Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

Shoulder pain is one of the most common musculoskeletal complaints in orthopedic practice. Rotator cuff injuries account for up to 70% of pain in the shoulder girdle. There is no clinical study carried out in Brazil comparing cost effectiveness between the open and arthroscopic methods of rotator cuff repair surgery.

The present study aims to determine which method of repair of the rotator cuff, open or arthroscopic, has the best cost effectiveness ratio.

A randomized clinical trial will be carried out in which patients with symptomatic rotator cuff lesion will be submitted to repair surgery by either open or arthroscopic technique and will be subsequently evaluated.


Clinical Trial Description

Introduction:

Musculoskeletal injuries are a major cost to the healthcare system. In 2004, 30% of the North American population had some kind of musculoskeletal disorder that required medical treatment; between 2002 and 2004, the estimated cost of treating these changes was $ 510 billion. Shoulder diseases represent the third most common cause of these changes, behind only spinal and knee disorders.

An evaluation of the primary health care system in Cambridge, United Kingdom, showed that the average frequency of shoulder pain was 9.5 per 1,000 individuals. Of these, 86% had rotator cuff tendinopathy. North American data estimate that approximately 4.5 million patients annually seek medical attention due to shoulder pain; of these, two million have some symptoms related to the rotator cuff. About 250,000 rotator cuff repair surgeries are performed annually in the United States of America (US), and with the continued increase in life expectancy and aging, there is a tendency to increase this number.

The rotator cuff is composed of the tendons of the subscapularis, supraspinatus, infraspinatus and teres minor muscles. The long portion of the biceps tendon also contributes to cuff function, which is to stabilize the humeral head in the glenoid cavity, preventing superior migration of the humeral head.

The possible lesions range from tendon degeneration (tendinosis/tendinopathy), through partial lesions (articular, interstitial or bursal), to complete lesions. Diagnosis is made by associating history and physical examination along with imaging methods, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is considered the method of choice.

Currently, the indication for surgical treatment is based on the persistence of symptoms and/or the degree of muscle weakness and/or size of the lesion, after a time of conservative treatment. In general, when opting for surgery, imaging can assist in the planning of surgical treatment, since it allows measuring the extent of the lesion (partial or total) and discriminating which tendons are involved (supraspinatus, infraspinatus, etc.).

Treatment of rotator cuff diseases depends on the type of injury, the patient's degree of activity, age, and the presence of symptoms. In general, tendon degeneration and partial lesions are treated non-surgically, with physiotherapy, infiltrations and analgesic medications. Complete and incomplete lesions that did not respond well to conservative treatment, however, should be treated surgically. Among the surgical options, the open method is still considered the gold standard, with good or excellent results in over 90% of cases. With the advent of arthroscopy and the evolution of arthroscopic instruments and implants in the last decade, the arthroscopic repair technique has gained space and is widely used in the investigator's country. Several studies abroad did not demonstrate superiority of one technique over another in terms of clinical outcomes. As the cost of arthroscopic surgery is higher, due to the equipment needed to perform it, it is important to establish which option has the best cost-effectiveness.

Some studies abroad even suggest the superiority of the open method over the arthroscopic method. However, there are no studies comparing cost-effectiveness between open and arthroscopic methods in Brazil. Therefore, the present study aims to compare the open and arthroscopic methods for rotator cuff repair and determine which presents the best cost-effectiveness ratio.

Hypothesis:

The hypothesis of this study is that the open method of rotator cuff repair will be more cost-effective compared to the arthroscopic method.

Justification:

In a systematic literature search, it was observed that there are no studies in the Brazilian literature comparing the cost-effectiveness of open and arthroscopic rotator cuff repair methods. Data from the international literature suggest that the open repair method is more cost-effective than the arthroscopic method (same clinical outcome and lower cost).

Thus, despite the high incidence of rotator cuff injury, there is insufficient evidence from the Brazilian experience to determine the best method for treating these injuries. So, this project proposes to conduct a study to answer the clinical question of which method, open or arthroscopic, has the best cost-effectiveness in the surgical treatment of rotator cuff injury. According to the levels of scientific evidence, the most appropriate study design to answer this clinical question is a randomized clinical trial.

Study Goal:

The present study aims to compare the open and arthroscopic methods for rotator cuff repair and determine which presents the best cost-effectiveness ratio. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT04146987
Study type Interventional
Source Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein
Contact Rafael Pierami, MD
Phone +55 (11)982325308
Email rafael.pierami@einstein.br
Status Recruiting
Phase N/A
Start date August 1, 2020
Completion date December 1, 2022

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT04930393 - Evaluating the Efficacy of PECS II Block Versus Axillary Ring Block in Rotator Cuff Repair Patients N/A
Completed NCT03717753 - Rotator Cuff Pathway N/A
Completed NCT04454671 - Ultrasound-guided Percutaneous Neuromodulation Versus Dry Needling in Shoulder Pain Treatment N/A
Completed NCT06274827 - Electromyographic Analysis of Scapular Muscles During Closed Kinetic Chain Exercises N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT05413213 - Ambulatory Rehabilitation Program in Patients With Degenerative Rupture of the Rotator Cuff Tendons of the Shoulder N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT05043844 - Comparison of the Incidence of Shoulder Pain According to Postoperative Use of Abdominal Binder N/A
Recruiting NCT02903719 - The Effect of Phrenic Nerve Block on Postoperative Shoulder Pain in Patients for Liver Resection. Phase 4
Completed NCT02777281 - Safe and Effective Shoulder Exercise Training in Manual Wheelchair Users With SCI N/A
Completed NCT02554968 - Reliability and Validity of Patient Reported Outcome Measures in Head and Neck Cancer
Recruiting NCT02242630 - Relationship to Dose of Triamcinolone Acetonide and Methylyprednisolone to Improvement in Subacromial Bursitis N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT02843269 - Multiple-component Workplace FRamed Intervention to Decrease Occupational Muscle Pain - FRIDOM N/A
Completed NCT02631395 - The Effect of a Shoulder Training Program to Prevent Shoulder Pain Among Girls in Junior Team Handball N/A
Completed NCT01733914 - Contralateral Acupuncture in the Treatment of Chronic Shoulder Pain Phase 2
Completed NCT01885377 - SWESS: The SWedish Exercise Shoulder Study in Primary Care for Patients With Subacromial Pain N/A
Completed NCT01205542 - Work Place Adjusted Intelligent Physical Exercise Reducing Musculoskeletal Pain in Shoulder and Neck (VIMS) - Shoulder Function N/A
Completed NCT01843660 - An Efficacy and Safety Study of Tramadol Hydrochloride-Paracetamol in Treatment of Moderate to Severe Acute Neck-Shoulder Pain and Low Back Pain Phase 4
Completed NCT00743600 - Ultrasound Evaluation of the Rotator Cable and Associated Structures. N/A
Completed NCT00679887 - Chronic Shoulder Pain Treated by Pressures With the Thumbs on the Trigger Points Phase 1/Phase 2
Completed NCT04058522 - Treatment of Subacromial Shoulder Pain by Individual or Group Physiotherapy Following Corticosteroid Injection N/A
Completed NCT03353272 - The Influence of a Cognitive Behavioral Approach on Changing Patient Expectations in Shoulder Pain N/A