood Drawn From the Pulp of Primary Molar Undergoing Pulpotomy or Pulpectomy.
Completed NCT04270318 - Sodium Hypoclorite as an Antibacterial Agent Prior to Pulpotomies N/A
Completed NCT04909827 - 3D-printed Endocrowns Versus Prefabricated Zirconia Crowns in Pulpally-treated Primary Molars Phase 4
Completed NCT03200938 - Clinical Applicability of PBS® CIMMO Cement in Pulpotomies N/A
Recruiting NCT04863222 - Clinical and Radiographic Success of MTA vs Biodentine Phase 4
Active, not recruiting NCT05554952 - Indirect Pulp Capping Versus Pulpotomy With MTA for Treatment of Primary Molars With Deep Caries N/A
Completed NCT03779698 - BiodentineTM Versus Formocresol Pulpotomy Technique in Primary Molars Phase 4
Completed NCT03395496 - Comparison of Biodentine and MTA Pulpotomies in the Primary Molar Teeth 3 Year Follow up Early Phase 1
Not yet recruiting NCT05747300 - Wellroot PT Versus MTA in Pulpotomy of Primary Molars N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06288477 - Clinical and Radiographic Evaluation of Vital Pulpotomy Techniques in Primary Molars Using of Premixed Bioactive Bioceramic MTA (Neo-putty) as a Novel Pulpotomy Medication Versus Formocresol N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06219824 - Clinical and Radiographic Evaluation of Bioceramic Putty MTA Versus MTA in Pulpotomy of Immature Permanent Molars Phase 3
Completed NCT03718676 - Pulpotomy With Various MTA Materials and Ferric Sulphate N/A
Recruiting NCT05279820 - Comparative Study of the Outcome of Partial and Full Pulpotomy in Irreversible Pulpits N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT02298504 - Vital Pulp Treatment in Primary Teeth Phase 4
Completed NCT04010929 - Efficacy of Er,Cr:YSGG Laser in Partial Pupotomy N/A
Terminated NCT02783911 - Comparison of Mineral Trioxide Aggregate (MTA) & Ferric Sulfate (FS) Pulpotomies N/A
Completed NCT05792748 - Comparison of Zinc Oxide Eugenol to Ferric Sulphate Pulpotomy in Primary Teeth N/A
Completed NCT05680285 - Evaluation of Low Level Laser Therapy in Primary Tooth Pulpotomy Treatment N/A
Completed NCT05297344 - Clinical Study of the Direct Pulp Capping in Primary Teeth N/A
Completed NCT03782714 - Low-level Laser Therapy Versus Formocresol in Primary Molar Pulpotomies N/A