Comparison of Quetiapine and Trazodone Treatment for Insomnia in Dually Diagnosed Veterans

Insomnia Clinical Trial

Official title: Comparison of Quetiapine and Trazodone Treatment for Insomnia in Dually Diagnosed Veterans: an Open (e.g. Unblinded) Randomized Stay-Switch Pilot Trial

Status Terminated

Clinical Trial Summary

This is a pilot comparative effectiveness study designed to determine whether trazodone is as effective as quetiapine for treatment of insomnia in veterans with a history of addiction and mental health issues. The study will have two concurrent phases (parts); first an acceptability determination phase, to determine whether and why (or why not) veterans already taking quetiapine are willing to try an alternative to quetiapine for sleep; and second, a randomized trial phase which will test whether staying on quetiapine has any advantage over switching to trazodone. The purpose of the first phase will be a) to document the proportions of patients and physicians who are willing to agree to such a switch, b) to characterize sociodemographic and clinical characteristics of potentially eligible subjects associated with a willingness to switch from quetiapine to trazodone and c) to record the reasons given why patients and their prescribers are (or are not) willing to accept a switch from quetiapine to trazodone. It will also function to provide some educational background to patients and a reminder to providers about the potential severe side-effects of quetiapine, and will thus facilitate clinical informed consent for the clinical trial phase of the study. Completion of the first part of the study will also serve as the screening component for part II. Part II includes, first, obtaining written informed consent from eligible subjects, and then randomly assigning them to continue quetiapine or to be switched to trazodone in open-label "real world" fashion for the duration of 4 weeks, followed by another four weeks of open, non-randomized follow- up. The purpose of the second part of the study is to determine if trazodone is an adequate substitute for quetiapine, primarily in terms of treating insomnia. The investigators hypothesize that trazodone will not be inferior to quetiapine in maintaining good quality of sleep measured by sleep scales (i.e., scores will not significantly worsen once switched). This study is open to Veterans in the VA system only. Eligible subjects must have a history of "dual diagnosis" (i.e., a history of addiction and mental illness).

Clinical Trial Description

Part I of the study involves identification through VA records of subjects eligible for the study based on their prescription of quetiapine. Potentially eligible subjects will be contacted by the research team. Subjects will answer a brief questionnaire about their experience with the medication quetiapine as used for insomnia. If subjects are interested in participated in part II, the clinical trial portion of the study, they will be further screened for eligibility.

Part II consists of a 4 week clinical trial in which subjects are randomized to stay on quetiapine or switch to trazodone, all of which will be open-label. Subjects will be evaluated for symptoms of sleep quality and excessive daytime sleepiness. subjects will also be assessed for changes in mood, and alcohol/drug use. After the initial 4 week treatment period, subjects on trazodone can choose to switch back to quetiapine or continue on trazodone. Subjects will also be evaluated after an additional 4 weeks (8weeks from start of the study) on outcome measures. ;

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Disease
• Insomnia
• Mental Disorders
• Mental Health Disorder
• Sleep Initiation and Maintenance Disorders
• Substance Use Disorder
• Substance-Related Disorders

• NCT number: NCT01662297
• Study type: Interventional
• Source: VA Connecticut Healthcare System
• Status: Terminated
• Phase: Phase 4
• Start date: July 2012
• Completion date: October 2015