Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Recruiting

Administrative data

NCT number NCT01755819
Other study ID # ACL Tightrope vs. Biocomposite
Secondary ID
Status Recruiting
Phase N/A
First received December 4, 2012
Last updated January 15, 2013
Start date January 2013
Est. completion date January 2016

Study information

Verified date January 2013
Source Medical University Innsbruck
Contact Rene EL Attal, Dr.
Phone 0043-50-504-80875
Email rene.attal@uki.at
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority BASG: Bundesamt für Sicherheit im Gesundheitswesen
Study type Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

Background:

Failure of graft incorporation and tunnel widening (TW) after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction has been frequently reported in the literature. The etiology of TW is still not fully understood.

Patients and Methods:

This is a prospective randomized study including 60 patients, conducted in a Level I trauma center in Innsbruck, Austria. The study protocol was approved by the hospital ethics committee. This study is planned and conducted following the Consolidated Standards on Reporting Trials (CONSORT) guidelines. Aperture fixation is performed using BioComposite interference screws (Arthrex, Naples, FL). Extracortical fixation is performed using the ACL Tightrope (Arthrex, Naples, FL). TW is measured on CT scan postoperative, after 6 and 24 months. Clinical outcome is determined at 1, 2 after reconstruction, IKDC with KOOS Knee-related QoL subscale, Lysholm, Tegner Activity scores, hop tests and KT-1000 measurements are performed.

Hypothesis:

The purpose of this randomized controlled trail is to determine the influence of two different fixation methods on TW and clinical outcome after anatomic ACL reconstruction using hamstring graft in young and active patients.


Description:

The study is a randomized controlled clinical trial and will be conducted at the Traumasurgery Innsbruck. Two different surgical methods are tested: ACL Tightrope reconstruction VS Biocomposite interference screws.

Following eligibility criteria have to be met:

1. Age 18 -40 years

2. ACL insufficiency diagnosed by clinical examination (positive Lachman test and/or pivot shift test) and MRI (complete tear)

3. Not more than 12 month after trauma to the knee

4. Tegner Score 5 to 10

Not eligible if:

1. Earlier major knee injury to the index knee

2. Previous knee surgery (except diagnostic arthroscopy) to index knee

3. Associated knee fractures

4. Associated PCL injury, complete MCL or LCL tear

5. Concomitant severe injury to contra-lateral knee at time of assessment

6. Injury to the lateral/posterolateral ligament complex with increased laxity (positive dial test and external rotation thigh foot angle test),

7. Pregnancy and scope to become within next time

8. A history of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or a disorder of the coagulative system

9. Claustrophobia

10. General systemic disease affecting physical function, any other condition or treatment interfering with the completion of the trial, including patients with metal devices, pacemaker or motion disorders

11. Chronic systemic use of steroids

Following inclusion and exclusion criteria have to be met:

Inclusion:

1. The ACL injury can be either "isolated" or combined with one or several of the following injuries visualized on MRI and/or arthroscopy:

- A meniscus tear that is either left untreated or treated with a partial resection

- A small, stable meniscus tear treated with fixation, but fixation not interfering with the rehabilitation protocol

- Cartilage changes verified on MRI with arthroscopically determine intact surface

2. A radiographic examination with normal joint status or combined with either one of the following finding:

- A small avulsed fragment located laterally, usually described as a Second fracture

- JSN grade 1 or osteophytes grade 1 as determined by the OARSI atlas (Altman et al. 1995)

3. Agreement to participate in the study and signed informed consent prior to inclusion.

Exclusion:

1.Presence of one of the following associated injuries to the index knee as visualized on MRI and/or arthroscopy:

- An unstable longitudinal meniscus tear that requires repair and where the following postoperative treatment (i.e. bracing and limited ROM) interferes with the rehabilitation protocol

- Bi-compartmental extensive meniscus resection

- A cartilage injury representing a full thickness loss down to bone

- A total rupture of MCL/LCL as visualized on MRI

A power analysis was performed, estimating that a minimum of 34 patients (17 in each group) would be required to obtain a power more than 80%.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Recruiting
Enrollment 60
Est. completion date January 2016
Est. primary completion date January 2016
Accepts healthy volunteers No
Gender Both
Age group 18 Years to 40 Years
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria:

1. The ACL injury can be either "isolated" or combined with one or several of the following injuries visualized on MRI and/or arthroscopy:

- A meniscus tear that is either left untreated or treated with a partial resection

- A small, stable meniscus tear treated with fixation, but fixation not interfering with the rehabilitation protocol

- Cartilage changes verified on MRI with arthroscopically determine intact surface

2. A radiographic examination with normal joint status or combined with either one of the following finding:

- A small avulsed fragment located laterally, usually described as a Second fracture

- JSN grade 1 or osteophytes grade 1 as determined by the OARSI atlas (Altman et al. 1995)

3. Agreement to participate in the study and signed informed consent prior to inclusion.

Exclusion Criteria:

1.Presence of one of the following associated injuries to the index knee as visualized on MRI and/or arthroscopy:

- An unstable longitudinal meniscus tear that requires repair and where the following postoperative treatment (i.e. bracing and limited ROM) interferes with the rehabilitation protocol

- Bi-compartmental extensive meniscus resection

- A cartilage injury representing a full thickness loss down to bone

- A total rupture of MCL/LCL as visualized on MRI

Study Design

Allocation: Randomized, Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment, Masking: Open Label, Primary Purpose: Treatment


Related Conditions & MeSH terms

  • ACL Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury
  • Outcome

Intervention

Device:
Biocomposite interference screw

Extracortical ACL Tightrope fixation


Locations

Country Name City State
Austria Medical University Innsbruck (Traumasurgery) Innsbruck Tyrol

Sponsors (1)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
Medical University Innsbruck

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Austria, 

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary Change of tunnel volume and diameter from baseline up to 2 year follow up CT tunnel measurements are conducted. Tunnel volume are calculated by CT volumetry measured in mm³ and tunnel diameter is measured in mm. 1-2 days before (knee) operation, 6 months FU, 2 year FU No
Secondary Clinical outcome: international knee score evaluating objective and subjective knee outcome variables Clinical outcome measured by IKDC (INTERNATIONAL KNEE DOCUMENTATION COMMITTEE) Subjective questionnaire (symptoms, sports activity, knee function): scaled from 0-100.
Objective evaluation form (radiological assessment of cartilage and menisci, functional knee examination, range of motion): scaled A-D
1-2 days before (knee)operation, 6 months FU, 1 year FU, 2 year FU No
Secondary Clinical outcome: influence on quality of life after knee ACL reconstruction Clinical outcome measured by KOOS Knee related QoL subscale 1-2 days before (knee)operation, 6 month FU, 1 year FU, 2year FU No
Secondary Clinical outcome: subjective evaluation of knee function Clinical outcome measured by Lysholm Score: subjective questionnaire 1-2 days before (knee)operation, 6 months FU, 1 year FU, 2 year FU No
Secondary Clinical outcome: return to sports activity Clinical outcome measured by Tegner Activity scores: sports activity level 1-2 days before (knee)operation, 6 months FU, 1 year FU, 2 year FU No
Secondary Clinical outcome: strength in single leg jumping after ACL reconstruction Single leg hop test measured in cm. Comparing the injured and healthy knee. 1-2 days before (knee)operation, 6 months FU, 1 year FU, 2 year FU No
Secondary Clinical outcome: objective knee anterior stability Clinical outcome measured by KT1000 arthrometer measurements in mm. 1-2 days before (knee)operation, 6 months FU, 1 year FU, 2 year FU No
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT05268419 - Efficacy and Safety of Ethanol Inhalation on COVID-19 Treatment (a Clinical Trial Study) Phase 3
Completed NCT03251573 - The Cohort Study of Cognitive Impairment in Chinese Hemodialysis Patients
Completed NCT04238806 - Desflurane,Brain Natriuretic Peptide and Cardiac Surgery N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT05161104 - A Multicenter Cross-sectional Study of Cardiac Ultrasound Phenotypes in Patients With Sepsis
Recruiting NCT03893136 - The Registry Study of Takayasu Arteritis in East China
Recruiting NCT03305276 - Observatory on Impact of Life Styles on Health Outcomes N/A
Recruiting NCT04963530 - Enamel Wear Evaluation in Patients With Different Ceramic Restorations N/A
Withdrawn NCT03022877 - Acute and Chronic Protective Effects of Peri-interventional Administration of Levosimendan in ST Elevation Myocardial Infarctions N/A
Completed NCT02041403 - RENAL RESISTIVE INDEX POST-OPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS IN MAJOR SURGERY? N/A
Withdrawn NCT01356446 - Checklist Application and Mortality N/A
Withdrawn NCT01343069 - Safety Improvement and Checklist Application N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT04918953 - Factors Influencing the Prognosis of Olfactory Dysfunction After Upper Sensation Phase 2
Completed NCT03765372 - Evaluation of BIomarkers for POstoperative Complications in Non-cardiac Surgery Patients
Completed NCT05133960 - The Turkish Version of the Activity Diversity Questionnaire
Completed NCT03247049 - Prognosis in Intracerebral Hemorrhage. The ICHCat Score in Primary Care. N/A
Recruiting NCT03143595 - Clinical Outcomes in Elderly Patients With Preoperative Cognitive Dysfunction N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06087939 - Outcome and Predictors of Mortality of Patients on Prolonged Mechanical Ventilation
Recruiting NCT04979741 - Recovery After Intensive Care Study
Completed NCT05976204 - Prognostic Value of NLR, TLR, and ALC in Predicting ToF Primary Repair Outcome
Completed NCT04746326 - Treatment in Right Colon Diverticulitis Patients N/A