Chronic Illness Clinical Trial
Official title:
Enhancing Self-care Through Opportunistic Motivational Techniques, Used by Community Nurses, While Caring for Housebound Patients With Long-term Conditions: a Mixed Methods Feasibility Study
The prevalence of people living with problems due to a long-term condition (LTC) such as
heart disease, diabetes or arthritis in England exceeds 15 million, and the number of those
with more than one LTC continues to grow (LTCs). This population consumes a large proportion
of health service resources. Advancing age and LTCs increase the likelihood of becoming
housebound, this has a detrimental effect on health and quality of life. Health policy
advocates a health service model of empowerment and self-care. People who live with LTCs are
often very knowledgeable about how to look after their health but find it difficult to adjust
their.
Motivational techniques have been demonstrated to facilitate behaviour change through
changing the style of communication from directive to collaborative. The use of
patient-centred conversational style of communication has been shown to elicit more
willingness to change than professional-led directive consultations. Community nurses are in
a unique position to influence housebound patients to play a greater part in caring for
themselves, preventing complications in their long-term conditions and further ill health.
This study intends to test the feasibility and acceptability of training community nurses in
Understanding Behaviour Change, a communication technique which uses motivational
interviewing to guide patients to change their behaviour. The opportunistic use of
motivational techniques to create participatory relationships between patients, community
nurses potentially represents an effective intervention to enable patients with LTCs to
optimise the way they care for themselves.
Motivational interviewing techniques have been widely demonstrated to bring about behaviour
change but have not been studied in the context of changing the style of communication
between housebound patients and the professionals caring for them.
Study Design and Methods This study has a pragmatic mixed methods explanatory design,
consisting of a clinical trial and a qualitative study. The results of the trial will be used
to inform the interview protocol for the qualitative study, the data from which will be
analysed to explore and elaborate on the results from the trial.
Phase one: Clinical Trial Design This is a parallel controlled, single blinded trial. The
outcomes of the patients cared for by nurses who have undergone UBC will be compared with the
outcomes from patients who have received usual care.
Population: All patients referred to the caseload of the community nursing teams will be
considered for inclusion in this trial. If the patients are on the community caseload they
will be considered housebound at the time of treatment as this is the criteria for acceptance
onto the caseload. The criteria of infrequent absences from home which are short in duration
and require taxing effort is used in line with the Medicare definition of homebound (U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services 2010).
Blinding: The patients will not be told whether or not they are being cared for by nurses who
have received UBC training.
Randomisation: It is intended that a trial resulting from this study would have a random
controlled cluster design to overcome this. All eligible patients in one locality will be
exposed to the intervention and all eligible patients in the other locality will not be
exposed. Randomising at community nursing team level in a cluster trial could lead to
contamination, as within the locality nurses may cover for other teams at weekends and during
periods of staff absence. If this feasibility study leads to a larger trial, it would be
possible to randomise at locality level to reduce bias. Non-randomised feasibility studies do
not have reduced validity (Craig et al 2008).
Setting: This feasibility study is planned to take place within two neighbouring Clinical
Commissioning Groups (CCG) that serve a population of 335,000 people (Office for National
Statistics 2011). The intervention locality has nine community nursing teams linked to GP
practices and grouped as three clusters. The patients in the usual care arm of the trial will
be recruited from a neighbouring CCG which has a similar configuration of community nursing
teams, including community matrons and specialist nurses. All the nursing working with
patients in the intervention cluster will be trained in UBC.
Sample: All patients are potential participants if they are admitted to community caseloads.
In the locality where UBC is to be used, all the patients seen by the nurses will be exposed
to motivational techniques. The participants will be those patients who are newly and
consecutively referred to the caseload of either the intervention community nurse teams or
the control teams and are expected to have three or more contacts with the community nurses.
Recruitment procedure All patients are potential participants if they meet the inclusion
criteria. Once identified the staff caring for them will explain the study and give them the
information sheet. If they are interested in participating they will be given a consent form.
They will be contacted the next day by phone to ask if they are willing to participate. If
they are willing, at the next visit, the usual carer or the investigator will discuss the
study with them and determine their understanding of participating. If they understand they
will be asked to sign a consent form. Their part in the trial will consist of completing
questionnaires at the start and 3 months into their treatment. The questionnaires will be
administered by either a member of the care team or the researcher. The final Questionnaire
will be given to them by a member of the usual care team or the researcher. The
questionnaires can be administered either face to face or by phone depending on the
participants' wishes. Questionnaires will be supplied with envelopes to encourage candid
responses. Health service use will be measured through the investigator accessing this data
from electronic records, with the patients consent, at referral and three months after
intervention.
Intervention: Understanding Behaviour Change (UBC) training. UBC training is structured on
the Prevention and Lifestyle Behaviour Change: Competency Framework (National Institute for
Health and Clinical Excellence 2007). The training is accredited by the Royal Society for
Public Health (RSPB). The training aims to enable learners to understand behaviours
associated with active listening, effective hearing, reflecting, checking understanding and
their use in effective communication. UBC training also identifies enabling approaches to
building relationships, knowledge of behaviour change models and how to explore an
individual's motivation to adopt positive health behaviours. The training will enhance the
trainees' skills in supporting individuals to develop strategies to enable them to plan and
implement changes in their lifestyle or health behaviour. The training is supported with role
play to develop communication skills.
Sixteen members of staff from the community nursing team leads, community matrons, and
specialist nurses will be trained as motivational champions with UBC consisting of two days
of face-to-face training. The motivational Champions will take a multiple-choice exam set by
an external examiner to assess their knowledge. The remaining 20 staff will have one session
of four hours training, face-to-face, and including role play. The training will be provided
by the KCHT Improvement Team in a venue within the locality. The champions will provide
supervision and encouragement in the use of the UBC Intervention through monthly action
learning sets. The action learning sets will be attended by two motivational champions and
two or three other staff. This allows the staff to reflect on their experiences of using UBC
and share the learning they have acquired. To evaluate their professional development the
champions will be asked to complete a questionnaire before undertaking the training and one
month afterwards. This will explore their knowledge and confidence in behaviour change and
the barriers and facilitators to implementing their learning. Themes from the questionnaires
will be discussed in the action learning sets.
Intervention fidelity All staff will have an assessment of a patient audiotaped and assessed
by the researcher for use of UBC using the Peer Proficiency Assessment (PEPA) (Mastroleo et
al 2009). This process will be explained to patients when they first consent to being part of
the study and again before the recording takes place. The audio-recorder will be encrypted
and the recordings will be analysed using the PEPA tool, by the investigator, and then
deleted. The PEPA tool was developed to evaluate the fidelity to use of MI skills in
undergraduate peer counsellors. PEPA is a valid tool which is simple to use and demonstrates
high inter-rater reliability between master coders, experienced peer counsellors and
minimally trained peer counsellors (Mastroleo et al 2009).
Phase two: Interview study Aim: To explore the intervention arm patients' experience of the
service they receive, their interactions with the nurses and any impact it has on their
ability to care for themselves.
Design: Qualitative Method: An interview protocol will be developed, informed by the analysis
of the quantitative data. Interviews allow rich data to be collected, guided by topic
headings in the specific research area. This creates flexibility and focus but depends upon
the interviewer having the skills to listen actively, reflectively and attentively while
guiding and controlling the quality of the data (Polit & Beck 2008). Each interview is
expected to take about an hour but may be shorter, depending on the wishes and health of the
individual patient. The interviews will be audio taped with permission and the interviewer
will take additional anonymised notes identifying patients with a unique number.
Sample: Six patients from the intervention group will be interviewed for rich qualitative
data, to explore their views and perception of how the community nurses talked to them and
any impact it has had on how they care for themselves. The sample to be interviewed will be
selected to represent the extremes of results from the Consultation and relational empathy
measure (Mercer et al 2004). It is initially intended to interview six participants, but if
important themes and differences are found it may be necessary to widen this inquiry to
explore the phenomena fully (Kelly 2010).
Analysis: The audiotapes will be transcribed verbatim, by the investigator or an agency used
for medical transcription by KCHT, and checked for accuracy by the interviewer. The
transcripts will be shared with the patient to check that they are a true representation of
their intended meaning. The audio tapes will be deleted after transcription; transcripts will
be anonymised using a patient identification number. The transcripts will be read with the
notes taken during the interview for meaning. They will be re-read to identify themes that
best capture the essential qualities of that interview. Themes from within each section of
the transcript will be identified, and possible or likely connections between themes sought.
A qualitative code book will be developed. The data will be coded and the codes assigned
labels. The codes will be grouped into themes, interrelated and assigned to a smaller set of
categories. Computer assisted data analysis software NVivo will be used to organise and
support rigorous data analysis (St John & Johnson 2004).
Bias: The researcher, who will not be delivering care to this group of patients, will
interview the participants using critical reflexivity, to guard against personal bias, and
the writing of memos to acknowledge personal preferences, theoretical leanings and investment
in the research process (Polit & Beck 2008).
Integration of quantitative and qualitative results:
The quantitative data will be examined with the data from the qualitative phase, to test and
refine the explanations for the outcomes (Cresswell & Plano Clark 2012) and inform the design
of a future study.
;
Status | Clinical Trial | Phase | |
---|---|---|---|
Terminated |
NCT03048565 -
A Trial of an Online Mindfulness Based Programme for Informal Caregivers of People With Chronic Illnesses
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT05785494 -
Web-based Support for Family Caregivers of Patients With Advanced Cancer
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT03601884 -
Effectiveness of OHP in Improving Self-efficacy in Patients With Diabetes Mellitus
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT03170167 -
Communitas: A Program for Teens Living With Chronic Illness and Their Families
|
||
Completed |
NCT01955005 -
Use of the My HealtheVet for Health Information Sharing
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01107119 -
Integrated Care Pathways in a Community Setting
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00194584 -
Childhood Chronic Illness: An Educational Program for Parents of Children With On-Going Health Care Needs
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT03434626 -
Advance Care Planning & Goals of Care Randomized Controlled Trial in Primary Care
|
N/A | |
Recruiting |
NCT05437978 -
"Sport on Prescription" in Primary Care for Patients With Long-term Illnesses
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT03067207 -
In-Person vs e-Health Mindfulness-Based Intervention for Adolescents With Chronic Illness
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT02277327 -
Trial to Reduce Hospitalizations in Children With Medical Complexity
|
Phase 2 | |
Recruiting |
NCT01480765 -
Preventing Pain After Heart Surgery
|
Phase 4 | |
Completed |
NCT01834456 -
Comprehensive Care of Children With Medical Complexity
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00773942 -
Design & Evaluation of a Medication Therapy Management Program to Improve Patient Safety in Medicare Beneficiaries
|
N/A | |
Terminated |
NCT00399373 -
Structuring the Integration of Care Management Services For Medicaid Enrollees Recipients With Chronic Illness, Substance Abuse Problems and Possible Psychiatric Disorders
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01321853 -
Home Care Medication Management Program for the Frail Elderly
|
Phase 1 | |
Completed |
NCT03295097 -
Characteristics and Clinical Implications of a Clinical Decision Support System
|
N/A | |
Suspended |
NCT04978610 -
Virtual ACT for Adolescent Stress
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01797068 -
Patient Navigation for Medicaid Frequent ED Users
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT02386189 -
Pilot Study to Improve Care Coordination
|
N/A |