Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Completed
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT02108769 |
| Other study ID # |
Pro00024336 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Completed |
| Phase |
N/A
|
| First received |
April 3, 2014 |
| Last updated |
April 7, 2014 |
| Start date |
October 2013 |
| Est. completion date |
November 2013 |
Study information
| Verified date |
April 2014 |
| Source |
Medical University of South Carolina |
| Contact |
n/a |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
Institutional Review Board:USA |
| Study type |
Interventional
|
Clinical Trial Summary
Our aim is to analyze two ancient Tamil practices (chanting and breathing exercise) if they
are capable of stimulating saliva containing agents that can be beneficial to the nervous
system. Our study subjects will perform Tamil chanting and Tamil breathing exercise. Saliva
will be collected before, during and after the exercises. We will quantify the specific
proteins in these salivary samples. The results will benefit further studies in various
patient populations.
Description:
A. SPECIFIC AIMS
SA1: Obtain a preliminary estimate of the extent to which a structured chanting exercise
stimulates salivary secretion that contains quantifiable amounts of NGF in healthy subjects.
SA2: Obtain a preliminary estimate of the extent to which a structured breathing exercise
stimulates salivary secretion that contains quantifiable amounts of NGF in healthy subjects.
B. BACKGROUND AND SIGNIFICANCE BACKGROUND Neurodegenerative Diseases Neurodegenerative
diseases such as Alzheimer's disease are a major healthcare concern globally. In the USA, AD
is the 6th leading cause of death. Both genetic and non-genetic factors contribute to the
development of AD. Individuals affected with AD require supports ranging from medications,
assisting devices and personal care that pose an enormous emotional and financial burden. AD
is associated with significant alterations at the molecular level that eventually translates
into cellular, tissue, organ and systemic dysfunction. Therefore, molecular therapy that
alters cell functions has been a major clinical option for treating AD . For example, NGF, a
trophic factor involved in the development, maintenance and survival of peripheral nervous
system and the cholinergic neurons of the central nervous system, show significant reduction
in AD subjects. The reduction in NGF causes significant decline in cognitive functions.
Therefore administration of NGF is followed as a viable clinical option for AD subjects. In
addition to these therapeutic options, non-pharmacological modes of treatment such as
meditation and yoga have been considered as alternative approaches to treat AD. Such
practices and life-styles are deeply rooted in several ancient cultures. This project is
based on two life-style health practices from the ancient Tamil culture.
NGF Nerve growth factor (NGF) is a neurotrophic protein (MW=13 kDa). NGF is produced by
every tissue/organ that is innervated by sensory afferents and/or sympathetic efferents, as
well as by central (CNS) and peripheral (PNS) nervous system, and immune cells. NGF is
important for the functional integrity of cholinergic neurons in CNS and for the development
and functional integrity of neurons in PNS. NGF is a survival, differentiation and trophic
factor for cells of the immune system and epithelial origin. Salivary glands
(submandibular/submaxillary) produce a large amount of NGF in humans and in mice. NGF
produced from mouse submaxillary glands is used in several clinical trials. In CNS, NGF is
produced in the cortex, the hippocampus and in the pituitary gland; and also in other areas,
including the basal ganglia, thalamus, spinal cord and in the retina. NGF binds to its
receptor TrkA and activates the mitogenic MAPK, PI3K/Akt and PLC-gamma pathways to mediate
cell growth, differentiation and survival. NGF mediated survival is important for the basal
forebrain complex (BFC) cholinergic neurons. These neurons contribute to consciousness,
memory, attention and arousal. BFC neurons are highly affected in neurodegenerative diseases
such as AD. NGF protects BFC neurons in experimental trauma models, and in age-associated
cholinergic decline. Due to the positive effects of NGF in multiple systems, development of
NGF as a drug is actively pursued for treating neurodegeneration, immune dysregulation,
chronic inflammation and autoimmune diseases. However, until recently clinical trials with
NGF have been without much success because of hyperalgesia. Recent studies are showing that
gene therapy, nasal and ocular routes of NGF administration to be effective with much less
nociceptive side effect. Moreover, a recent finding that chemical modification of NGF
reduces pain is considered as a new direction in NGF therapy. A Phase II clinical trial
assessing the beneficial effects of an adeno-associated virus mediated expression of NGF in
the cholinergic neurons of the brain is underway at MUSC involving the co-investigator of
this project Dr. Jacobo Mintzer.
NGF is taken up from the target organs by the innervating neurons and transported to axonal
body by retrograde axonal transport. Researchers have used quantum-dot labeled NGF to show
that each NGF dimer is packaged into individual endosomes during retrograde transport.
Retrograde axonal transport of NGF signals for the survival, differentiation, and
maintenance of peripheral sympathetic and sensory neurons, and basal forebrain cholinergic
neurons. Botulinum toxin follows a retrograde pathway to reach central neurons.
Additionally, it was recently confirmed that Botulinum neurotoxins A and E reach distal
sites in the nervous system via retrograde long range transport via motor neurons and
suggested that this mechanism could be common for the dissemination of other neurotrophic
factors as well. This might explain why intranasal application of NGF is considered
effective for NGF therapy. In addition, the sublingual route of absorption that bypasses
gastrointestinal route is used for the application of nitroglycerine and other psychoactive
agents. Thus, our rationale that NGF produced by the salivary glands is taken up by 1) the
innervating sensory and motor neurons for retrograde axonal transport to the cell body and
transcytosis to reach the central neurons, and 2) the sublingual absorption route into the
bloodstream to reach other distal target organs is well within the theoretical framework of
production and transport mechanisms established for neuromodulators. It is to be emphasized
here that this proposal is the first ever attempt to stimulate NGF by non-invasive methods.
Chanting Chanting and singing are two ancient cultural practices in human history. Recent
evidence suggest that these two practices can regulate breathing. The sound symbol Om
(Figure 2) is referred as the one-lettered key to happy living. Om is a well-known prefix in
several chanting throughout eastern religions. Chanting Om is believed to be associated with
physical and emotional well-being. Chanting Om increases the cutaneous peripheral vascular
resistance, which is a sign of increased mental alertness even while being physiologically
relaxed. In about 40% of Alzheimer's subjects, the middle latency auditory evoked potential
(MLAEP) is lacking. Chanting Om is shown to improve MLAEP in normal subjects after chanting
suggesting that a similar effect could be observed in AD subjects. Vagal nerve stimulation
(VNS) was beneficial in AD subjects as it enhances cognitive functions. Electrical pulsing
for VNS showed deactivation of limbic brain regions. Chanting Om also caused a similar
deactivation of the limbic brain regions, amygdala, hippocampus, parahippocampal gyrus,
insula, orbitofrontal and anterior cingulate cortices and thalamus. The neurophysiological
effects of chanting Om could be mediated through the auricular branches of the vagal nerves.
However, it is not understood if specific molecular changes, in terms of neurotrophic
factors like NGF, occur after Om chanting.
Breathing Exercise Breathing exercise is an active way of regulating breathing. Common
breathing frequency is 15 times per minute in normal adult humans. This frequency changes
with age and physiological condition. In heart failure subjects Bernardi et al showed that
slowing down breathing to be beneficial. Exercises such as yoga, chanting and breathing
exercise regulate breathing and cognitive functions. One of the ancient texts referring to
the benefits of breathing exercise is Thirumanthiram written by the Tamil sage Thirumoolar
whose texts are known for health and longevity practices. Breathing exercise is believed to
produce cycles of oxygenation and non-oxygenation states as a means of ischemic
preconditioning. Remote ischemic preconditioning, i.e., inducing short periods of ischemia
in a remote organ provides protection from a subsequent ischemic insult. Breath-holding
increases vagal tone, increases parasympathetic dominance and decreases sympathetic
discharges. Regulated breathing leads to predominance in abdominal/diaphragmatic breathing.
Thus breathing exercise could be a potential way of inducing ischemic preconditioning in the
neurons. It is known in brain and heart that ischemic preconditioning is beneficial in
averting future major ischemic events by producing cell survival signaling. Interestingly
NGF is a cell survival signaling molecule. Therefore it is conceivable that breathing
exercise induces cell survival in central and peripheral nervous system cells via the
actions of NGF.
Saliva as a Biomarker A normal human produces about 0.75 to 1.5 L of saliva per day. Saliva
contains numerous biologically active molecules including proteins, peptides, mRNA, DNA, and
miRNA of both human and oral microbial origin. Salivary secretion regulates the digestive,
nervous, immune and respiratory systems. For example, 1) Nerve growth factor (NGF),
substance P and calcitonin-gene related peptide (CGRP) are secreted in saliva in response to
chronic migraine, and 2) Opiorphin, a potent anti-nociceptive agent is expressed in saliva.
Salivary proteomic and mRNA profiling have identified significant differences between
control and cancer subjects. These studies indicate that saliva serves as a source of
biomarkers in diagnosis and prognosis of a number of pathological conditions including AD.
SIGNIFICANCE Neurodegenerative diseases such as AD constitute a major global healthcare
problem. Non-pharmacological and non-invasive practices could alter neurological functions
in normal and pathological settings. Salivary secretion of neurotrophic factors indicates
that saliva could be a potential source and a biomarker for neurotrophic factors. Therefore,
salivary NGF estimation could be a tool for diagnosis and prognosis in AD. Ancient Tamil
culture has preserved practices to maintain a healthy psychological and physiological
status. Chanting and breathing exercise are known to promote salivary secretion. However, it
is not fully understood if such practices induce the expression of neurological factors in
the saliva. We aim to quantify salivary NGF in response to chanting and breathing exercise
in normal human subjects. This will establish a hitherto unreported relationship between
tongue tactile and respiratory signals for salivary secretion of NGF, and its effects on the
nervous system. Our project will quantify candidate neurotrophic factor NGF in saliva at
basal, during and post-exercise. In future studies we will use proteomic, peptidic and
genomic approaches to identify other neurotrophic factors regulated in saliva by these
exercises. Our findings will introduce a new paradigm in the treatment and care of
individuals with/prone to AD and other neurodegenerative diseases.
Clinical and Translational Impact: Given the fact that AD, aging and other neurodegenerative
disorders are associated with declined neurotrophic factor production (e.g. NGF), and that
NGF is actively pursued as a drug in clinical trials, our findings that NGF could be
stimulated in situ by simple, non-invasive ethnic practices will have strong clinical
application. Future studies using genomic and proteomic approaches will identify additional
neurotrophic factors in saliva that could potentially be drug targets to treat AD and other
neurodegenerative diseases.
C. PRELIMINARY STUDIES None. D. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS Human Subjects
A total of 20 volunteers (male or female), aging 18 and above will be included in the study.
The following is a list of conditions for exclusion:
- breathing problems (inability to breath through nostrils, chronic bronchitis, emphysema
and asthma)
- speech problems that would prevent chanting
- inability to listen and follow exercise instructions
- sinus congestion
- Sjogren's syndrome
- chronic dry mouth due to medication or other conditions
- use of anti-cholinergic medications Informed consent will be obtained from each subject
after completely describing the study.
Human Subject Recruitment Once we get an IRB approval, we will recruit 20 subjects required
for this study by posting an advertisement in MUSC elevators and in nearby Yoga centers.
Interested participants will contact the PI at the given telephone number. Eligibility of
the subjects will be assessed by the PI based on questions given in the Questionnaire. The
PI and the participant will agree on an appointment time. The participant will come to the
PI's lab at Strom Thurmond Building (STB, Room 222). This meeting room is located on the
same floor as the PI's research laboratory. We chose this room for its quiet atmosphere
without any interference by other lab personnel during the protocol. This room is reserved
via the Gazes Cardiac Research Institute Lab Manager, and is freely available to the PI.
Upon arrival, the PI will explain the study to the subject and obtain consent using the
Consent Form. The PI will also sign and date the Consent Form and give a copy to the
participant. The subject will then fill the Questionnaire to confirm eligibility.
Enrolled and consented subjects will be randomized to one of 2 conditions (the
"Chanting/Breathing" (CB) arm versus the "Control" arm. Randomization will be conducted in
collaboration with a biostatistician and will be done in a stratified manner (i.e. by
gender), to ensure that equal gender distribution in the 2 experimental groups (CB vs.
Control). The biostatistician will provide the PI with envelopes containing the study
identification number and random group assignment (i.e. CB vs. Control). Each envelope will
be opened only after study eligibility has been established and consent has been obtained.
Prior to exercise and sample collection, the PI will teach each subject how to perform
chanting and breathing exercise. Each subject will test individually because of ease of
sample collection and to avoid any variability that could arise in neuronal stimulation in
subjects in the presence of individuals other than the researchers.
Chanting, Breathing exercise and Specimen collection The subjects will get an introduction
to the chanting and breathing exercise. As a chanting/yoga/breathing exercise practitioner,
the PI will provide this training, which should not take more than 5 minutes to learn. The
plan for collecting whole saliva samples is depicted in Figure 3. Salivary samples will be
collected once at the beginning of the protocol (Time 0) while the subjects are seated.
Saliva will be naturally allowed to accumulate in the oral cavity and the participant will
discharge it into the specimen tube (5 mL capacity) with lid.
Chanting Om (C):
The subjects will then chant Om as follows:
1. Sharp deep inhalation through nostrils
2. Slow exhalation through mouth while chanting Om. At this step the subjects will perform
a slow and complete exhalation.
These two steps are repeated continuously for 10 min with closed eyes.
Breathing Exercise (BE):
Following the chanting, the subjects will perform the breathing exercise as follows, as
instructed by the PI based on Thirumanthiram:
1. Check which of the two nostrils exhibit free flow of air. For the explanation purpose
the nostril with free flow of air is treated as Nostril 1 and the other one as Nostril
2.
2. Close Nostril 2 and inhale a sharp deep breath through Nostril 1 and then close both
the nostrils so no inhaled air escapes. Air should not escape through mouth either.
This inhalation step should take about 4 seconds.
3. Hold breath in this position for about 16 seconds.
4. Open Nostril 2 and exhale for about 8 seconds. Complete exhalation is required. Abdomen
will slowly curve-in as the subject exhales. This is normal and encouraged. No air
should leak through the Nostril 1 or mouth.
5. Go to step a). During the exercise, if the oral cavity accumulates saliva, the subject
can swallow it at the end of exhalation step (Step d). The subjects will perform
breathing exercise for 10 min. Salivary samples will be collected at 5 and 10 minutes
of breathing exercise in tubes labeled BE-1, BE-2. Thus each individual will provide
the following five saliva samples: + (Time 0), Om chanting (C-1 and C2), and Breathing
Exercise (BE-1 and BE-2).
Control group In the case of control group, the subjects will sit quietly for the same
duration as the CB group. Saliva samples will be collected at the same time points (at 5 min
intervals for 20 min) as the CB group.
The approximate total time for the whole protocol will be as follows:
Introduction and Questionnaire - 10 minutes Instruction for chanting, breathing exercise (CB
group) or sit quietly (Control group) and salivary sample collection - 10 minutes (CB group)
or 5 minutes (Control group) Basal sample collection - 1 minute Om Chanting - 10 minutes
Breathing Exercise - 10 minutes Any other question by the subject - 2-3 minutes Total
appointment time for a subject = approximately 45 minutes (CB group) 40 minutes (Control
group) For the study participants' time and any inconvenience a monetary compensation will
be provided.
Processing of samples Place the collected saliva samples on ice. Using sterile techniques,
transfer the saliva to centrifuge tubes while measuring the quantity of each sample. The
number of samples collected from each sample at each step of the experiment could vary.
Treat the samples from individual tubes separately without pooling any sample. Calculate the
total volume of saliva during normal resting phase, during chanting and during breathing
exercise. Store the samples at -80 degree C until analysis. Samples will be discarded after
the data analysis.
Enzyme-linked immunoassay Quantify the levels of NGF in each sample by enzyme-linked
immunoassay using commercial kits according to the manufacturer's instructions (Promega).
All the reagents necessary to conduct the ELISA experiment are provided in the kit.
Additional reagents if any, and the ELISA reader are available to the PI at STB Room 511.
Data management All study data collected from participants by the PI will be entered into a
REDCap database, developed with assistance from the project biostatistician. REDCap
(Research Electronic Data Capture) is a software toolset and workflow methodology for
electronic collection and management of research and clinical trial data available to MUSC
researchers. The iterative development and testing process results in a well-planned data
collection strategy for individual studies which facilitates data entry, edit checks and
eventual statistical analysis. The underlying database is hosted at the MUSC Data Center,
and the system is protected behind a login and Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) encryption.
Statistical Analysis Statistical analysis will be done under the guidance of a
biostatistician, who has collaborated with the PI in developing this study. Initially,
descriptive statistics will be used to characterize the study participants with respect to
demographic, any relevant clinical characteristics, and NGF measurements at baseline and
over time. Group differences in demographics and other baseline variables will be examined
via t-tests, chi square tests, and Fisher's exact tests, as appropriate. This study is meant
to obtain preliminary evidence of the effectiveness of these exercises (chanting and/or
breathing vs. resting control) to stimulate salivary NGF; as such, no formal hypothesis
testing will be conducted. Instead, general linear mixed models (GLMMs) will be used to
obtain estimates (and their respective 95% confidence intervals) of the group differences
over time with respect to the NGF levels. GLMMs are ideal for analyses involving between-
and within-subject variability and are especially useful for repeated measures study designs
such as that used for this proposed study. Since age is believed to affect NGF, age will be
included as a covariate in all models. Linear, quadratic, and cubic effects of time will be
considered. Different types of error covariance structures will be examined, and Akaike
Information Criterion values will be used to select the most appropriate-fitting GLMM. Using
the GLMM will allow us to characterize the typical trajectory of NGF measurements over time
in both experimental conditions and will also afford us the opportunity to compare chanting
versus breathing exercises within the CB group. Results from this type of statistical
modeling will be valuable for planning (externally funded) future, larger and more
definitive studies.
Sample Size Justification Since no formal hypothesis testing will be conducted, statistical
power is not relevant for this proposal; thus the sample size justification is based on the
precision of our estimation processes and on the learning experiences involved with
enrolling, observing, and measuring the subjects in this study as well as conducting the
laboratory tests in the most efficient manner as possible. Having n=10 subjects in each
experimental group (for a total of n=20 subjects) will allow us to make preliminary
estimates of the NGF measurements over time in each group. With n=10 subjects per group, 95%
confidence intervals around group mean estimates will extend ~0.6 standard deviations in
either direction, and 95% confidence intervals around mean group difference estimates will
extend ~0.9 standard deviations in either direction. With n=10 per group, we will also gain
a greater understanding of subjects' willingness to be randomized in this type of
complementary and alternative medicine study and of the best techniques associated with
delivering the chanting and breathing exercises intervention.
E. PROTECTION OF HUMAN SUBJECTS
1. Risks to the Subjects There will be 20 subjects both men and women participating in
this study who are in the age group of 18 and above. This protocol will consist of
single visit, one-on-one sessions for individual participant. These exercises do not
pose any physical, psychological, social risks to the participants. Breach of
confidentiality could be one potential risk as the Questionnaire collects health
information of the subjects. The participants may feel slightly uncomfortable to spit
or drool in the presence of another individual. There is a chance for the participant
to feel that they do not know the exercises beforehand or they could feel that they are
not fully capable of following the exercise instructions.
Protections against Risks The instructor will try to make sure that the subjects feel
at ease and comfortable. All the information collected in the study will be treated
with confidentiality and stored in secured servers as described above. The paper works
generated in the present study contains potential personal information.. These
documents will be secured in a locked cabinet belonging to the PI located in Room 625
of STB at MUSC. The participants will be identified by an identification number in all
the documents, data and in salivary samples. The Informed Consent is the link between
the participant identification number and their name. The salivary samples collected
will be secured at -80 degree freezer with a lock in STB Room 213 and discarded
immediately after the data analysis. The breathing exercises and chanting are mild
exercise forms and do not pose any health risks in participants. The study participants
will not be contacted for another study.
2. Potential Health Benefits to the Subjects Yogic breathing in particular and yoga in
general are good exercises for a healthy life. Several studies indicate that yogic
breathing reduces stress and improves the quality of life in multiple patient groups
and in otherwise healthy individuals. At the end of the study, the subjects under the
Chanting/Breathing Exercise group could feel physically and psychologically better
because of the neurotrophic effects. These subjects end up learning new techniques from
another culture (cross-cultural experience) to regulate breathing that they can
practice daily at their will as continuous practice could benefit them in long run.
