Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

This study evaluates healing time in usage of honey and povidone-iodine over paraffin gauze as dressings in the treatment of acute laceration wounds. In Indonesia, especially in rural area, where most of the resources is limited and modern dressings are expensive and hard-to-find. The investigators tried to find an alternative which was easier to find and could act as a substitute of modern wound dressing.

The hypothesis of this study is honey and povidone-iodine could be a good substitute (or equal to) to paraffin gauze on acute laceration wounds.

Honey is chosen because of its versatility and already well-known to be used as a chronic wound dressing. Povidone-iodine was chosen as another alternative because it is still one of the most used substance in rural area as a wound dressing, but there is not enough study to support the usage of this substance. Paraffin gauze was chosen as a representative of modern wound dressing because it fulfilled the standard of wound dressing on acute wound, which is non-adherent and also moist.


Clinical Trial Description

The investigator's team consists of five members, each have their own specific tasks and divided by two groups, which are ER group (first time encounter, informed consent, and intervention) and polyclinic group (routine wound care). All of the data are primary data. Data registry were taken by the team without involving any other party. Any intervention done to the participants were also done only by the team(suturing, wound care). Appointment for routine wound care was also made by contacting the participant through their cellphone numbers which were collected when they come to the ER.

The data of each of the participant was registered on a form which was pre-made by the investigators. It recorded the identity of the patient, history taking, physical examination, and also to record more detailed information about our intervention, such as the amount of stitches and how many and what kind of resources that have been spent on the participant.

Every sample will be categorized into 3 randomized groups of intervention; honey, povidone-iodine, and paraffin gauze, which will also be categorized by location of their wound; face and neck, upper extremity, and lower extremity. Participants on each intervention group are distributed evenly using stratified block randomization. Photos of the wound will be taken before and after the wound is cleaned, and after the wound has been sutured. Every patient will be asked to attend a predetermined schedule for wound care assessment. The wound will be evaluated by photos before and after the wound is cleaned, debrided, or have its sutures removed. Parameter of evaluation will be duration of wound healing per anatomical region, infection, cleanliness of wound, odor, exudate level, pain, itch, and total cost of wound care.

Every paper consists of participants' data that were collected on colored maps based on the intervention group (red: povidone-iodine, yellow: honey, blue: paraffin). At the end of the study, three of the team's members converted the data to be analyzed using Microsoft Excel and SPSS.

The investigators prepared beforehand the Standard Operational Procedures regarding any possibilities of adverse events, such as lidocaine toxicity and honey hypersensitivity and were already approved by the hospital's committee.

The investigators determined the target of the sample size with the total sample of 36 participants, distributed evenly based on intervention groups and wounds' location using stratified block randomization ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT03641053
Study type Interventional
Source S.K. Lerik General Hospital
Contact
Status Completed
Phase Phase 3
Start date January 29, 2018
Completion date June 30, 2018

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT04554212 - Blood Flow Restriction Training After Patellar INStability N/A
Suspended NCT02932176 - Machine Learning for Handheld Vascular Studies
Recruiting NCT04803253 - Study of the Social and Professional Reintegration Improvements Using a Set of Solutions for Upper Limb Amputation N/A
Completed NCT00116337 - Spinal Cord Stimulation to Restore Cough N/A
Completed NCT03463720 - Outcome for Patients With War-Associated Extremity Wound Infection N/A
Completed NCT03113253 - TRANexamic Acid to Reduce Bleeding in BURN Surgery Phase 4
Not yet recruiting NCT05492903 - COMmunity of Practice And Safety Support for Navigating Pain (COMPASS-NP) N/A
Terminated NCT02909231 - One-year Patient Reported Outcomes Following Hospitalization for Trauma N/A
Completed NCT02432456 - Ketamine Infusion Therapy for the Management of Acute Pain in Adult Rib Fracture Patients Phase 4
Completed NCT02744144 - Wound Bacterial Microbiota and Their Antibiotic Resistance N/A
Completed NCT02266771 - Impact of V.A.C. Veraflo Therapy in Wounds Requiring Debridement Within an Orthopedic Practice N/A
Completed NCT02394821 - Odor Management in Fungating Wounds Comparing Metronidazole and Polihexanide Phase 3
Not yet recruiting NCT01665963 - Efficacy of TopClosure(C)System in Healing Complicated Pacemaker Wounds N/A
Completed NCT00151112 - Comparison of Two Different Procedures for Plexus Anesthesia N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT03872544 - Short Term Status of Free Dermal Fat Autografts for Complex Craniofacial Wounds
Recruiting NCT04596124 - Effectiveness and Tolerability of Fitostimoline Plus Cream and Gauze vs Connettivina Bio Plus Cream and Gauze N/A
Recruiting NCT05800834 - Benefits of Morphine Gel for Pain Reduction in Patients With Cancer Wounds Phase 2
Enrolling by invitation NCT03880188 - Long Term Status of Free Dermal Fat Autografts for Complex Craniofacial Wounds
Terminated NCT04775316 - Prospective, International, Multicenter, Observational Study to Evaluate the Clinical Performance and Safety of a Silicone-coated Transparent Postoperative Dressing
Enrolling by invitation NCT03312504 - Implementing a School Prevention Program to Reduce Injuries Through Neuromuscular Training N/A