Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Recruiting
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT01154712 |
| Other study ID # |
244 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Recruiting |
| Phase |
Phase 1
|
| First received |
June 30, 2010 |
| Last updated |
July 12, 2010 |
| Start date |
June 2010 |
| Est. completion date |
June 2012 |
Study information
| Verified date |
January 2010 |
| Source |
BeerYaakov Mental Health Center |
| Contact |
Oded Rosenberg, M.D. |
| Phone |
97289284293 |
| Email |
odedaruna[@]gmail.com |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
Israel: Ethics Commission |
| Study type |
Interventional
|
Clinical Trial Summary
Pathological gambling (PG) is characterized by a persistent pattern of continued gambling
behavior despite its adverse consequences. PG is a chronic, progressive, male-dominated
disorder, which has a prevalence of 1% to 3.4% among US adults. Deep transcranial magnetic
stimulation (TMS) is a novel neuro-stimulation method capable of inhibiting neuronal
activity when given in low frequency. The hypothesis of this study is that , Pathological
gambling will be ameliorated if low frequency magnetic field using Brainsway H1 coil will be
applied to the left dorso-lateral prefrontal cortex of these patients.
Description:
Deep Low-Frequency Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation for cessation of
pathological gambling
Introduction:
Pathological gambling (PG) is characterized by a persistent pattern of continued gambling
behavior despite its adverse consequences. PG is a chronic, progressive, male-dominated
disorder, which has a prevalence of 1% to 3.4% among US adults. Typically, the patient's
life becomes dominated by the gambling behavior leading to overwhelming financial burdens,
an inability to maintain a career, and to the eventual disintegration of family
relationships. The enormous personal and social consequences of this disorder include a high
rate of suicide attempts, legal problems, and criminal behavior [R1].
Several theoretical models of drug addiction have suggested that addiction is related to
abnormal activity in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex system, which is necessary for
inhibiting both the craving for immediate reward and excitement-seeking behavior [ref2].
Neuropsychological studies of pathological gamblers [ref 3to9 ref2 ref10] have demonstrated
that pathological gamblers have deficits in the frontal lobe/reward system leading
investigators to hypothesize that impairment of executive function may play an important
role in the etiology of pathological gambling.
Drawing from the field of drug dependence, it has been speculated that the underlying
pathology in pathological gambling is a reduction in the sensitivity of the reward system.
Reuter et al studied pathological gamblers and controls during a guessing game using
functional magnetic resonance imaging and observed a reduction of ventral striatal and
ventromedial prefrontal activation in the pathological gamblers that was negatively
correlated with gambling severity, linking hypo-activation of these areas to disease
severity [ ref11]. Studies in the field of addiction have shown that prefrontal regulation
of behavior is reduced in basal conditions, thereby contributing to the reduced salience of
non-drug motivational stimuli and reduced decision-making ability. However, when stimuli
predicting drug availability are presented, there is profound activation of the prefrontal
cortex and glutamatergic drive to the nucleus accumbens [ref12].
Potenza et al in a functional magnetic resonance imaging study demonstrated that male
pathological gamblers showed relatively reduced activity in the frontal and orbitofrontal
cortex, caudate and basal ganglia and thalamus as compared to controls when presented with
visual gambling cues [ref13].Recent neurobehavioral studies have demonstrated poor
performance on tests of executive function in pathological gamblers suggesting that the
financial risk-taking behavior seen in PG may be associated with both dorsolateral
prefrontal and orbitofrontal cortex dysfunction [ref 14-17].Neuropsychological studies of
PGs have demonstrated that PGs have deficits in the frontal lobe/reward system [ref18
ref10].Patients with pathological gambling demonstrated greater decreases in binding
potential in the ventral striatum during gambling (13.9%) than control patients (8.1%),
likely reflecting greater dopaminergic release. Ventral striatal bindings at baseline during
control task were also lower in patients with pathological gambling [ref19].
Reductions in right prefrontal activity during decision-making appear to be modulated by the
presence of gambling problems and may reflect impaired working memory, stimulus reward
valuation, or cue reactivity in substance dependent individuals [ref20].
PG is related to response perseveration and diminished reward and punishment sensitivity as
indicated by hypoactivation of the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex when money is gained and
lost. Moreover, intact planning abilities and normal dorsal frontostriatal responsiveness
indicate that this deficit is not due to impaired executive functioning. Response
perseveration and ventral prefrontal hypo-responsiveness to monetary loss may be markers for
maladaptive behavior seen in chemical and non-chemical addictions [ref21].
In one study, subjects and 10 matched healthy control subjects underwent fMRI during visual
presentations of gambling-related video alternating with video of nature scenes.
Pathological gambling subjects and control subjects exhibited overlap in areas of brain
activity in response to the visual gambling cues; however, compared with control subjects,
PG subjects exhibited significantly greater activity in the right dorsolateral prefrontal
cortex (DLPFC), including the inferior and medial frontal gyri, the right parahippocampal
gyrus, and left occipital cortex, including the fusiform gyrus [R22].
It has been reported that High-frequency (20-Hz) rTMS of left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
can reduce cigarette smoking significantly [ref23].In another study, found that multiple
high-frequency rTMS of the DLPFC can attenuate nicotine craving [ref 24].Regarding cocaine
addiction treatment with TMS, it has been shown that one session of 10Hz rTMS over right,
but not left, DLPFC transiently reduces craving in cocaine dependent individuals
[ref25].Politi et al. conducted a study including thirty-six subjects fulfilling DSM-IV
criteria for cocaine dependence. Subjects were treated with 20 trains of TMS applied to the
left prefrontal cortex in frequency of 15 Hz and intensity of 100% of the motor threshold.
Repeated measures analyses of variance showed that cocaine craving were gradually reduced
during sessions of TMS [ref26].
Hypothesis Assuming substance addiction and pathological gambling share similar
patho-physiology and considering the evidence that transcranial magnetic stimulation of left
dorsolateral prefrontal cortex can ameliorate addiction in both smoking [ ref23 ] and
cocaine[ ref26 ] we hypothesize that transcranial magnetic stimulation may also reduce
gambling "craving" in pathological gamblers.
H-coil placed over the frontal cortex exerts a significant effect over the entire
ipsilateral cortical hemisphere, but significantly less over the contralateral hemisphere
[ref27].Thus, the H-coil placed over the DLPFC is hypothesized to exert a direct and more
consistent effect on cortical and subcortical regions such as the anterior cingulate and
nucleus accumbens (ventral striatum), compared to the figure-8 coil. Because these regions
are considered to play a role in drug craving and addiction, rTMS applied with the H-coil
may be more effective in reducing drug craving than rTMS applied with the standard figure-8
coil.
Deep TMS:
Deep TMS is currently being evaluated as a treatment option in major depression. It has been
shown to be a safe procedure [ref28, ref29]. The innovative design of Brainsway H-Coils is
intended to generate sufficient magnetic field strength to stimulate neurons deep inside the
brain mass without posing a hazard. This forms the basis of the Brainsway H-Coil used in
their deep rTMS device. The coils are designed to maximize the electrical field deep in the
brain by the summation of separate fields projected into the skull from several points
around its periphery. The device also minimizes the accumulation of electrical charge on the
surface of the brain, which can give rise to an electrostatic field that might reduce the
magnitude of the induced electric field both at the surface and inside, and reduce the depth
penetration of the induced electric field [ref30]. The unique shape of the device's base
includes wire coils containing several wire strips, set tangentially to the scalp's surface.
Each set of strips is connected in series and contains current flowing in the same
direction, therefore generating a field that extends into the brain in a specified
orientation from each location along the scalp. Computerized theoretical calculations were
made in order to optimize the coil design for maximizing the percentage of stimulation in
depth relative to the cortical regions. These, in conjunction with tests performed in a
phantom model, [ref 30, ref28, ref27] demonstrated the ability to stimulate, by means of the
H-Coil, deep brain regions. It may be assumed then that the activation of deep brain regions
and their interconnecting fibers may serve as a new approach in treating neuropsychiatry
illnesses with prominent advantage over the standard coil, unable to affect regions as deep
as the H-Coil. Deep TMS could be more effective than rTMS due to its deeper penetration into
brain tissues [ref28]. The deeper penetration should produce greater action on nerve fibers
connecting the prefrontal cortex to the limbic system.
In a randomized controlled study of deep transcranial magnetic stimulation conducted in
Israel, 32 healthy volunteers (9 of which were tested for H1 coil presented in this report)
were evaluated for possible cognitive impairment. Cognitive evaluation was conducted using
the Cambridge Neuropsychological Test Automated Battery (CANTAB), which is sensitive to
cognitive changes caused by a wide range of Central Nervous System disorders and medication
side-effects. No deterioration in cognitive functions was found, except for a transient
short-term effect of the H1-coil on spatial recognition memory on the first day of rTMS (but
not in the following treatment days). Questionnaires conducted for emotional or mood
alterations, showed no significant changes except for reports on 'detachment' experienced by
subjects treated with the H1-coil.In addition, stimulation with the novel H-coils was found
to be well tolerated, with no adverse physical or neurological outcomes [ref29].
Contraindications to deep TMS are essentially the same as those for rTMS. Absolute
contraindications include history of any metal object in the head, known history of any
metallic particles in the eye, implanted cardiac pacemaker or any intra-cardiac lines,
implanted neurostimulators, surgical clips or any medical pumps, history of cochlear
implants and a history of seizure or heat convulsion. Relative contraindications include
epilepsy or seizure in first degree relatives, history of head injury; frequent or severe
headaches, migraines; hearing loss; drug abuse or alcoholism, pregnancy or not using a
reliable method of birth control and systemic and metabolic disorders.
Methods:
40 patients aged 18-65 years, diagnosed as suffering from pathological gambling according to
DSM-IV-TR will be recruited from outpatient treatment programs at the Beer Yaacov Mental
Health Center. Within 3 days prior to the first treatment session patients will be assessed
by a rater blind to real /sham treatment with the following measures:
1. SCID -version 2
2. Hamilton Depression 24 items
3. Hamilton Anxiety
4. Y-BOCS
5. SOGS (South Oaks Gambling Screen)
6. DAGS (Dannon Ainhold Gambling Scale)
7. VAS (visual analogue scale)
8. CGI-I
9. Social Adaptation Scale (SAS)
10. Complete battery of Neurocognitive tests
Following preliminary assessment, patients will be equally and randomly divided to 2 study
arms as described below:
Real TMS Sham TMS Gambling photos \ videos 20 Patients 20 Patients
Real TMS will be given to the Dorso-lateral prefrontal cortex with the following parameters
:
- Frequency: 1HZ
- Total number of stimulations per session: 600
- Motor threshold percentage: 120%
- Total duration of treatment session (minutes): 10
- Total number of treatment sessions: 15
Deep TMS coil used in this study will be the H-ADD coil (Please see investigator's
brochure).
Patients will undergo 5 courses per week during 3 weeks.
Evaluations (Including the Neurocognitive tests) will be performed 24 hours after the 15th
session and again 1 week after the last session and 1 month after the last session.
