Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

NCT number NCT05141227
Other study ID # Complex pilon fractures
Secondary ID
Status Completed
Phase N/A
First received
Last updated
Start date December 1, 2021
Est. completion date February 1, 2024

Study information

Verified date April 2024
Source Ain Shams University
Contact n/a
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

This study aims to compare the clinical, radiological, and functional outcomes of two-stage open reduction and internal fixation with single-stage external fixation in the treatment of comminuted tibial pilon fractures.


Description:

A pilon fracture ( also known as tibial plafond fractures) is a fracture of the distal end of the tibia with comminution, intra-articular extension and significant soft tissue injury.Pilon injury accounts for about 5% to 10% of all tibial fractures, and for <10% of lower extremity injuries. The incidence rate is relatively low. However, with the high incidence of high energy trauma and accidental falls, the number of comminuted fractures has increased in recent years.Among all pilon fractures, about 30% are complex pilon fractures (AO/ OTA 43C type) caused by high-energy injuries. Most complex pilon fractures are associated with severe soft tissue injuries, making the treatment challenging. Optimal treatment of comminuted pilon fractures requires precise anatomical reduction accompanied by early functional exercise. Several methods have been advocated to manage complex pilon fractures, but an optimal fixation technique remains controversial. In 1979, Ruedi and Allgower first reported satisfactory results with primary open reduction and internal fixation.However, many authors have noted significant complications when open reduction and internal fixation was applied to severe pilon fractures, including an infection rate as high as 55%, wound necrosis and skin sloughing. These complications arose from the internal fixation, leading many orthopaedic surgeons to choose external fixation as an alternative. Although external fixation decreased wound necrosis and skin sloughing, high rates of pin site infection and malalignment with subsequent non-union occurred. Therefore, orthopaedic surgeons made great efforts to establish methods that provided good results and decreased postoperative complications. With the accumulation of surgical experience and the development of surgical techniques, two-stage open reduction and internal fixation and limited internal fixation combined with external fixation were established, and these two methods are now widely advocated for the treatment of comminuted tibial pilon fractures. Two-stage open reduction and internal fixation involves closed reduction and external fixation followed by conversion to open reduction and internal fixation after the condition of the surrounding soft tissues has improved. This technique focuses on the soft tissue condition and potentially decreases the incidence of soft tissue complications.Thus, this method is widely considered the standard of care for high-energy pilon fractures. However, other surgeons have recommended limited internal fixation combined with external fixation for these severe fractures as an alternative to open reduction and internal fixation to reduce the risk of postoperative complications. The CT based four-column classification has been adopted by many surgeons as a guide for the treatment of comminuted pilon fractures. The four-column classification can be summarized as lateral column (the distal fibula), posterior column (the posterior part of the intermalleolar line with the distal tibial shaft), anterior column (the anterior part of the intermalleolar line with the distal tibial shaft) and medial column (the medial one-third of the tibial plafond with the distal tibial shaft) Till now, there's no randomized prospective controlled trials confirmed which method either two-stage open reduction and internal fixation or single-stage external fixation is superior regarding clinical, radiological, and functional outcomes.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Completed
Enrollment 60
Est. completion date February 1, 2024
Est. primary completion date December 15, 2023
Accepts healthy volunteers Accepts Healthy Volunteers
Gender All
Age group 18 Years and older
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria: - Skeletally mature patients - Both males and females - Closed or open (grade 1&2) pilon fractures according to Gustilo and Anderson classification - AO/OTA type C fractures - Compromised soft tissue not allowing for primary open reduction and internal fixation - Unilateral or bilateral - Isolated or polytrauma patients Exclusion Criteria: - Skeletally immature patients - Open grade 3 pilon fractures - Patients eligible for primary open reduction and internal fixation - Ipsilateral lower limb fractures - Pathological fractures - Pre-existing symptomatic ankle arthritis

Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


Intervention

Procedure:
Two-stage Open reduction and internal fixation ( ORIF) using plates & screws
Two stage ORIF using initially temporary spanning fixator then conversion to plates & screws
single-stage external fixation (EX.FIX.) with minimal internal fixation using cannulated screws if needed
Single stage Ex.Fix. Using illizarov & minimal fixation of the articular surface using cannulated screws through mini open approaches

Locations

Country Name City State
Egypt El-Demerdash hospital Ain shams university Cairo

Sponsors (1)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
Ain Shams University

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Egypt, 

References & Publications (3)

Mauffrey C, Vasario G, Battiston B, Lewis C, Beazley J, Seligson D. Tibial pilon fractures: a review of incidence, diagnosis, treatment, and complications. Acta Orthop Belg. 2011 Aug;77(4):432-40. — View Citation

Michelson J, Moskovitz P, Labropoulos P. The nomenclature for intra-articular vertical impact fractures of the tibial plafond: pilon versus pylon. Foot Ankle Int. 2004 Mar;25(3):149-50. doi: 10.1177/107110070402500307. — View Citation

Ruedi TP, Allgower M. The operative treatment of intra-articular fractures of the lower end of the tibia. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1979 Jan-Feb;(138):105-10. — View Citation

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary Functional Functional outcome will be assessed using the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) evaluation system.
The score includes I.Pain (40 point) II. Function (50 points) It's divided into 7 items
Activity limitations, support requirements (10points)
Maximum walking distance, blocks (5 points)
Walking surfaces (5 points)
Gait abnormality (8 points)
Sagittal motion (flexion plus extension) (8points)
Hindfoot motion (inversion plus eversion) (6points)
Ankle-hindfoot stability (anteroposterior, varus-valgus) (8 points) III. Alignment(10 points) IV. Total Score(100 points)
12 months
Primary Radiological Accuracy of reduction in plain x Ray using burwell& charnely score It includes Anatomical reduction , fair reduction & poor reduction
Anatomical...
No medial or lateral displacement of the medial & lateral malleulus
no angulation
no more than 1 ml of longitudinal displacement of the medial or lateral malleli
no more then 2 ml of proximal displacement of a large posterior fragment
no talus displacement
Fair ...
No medial or lateral displacement of the medial & lateral malleulus
no angulation
2-5 ml of posterior displacement of lateral malleulus
2-5 ml of proximal displacement of a large posterior fragment
no talus displacement
Poor ...
Any medial or lateral displacement of the medial & lateral malleulus
no angulation
more than 5 ml of posterior displacement of lateral malleulus
more than 5 ml of proximal displacement of a large posterior fragment
any residual talus displacement
12 months
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT05280639 - Simplified Post Op Rehabilitation for Ankle and Pilon Fractures N/A
Completed NCT02609347 - Manual Therapy After Ankle/Hindfoot Fractures N/A
Withdrawn NCT01818466 - Anterior Tibiotalar Arthrodesis With Blade Plate Fixation N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06182904 - Management of Pilon Fractures With Versus Without Fibula Fixation
Recruiting NCT03652753 - Pilon Fracture With Intra-articular Injection of N-Acetylcysteine (Pilon NAC) Phase 4
Completed NCT03562364 - Early Advanced Weight Bearing for Peri-articular Knee and Pilon Injuries N/A
Completed NCT01126398 - Trauma Expectation Factor Trauma Outcome Measure
Recruiting NCT06089525 - Treatment of Complex Pilon Fractures
Recruiting NCT05131321 - Primary Ankle Arthrodesis Versus Open Reduction and Internal Fixation for Fragility Fractures Around the Ankle in the Frail Elderly.