Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic Clinical Trial
Official title:
Neurofeedback Preventive Intervention for PTSD: a Method to Strengthen Mental and Emotional Resilience
Exposure to life threatening, traumatic and stress inducing events in general is an inevitable part of military combat service . Among individuals exposed to a traumatic event, approximately 85-90 % will develop a stress response from which they will recover without need for any medical intervention whatsoever. However, roughly 10-15 % will continue to suffer from post-traumatic symptoms along with depression or anxiety disorders1, . The prominent symptoms of post - traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), consists of reliving the event via invasive and painful memories that include: images, thoughts or feelings, night terrors, and extreme emotional distress that arise when exposure to external or internal cues similar to or symbolizing aspects of the traumatic event. Following this distress, behavioral avoidance of situations that trigger unpleasant memories may develop. Such mental stress may lead to avoidance of social situations and hinder normal daily functioning in a variety of contexts2. The question arises as to what distinguishes between those who are exposed to a traumatic event and recover spontaneously and those who fail to resume daily life and develop PTSD. Attempts to find personality and environmental risk factors for the development of PTSD have yet to yield any unequivocal conclusions. This has lead the scientific community to look for neuro-physical risk factors as well . Furthermore, evidence that early diagnosis and treatment of the disorder helps reduce the severity of post-trauma symptoms -stresses the need for the accurate localization of neurological risk factors and new immediate and/or preventative interventions. The aim of the present project is to develop a brain oriented training method for early preventive interventions of PTSD.
The most significant disadvantage of the current EEG-NF method is the low spatial resolution
of the EEG, which does not allow for the localization of site activity within deep brain
regions known to be associated with the development of PTSD, such as the amygdala, the
hippocampus, and the mPFC. The aim of the present project is to overcome this drawback by
integrating EEG and fMRI imaging methods, such that the patient will receive real-time
feedback regarding the activation of emotional target areas located deep within the brain.
FMRI is based on the measurement of metabolic changes following electrical activity in the
brain, thus non-invasively representing the neuronal activity of various brain regions when
performing emotional and/or cognitive tasks. fMRI has high spatial resolution, and in
contrast to EEG - it allows for the localization of regions deep within the brain, such as
those related to trauma responses within the limbic system and prefrontal cortex. Recently,
real-time fMRI (rt fMRI) has been used to train subjects to modulate activity within deep
brain regions , . Some studies have even shown that subjects can be trained to regulate
activity within a network of regions including the mPFC and limbic regions, resulting in a
positive effect on patients suffering from chronic pain and depression . Moreover, it has
also been found that via real-time fMRI feedback subjects can be trained to regulate activity
within networks that have been linked to emotional regulation; a skill critical for dealing
with traumatic events . The major disadvantage of this method is that fMRI tests are
expensive and inconvenient for the patient, and the MRI machine required for this method are
stationary and not easily accessible.
To combine the advantages of both methods the investigators performed simultaneous testing of
both EEG and fMRI. Using special algorithms, with high reliability, the investigators studied
the electrical signals that represent activity related to emotional regulation within deep
brain regions . This combination allowed for a significant improvement in the spatial
resolution of the EEG device and added significant temporal information taken from the fMRI
signal. The combined recording of EEG and fMRI with advanced computational methods, such as
cross correlation and machine learning, provide significant improvement in the attribution of
EEG signal localization, which until now could not be achieved with adequate reliability. In
other words, the EEG pattern of activity reliably represents activation of deep limbic
regions providing an "electrical fingerprint" (EFP) of these areas.
Accordingly, the investigators developed an innovative treatment protocol in which subjects
are asked to control either visual or auditory stimuli, determined by feedback from the
brain, based on the extent of the EFP . In a pilot study on a group of civilians the
investigators showed that subjects successfully learned to modify their electrical brain
signal based on the EFP . In an additional study, simultaneous recordings of EEG and fMRI
showed that success was indeed related to changes in activity within deep brain regions
involved in emotional regulation; such as the mPFC and hippocampus. Furthermore, our results
indicate that following training to volitionally regulate the EFP via EEG-NF, participants
exhibited improved emotion regulation .
Rationale for current study:
Based on the EFP model and the NF literature in the treatment of PTSD this study aims to
examine the efficiency of an fMRI-guided-EEG-protocol for self-regulation through NF for
reducing stress vulnerability.
The study will assign two groups:
experimental group: EFP neurofeedback control groups: Sham neurofeedback In order to assess
the efficiency of the NF protocol as a preventative intervention for PTSD, the investigators
plan to compare this treatment outcomes to those of a placebo sham protocol.
Primary objective:
Examine the efficiency of NF in reducing stress vulnerability.
Secondary objective:
Examine the efficiency of amygdala targeted Neurofeedback (NF) in reducing stress symptoms
among individuals who were recently exposed to a traumatic event. .
Study design:
Randomized parallel design, with 2 groups: EFP-NF (n=35), Sham-NF (n=35)
Participant selection:
The study will involve 40 participants with PTSD symptoms between the ages of 18-40, who will
be divided randomly into 2 groups (experimental group, control group).
Number of participants:
The study will involve 70 individuals.
Recruitment process:
Participants will be recruited from the ER and trauma clinic at TASMC. The hospital will
provide our research team with daily lists of the individuals who arrived at the ER over the
past 24 hours, screened for possible trauma related incidents. Our team will then contact the
potential subjects over the phone and will request informed consent to conduct a phone
interview to assess the presence of acute stress symptoms. A brief description of the study
will be provided. If the individual agrees and is found suitable for further participation
they will be invited to the trauma clinic at TASMC where a trained clinical psychologist will
conduct a comprehensive PTSD evaluation. The trauma clinic at TASMC will also refer suitable
patients from within their database for participation in our study. All subjects referred by
the trauma clinic will undergo identical procedures for obtaining informed consent and
subsequent clinical evaluation as those described above.
Intervention arms:
The study will include 2 groups. The experimental group will receive EEG-NF sessions targeted
on the amygdalae and the control group will Sham-NF.
Brain area/s of interest:
The regions of interest will include the limbic system and more specifically the Amygdala,
hippocampus ventral striatum, as well as cortical areas associated with emotional regulation
(such as dorso-lateral PFC and dorso and ventro-medial PFC cingulated cortex and insula).
Study procedures:
Pre treatment phase Day 1 Participants will undergo a psychiatric evaluation (using SCID),
and medication monitoring. Participants will also be asked to fill in demographic and
psychological questionnaires assessing emotion regulation abilities (ERQ), state anxiety and
traits (STAI), and questionnaires measuring symptoms of stress, anxiety and depression (CAPS,
PCL, BDI).
Day 2 All Participants will undergo a brain-imaging scan to characterize brain network
responses associated with emotional arousal and regulation. Participants will be scanned for
functional and structural MRI which will include ROI localizer for the NF, resting state,
emotional conflict task, facial recognition task reward task and DTI.
The research staff will explain the course of the MRI testing to the participant, and will
enter with the subject into the mock simulator to verify that he is lying on his back
properly and feels comfortable. During testing the patient will be presented with visual and
auditory stimuli, as well as short video clips. Auditory presentation: stimuli will be heard
via MRI-compatible headphones. Visual displays: the subject will view the stimuli through a
mirror and projected onto a screen in the magnet room. In between sessions the patient will
be given time to rest. Participants will be asked to avoid moving as much as possible during
the scans.
The total duration of testing, from subject arrival to departure, will take approximately
90-180 minutes (20-30 minutes to fill out forms and undergo training, 30 minutes for
explanations and a break, and 60 minutes of imaging). Participants will remain in the MRI for
about 60 minutes, and under no circumstances will remain longer than 90 minutes.
Training phase The duration of the training phase will be 4 weeks. At this point participants
will be randomly assigned to either the EFP-NF or T/A-NF groups. Both the EFP-NF and the
T/A-NF groups will receive 1-2 sessions per week for a total of 6 sessions.
During training sessions, participants will train to develop skills for regulating brain
activity using auditory or visual feedback. Each session will last an hour, including EEG Cap
placement and filling state questionnaires. The participant will be seated comfortably in
front of a computer screen. A staff member will explain the goal of the meeting to the
participant, introduce the equipment to be used, and describe the course of the meeting.
Following the above explanations, the staff member will place the EEG cap on the
participant's head and will ensure that the participant feels comfortable. The EEG -
Neurofeedback practice will consist of five-minute segments repeated for up to 30 minutes.
During each practice segment the participant will be asked to modify any visual or auditory
media that provides feedback on the degree of successful brain training. For example, during
visual feedback the participants will be asked to lower the speed of a skateboard presented
on the computer screen or alternatively, during auditory feedback to reduce the level of
music audible through headphones placed on their ears. After every two practice segments, the
duration of each practice will increase such that the two first steps will be very short
(about 5 minutes each) and the last two the longest (about 10 minutes each); a total of six
steps every trial over a total of approximately 45 minutes
Post treatment phase This phase will take place 3-5 days after the end of the training phase.
Day 1
- Participants will undergo a second psychological evaluation (CAPS).
- Participants will complete the same questionnaires as in the pre treatment phase (BDI,
ERQ, STAI, PCL).
Day 2 • All Participants will be scanned for functional and structural MRI which will include
ROI localizer, resting state, DTI.
Follow-up phase Day 1-5
• All participants will receive 2 maintenance sessions (EFP-NF or T/A-NF)
Day 6
- Participants will undergo a third psychological evaluation (CAPS).
- Participants will complete the same questionnaires as in the previous phases (BDI, ERQ,
STAI, PCL).
Data collection:
Researchers will assist participants filling in the electronic questionnaires and will
conduct the non electronic ones (these would be later transcribed to excel sheets by research
assistants).
Researchers will run the MRI scans and the NF sessions (all the rt-fMRI NF and some of the
EFP-NF), together with two to five research assistants. The contact with the participants
will be by E-mail and phone. The research assistants will monitor participation. The
participants will receive a reminder (by phone and or email) one day prior to each session.
;
Status | Clinical Trial | Phase | |
---|---|---|---|
Recruiting |
NCT05620381 -
Health and Sleep Assessment After the Strasbourg Attacks of December 11, 2018
|
||
Completed |
NCT02856412 -
Improving Mind/Body Health and Functioning With Integrative Exercise
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT05400200 -
PTSD and Self-regulation: Coping, Emotional Regulation and Cognitive Control and Their Relationships to Symptom Management
|
N/A | |
Not yet recruiting |
NCT06088303 -
Enhancing PTSD Treatment Outcomes by Improving Patient-Provider Communication
|
N/A | |
Not yet recruiting |
NCT03652922 -
Propranolol Reactivation Mismatch (PRM) Treatment for PTSD
|
Phase 4 | |
Completed |
NCT02875912 -
Prospective Evaluation of Family Care Rituals in the ICU
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01589575 -
Anxiety and Depression in Relatives of Critically Ill Patients: Spouses Versus Other Close Relatives
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01291368 -
Sedation Influence on Delirium and Post-traumatic Stress-disorder as a Result of Hospitalization in Intensive Care
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00990106 -
Augmentation Trial of Prazosin for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
|
N/A | |
Active, not recruiting |
NCT00657787 -
Development of a Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) Population Registry for Veterans
|
||
Completed |
NCT00835627 -
Treatment Trial for Psychogenic Nonepileptic Seizures
|
Phase 4 | |
Completed |
NCT01365247 -
Concurrent Treatment for Substance Dependent Individuals With Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00880152 -
Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Pilot Study
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00419029 -
Motivational Interviewing to Engage Operations Enduring Freedom and Iraqi Freedom (OEF/OIF) Veterans in Mental Health Treatment
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00514956 -
Effect of Emotional Freedom Technique and Diaphragmatic Breathing on Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
|
Phase 1 | |
Completed |
NCT00333710 -
Evaluating a Telehealth Treatment for Veterans With Hepatitis C and PTSD
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01120847 -
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), Sleep Disordered Breathing And Genetics: Effects On Cognition
|
||
Completed |
NCT00069225 -
Brain Structure and Function Before and After Treatment for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00055354 -
Acupuncture for the Treatment of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00186212 -
Alternative Support for Rural and Isolated Women in an HMO
|
Phase 3 |