Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Recruiting
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT04656938 |
| Other study ID # |
2018/2353 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Recruiting |
| Phase |
N/A
|
| First received |
|
| Last updated |
|
| Start date |
May 1, 2018 |
| Est. completion date |
May 2021 |
Study information
| Verified date |
December 2020 |
| Source |
Sengkang General Hospital |
| Contact |
Laura Tay |
| Phone |
64722000 |
| Email |
laura.tay.b.g[@]singhealth.com.sg |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
|
| Study type |
Interventional
|
Clinical Trial Summary
The current healthcare response to frailty has been mainly reactive to acute health crises of
the elderly. With its insidious onset and progression, frailty is often not apparent unless
actively sought. Well-validated models of frailty already exist and, instead of trying to
create new frailty criteria or insisting on a universal approach to measuring frailty, it is
needed to move on to higher levels of care systems supporting their practical implementation,
mapping the chosen frailty instrument to its specific role. This pragmatic study will equip
older persons with awareness of their frailty status through community-based screening,
allowing for timely stage-specific care to avoid deleterious outcomes. While older persons
meeting frailty criteria will be referred for comprehensive geriatric assessment, pre-frail
older persons will be targeted for multi-factorial exercise and nutritional intervention in
the community to reverse the frailty trajectory. An over-arching aim will be to create a
sustainable triaging system and early intervention programme that can be administered by
trained members of the community. This will allow older persons to receive regular
re-assessments in the community such that any transitions to a higher state of frailty may be
captured and promptly addressed.
Description:
This is a non-controlled prospective cohort study, recruiting community-dwelling older
persons aged >55 years, from various senior activity centres, day care and community centres
in the North-East region of Singapore. A mobile community-based platform for frailty and
physical fitness assessment will be anchored at the void decks of public housing blocks,
senior activity centres (SACs), senior care centres (SCCs) or community clubs for
accessibility. The platform will be maintained at each site for 2-3 consecutive weeks, and is
managed by members of the multidisciplinary team, with the same site being re-visited at
yearly intervals to allow follow-up. Each participant undergoes a multi-domain geriatric
screen and physical fitness assessment, and will be triaged by physical frailty status for
stage-specific care.
Written informed consent will be obtained from all participants, and ethics approval has been
obtained from the Institutional Review Board of Singhealth.
Measures Multi-domain geriatric screen The multi-domain geriatric screen includes assessment
of (i) socio-demographic characteristics (including social support network, socio-economic
status, education and employment); (ii) mood as assessed using the 15-item Geriatric
Depression Scale; (iii) cognitive performance using the locally validated modified Chinese
version of Mini Mental State Examination (CMMSE); (iv) nutrition using the Mini Nutrition
Assessment-Short Form (MNA-SF) and Subjective Global Assessment (SGA); (iv) physical activity
level based on a structured questionnaire to assess the time spent on physical activities
over the last 7 days; (v) functional performance using Barthel's Index for activities of
daily living (ADLs) and Lawton and Brody's instrumental ADLs, as well as Life Space
Questionnaire (LSQ) for functional mobility; (vi) quality of life on EuroQol 5 dimensions
(EQ-5D-5L) questionnaire and a visual analogue scale; (vii) sarcopenia using SARC-F
questionnaire enquiring ability to carry a heavy load, walking, rising from a chair, climbing
stairs and falls, has been validated as a suitable tool for community screening for
sarcopenia.
Frailty Assessment Frailty screening will be based on the 5-item FRAIL scale, which assesses
for self-reported fatigue, resistance, ambulation, illnesses and loss of weight, to
categorize participants as frail (score 3-5), pre-frail (1-2) or robust (0).
Physical frailty will be objectively assessed using modified Fried's criteria, with frailty
defined by the presence of at least 3 and pre-frailty as 1-2 of 5 components - exhaustion,
slow gait speed, weak grip strength, low body mass index (BMI<18.5kg/m2) and low physical
activity.
Grip strength will be measured using a JAMAR hand dynamometer, with 2 trials for each hand,
and the maximum value will be used for analysis. Gait speed will be based on time taken to
walk 10m at usual pace. Weakness (<18kg for women and <26 kg for men) and slowness (<0.8m/s)
will be defined using reference values from the Asian Working Group for Sarcopenia
Physical Fitness Tests The physical fitness test battery was modified from the Senior Fitness
Test. Participants who report feeling unwell on pre-assessment screening will be exempt from
fitness tests.
Lower body strength and power will be measured using the chair stand test, in which the
participant will be instructed to rise as fast as possible from seated to a full standing
position, while keeping the arms folded across the chest. Time taken to complete 5 chair
stands as well as the number of full chair stands performed in 30 seconds will be recorded.
In addition to grip strength, upper limb dexterity will be assessed using the box-and-block
test, in which participants pick up blocks and place them in the box on the other side across
a barrier as quickly as possible. The number of blocks transferred in 1 minute will be
recorded. 2 trials will be performed, one for each arm, and the better performance will be
used for analysis.
Dual-task gait performance will be assessed by asking the participant to walk 10-metres while
performing serial 2-step forward calculation and animal naming without specific instruction
on task prioritization. Gait speed and number of correct calculations on the dual-task
protocol will be recorded.
Upper and lower body flexibility will be assessed using the back-scratch and chair
sit-and-reach tests respectively, with 2 trials for each test, and the better performance
will be used for analysis. The back-scratch test is performed with the participant placing
one hand behind the shoulder and the other hand up the middle of the back, fingers extended.
The distance (cm) the middle fingers are short of touching (-) or overlapping (+) will be
recorded. In the chair sit-and-reach test, participant sits on the edge of a chair with one
leg extended in front while reaching forward with the hands toward the toes. The distance
(cm) from the extended third finger to tip of toe (+ for beyond, and - for behind the toe)
will be recorded.
Dynamic balance (agility) will be assessed on the Timed Up-and-Go Test, which requires the
participant to stand from a seated position, walk as quickly as possible around a cone 3m
ahead of the chair, and return to a fully seated position. The balance subtests of the Short
Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) was also adopted, including side-by-side, semi-tandem and
tandem standing.
Cardiorespiratory endurance will be evaluated using the 6-minute walk test (6MWT), along a
walkway of at least 20m and with constant encouragement throughout the test. The total
distance walked in 6 minutes will be recorded, and rest is permitted anytime during the test.
Each participant will be scored on the SPPB for a composite measure of physical performance,
applying established cut-offs on the individual tests of gait speed, balance and chair stand.
Body Composition Participants will under Bioimpedance Analysis (BIA) (MC-780M, TANITA, Tokyo,
Japan) for measurement of muscle mass.
Intervention for pre-frail older adults Pre-frail will be operationalized as the presence of
1-2 positive responses on FRAIL, or FRAIL score of 0 but with objective weak grip strength
and/or slow gait speed. The latter takes into consideration the potential for under-reporting
of symptoms on the FRAIL questionnaire.
Participants meeting operational criteria for pre-frailty will be enrolled in a group-based
physical exercise and nutritional intervention programme, delivered over 4 months. The
intervention will commence 3 months from the baseline screening.
Group-based, as opposed to traditional individual physiotherapy sessions, has been shown to
boost older persons' motivation for participation and potentially addresses the social
contribution to frailty.
Participants will undergo weekly 1-hr exercise sessions designed to challenge all major
muscle groups with specific emphasis on strength training, in addition to gait, balance and
endurance exercises, to target the major frailty elements of weakness and gait deficit, with
demonstrated effectiveness for falls prevention in older adults. Upper limb strengthening
exercises will be conducted through the use of therabands or free weights (e.g. bottled
water) for resistance. The exercises will be made progressively more difficult over time
(e.g. increasing the number of repetitions) according to group's progress, yet also catering
for individual variability, under supervision of the physiotherapist. Endurance exercise will
consist of outdoor walking. Targeting to each older adult's individual intensity level with
progression as they improve ensures that the exercises remain physically challenging to
provide sufficient stimulus. An individually prescribed structured home exercise programme
with pictorials and explanations at the end of each session will be provided so that
participants can continue with the exercises between sessions to achieve an optimal frequency
of exercising at least three times a week, with a checklist to record adherence.
Nutritional intervention (6 group-based session) will be delivered with the aim of
facilitating healthy eating habits to achieve adequate protein, energy, Vitamin D and fluid
intake through regular foods and beverages without the need for nutritional supplements.
Educating older adults to evaluate and adapt their nutritional intake, taking into
consideration their dietary habits, can be expected to improve sustainability of effect and
adherence. A group grocery-shopping trip will be conducted to provide guidance on choosing
quality food within budget.
All participants will be followed up at 6-, 12- and 24-month. Participants enrolled in the
intervention programme will have their physical performance measures at 3-month (immediate
pre-intervention). Subsequent follow-up visits will be at the end of the 4-month
intervention, 6- and 12-month post-intervention.
