HO Prophylaxis Therapy for Distal Humerus Fractures

Radiation Therapy Clinical Trial

Official title: Prophylaxis Low-Dose Radiation Therapy for Heterotopic Ossification in Distal Humerus Fractures

Status Terminated

Clinical Trial Summary

To determine the effectiveness of 500 cGy dose of radiation therapy vs. an untreated group in the prophylactic treatment of heterotopic ossification in distal humerus fractures

Clinical Trial Description

Heterotopic ossification is the formation of ectopic lamellar bone in the soft tissues. The process is thought to occur through local and distal recruitment osteoprogenitor cells especially mesenchymal stem cells which lead to HO formation based on local microenvironmental factors including activation of the BMP-mediated pathways.1 There are several risk factors associated with HO development such as central nervous system injury, thermal burn, hip arthroplasty, acetabular fractures, and elbow fractures; HO is also seen with certain arteriopathies and genetic conditions e.g. ankylosing spondylitis, seronegative arteriopathies, diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis (DISH), and fibrodysplasia ossificans progressive. In elbow fractures, the prevalence of HO is around 40%, and of those that develop HO, 20% experience a clinically relevant decrease in elbow range of motion with a flexion-extension arc of <100°. In a study by Foruria, et al. of 89 patients with a distal humerus fracture without associated proximal radius or ulna fracture that underwent surgical treatment with ORIF, 42% developed HO and the HO in these patients was associated with significantly less extension and a limited flexion-extension arc but was not associated with a change in supination or pronation. Abrams, et al. looked at the development of HO after elbow fracture fixation in 89 pts including 20 distal humerus fractures and found that distal humeral fractures were more likely to have higher grade of HO, have more compromised functional outcomes, and require return to the OR more often for capsular release with HO resection at a rate of 25%. Prophylactic treatment for HO is most commonly achieved through the use of NSAIDs such as indomethacin and radiation therapy. Both modalities have the risk of nonunion of fracture and radiation therapy has additional risks such as delayed wound healing, soft tissue contracture, and the theoretical risk of malignancy although no cases of malignancy after prophylactic radiation have been reported to date. Radiation therapy in the prevention of HO has been well studied in the hip with low-dose radiation being established as an effective dose and 700cGy as the most commonly used dose.5 Radiation therapy in the prevention of HO at the elbow is not as well studied and existing studies have commonly used a dose of 700cGy. One study looked at the use of radiation therapy in combination of patients being treated acutely for elbow trauma and patients being treated for HO after previous elbow trauma, and the study found that 3 of the 36 patients developed new HO and found an occurrence of 2 nonunion with the majority treated with 700cGy but 2 pts received 600cGy.6 Heyd, et al. present a case series of 9 patients that underwent surgical excision of clinically significant HO at the elbow and received radiation therapy of 2 doses of 500cGy, 1 dose of 600 cGy , or 1 dose of 700 cGy ; at a mean follow up of 7.7 no patients had recurrence of HO and 8 of 9 showed clinical improvement.7 A study of 11 patients that underwent ORIF for fracture-dislocation of the elbow and single-dose radiation therapy of 700 cGy within 72 hours postoperatively, and 3 patients (27%) developed radiographic evidence of HO while 10 patients (91%) had no functional limitations and 100% of patients completely healed there fracture without complications at average follow up of 12 months (9-24 months). 3 of the 11 patients had distal humerus fractures and none of them had radiographic evidence of HO or functional limitation.8 A recent multicenter randomized control trial of patients with intraarticular distal humerus fractures or fracture-dislocation of the elbow with proximal ulna and/or radius fracture randomized patients to either receive a single dose of 700cGy within 72 hours postop or receive nothing for HO prophylaxis. Although, HO occurrence in the 21 patients in the treatment group vs the 24 in the control group (33% vs 54%), the rate of nonunion was higher in the treatment group (38% vs 4%) resulting in termination of the study. Several studies have demonstrated the efficacy and safety of radiation therapy in the prophylactic treatment of HO in the elbow, but the study by Hamid questions the use of a 700 cGy dose because of the rate of nonunion observed. Thus, the investigators hypothesize that a dose of 500 cGy will be adequate in the elbow HO prevention as there is smaller treatment area compared to the hip where 700 cGy is an effective dose and that this dose will not result in an increased rate of nonunion.

Early osteoprogenitor cells involved in bone repair are thought to be more radiosensitive than the more mature cells seen later in the development of bone formation after fracture. Thus, radiation specifically works to inhibit the osteogenic pathway. Based on a recent Cochrane review, the incidence of HO development with any dose of RT was 24%. The was no correlation with site (hip, elbow, knee) or radiation dose, which ranged from 500cGy - 2000cGy. The most commonly used regimen was 700cGy (60%) while dose less than 700cGy represented 12%. The problem with 700cGy is the reported rate of non-union is as high as 40%, especially when the elbow is treated. Additionally, increasing radiation dose alters the expression of transforming growth factor-beta 1, vascular endothelial growth factor, and alkaline phosphatase which can prevent bone union. Based on this data, 500cGy should still be adequate to inhibit the osteogenic pathway by causing lethal damage to osteoprogenitor cells while at the same potentially allowing for a better bone union. ;

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Fractures, Bone
• Heterotopic Ossification
• Humeral Fractures
• Ossification, Heterotopic
• Radiation Therapy

• NCT number: NCT03724422
• Study type: Interventional
• Source: University of Louisville
• Status: Terminated
• Phase: N/A
• Start date: October 9, 2019
• Completion date: November 17, 2020