Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

The purpose of this study is to evaluate outcomes of an established procedure for treatment of kidney stones that are present within the inner aspect of the kidney. This procedure is called flexible ureteroscopy, which involves placing a small camera through the urethra while anesthetized (asleep), up the ureter (the tube connecting kidney and bladder) and into the kidney to the kidney stone. Then, the stone is broken into tiny fragments using a small laser called a Holmium laser. While this treatment is a well-established option for treatment of these stones, there are several different techniques used to help eliminate them from the kidney. Some urologists treat the stone by a method called "active" extraction whereby the ureteroscope is passed back and forth into the kidney to remove all visible stone fragments. Others use a method called "dusting" whereby the stones are broken into tiny fragments or "dust" with the intention that achieving such a small stone size will allow the stones to pass spontaneously. There has not been a systematic and rigorous comparison of these techniques in terms of treatment outcomes. By collecting information on the success of treatment, the investigators hope to provide benchmark data for future studies of kidney stone treatment and improve the care of all patients who need surgery for their kidney stones.

The investigators hypothesize that the stone free rate for renal stone(s) 5-15 mm is around 90% and that the stone clearance rate with be 20% higher in those patients that undergo complete stone fragment extraction versus those that undergo stone dusting (residual fragments < 2mm).


Clinical Trial Description

To date, there is inadequate literature to confidently determine the ideal technique of stone extraction during ureteroscopy, an endourologic procedure for the treatment of kidney stones. The goals of ureteroscopy for intrarenal stones are to fragment stones and minimize residual fragments while doing so in a safe and expeditious way with minimal harm to the patient. Options for the treatment of intrarenal stones consist of using a basket to pull them out or a laser to break them into small fragments. When stones are deemed too large to be basketed primarily, the standard preference in ureteroscopic laser lithotripsy is use of the Holmium:YAG laser which can effectively break stones into fragments small enough to remove or pass spontaneously.

There is no consensus on how to achieve optimal stone clearance once the primary stone is fragmented with lithotripsy. Many urologists choose to &quot;dust&quot; the stone by breaking it into tiny fragments &lt; 1 - 2 mm in size with the assumption that stone fragments of such a small size will pass spontaneously after surgery. This can theoretically decrease operative times and lower risk of ureteral trauma by minimizing repetitive introduction and removal of the ureteroscope. Others choose to actively extract each possible stone fragment during the procedure thereby increasing the immediate stone-free outcome.

Active extraction however typically increases costs as it requires use of a basket or grasper and ureteral access sheath. To date, only one prospective, randomized study has addressed the practice of active extraction vs spontaneous passage, the results of which suggested higher rates of residual stone fragments, hospital readmissions and need for ancillary procedures when stones were not actively extracted (8). This study was criticized for not following a standardized operative protocol and not reporting several important outcomes including stone composition. Additionally, this study used semirigid ureteroscopy, specifically addressed ureteral rather than intrarenal stones, and did not follow a "dusting" protocol assuring minimal size of residual fragments.

Complete eradication of stone fragments is one of the primary outcomes of ureteroscopy as residual renal stone fragments after ureteroscopy have been shown to lead to a subsequent stone event in approximately 20% of cases(9). However, maximizing eradication of stone fragments must not come at the expense of the patient. For this reason it is important to consider the operative variables associated with the different techniques employed to clear stone during such procedures.

For example, an average of nearly three times as much laser energy was used to fragment the stone into tiny pieces compared to active extraction (8). Conversely, active extraction of stone fragments requires introducing and removing the ureteroscope through the ureter a greater number of times in order to facilitate stone removal; which generally requires use of a ureteral access sheath, a treatment with its own associated risk.(10). The short term and long term differences resulting from use of these techniques is currently unknown. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT01619735
Study type Observational
Source Mayo Clinic
Contact
Status Completed
Phase
Start date April 2013
Completion date June 10, 2017

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Enrolling by invitation NCT04746378 - PRedictive Accuracy of Initial Stone Burden Evaluation.
Recruiting NCT05100017 - Methocarbamol vs Oxybutynin for Management of Pain and Discomfort S/P Ureteroscopy Procedure N/A
Recruiting NCT03692715 - Antibiotic Prophylaxis Before Shock Wave Lithotripsy Phase 4
Completed NCT02547805 - Evaluate the Effect of ALLN-177 in Reducing Urinary Oxalate in Patients With Secondary Hyperoxaluria and Kidney Stones Over 28 Days Phase 2
Completed NCT02289755 - Evaluating ALLN-177 for Reducing Urinary Oxalate Excretion in Calcium Oxalate Kidney Stone Formers With Hyperoxaluria Phase 2
Completed NCT01690039 - Influence of Polymorphisms in the ATP6V1 Gene of the V-ATPase on the Development of Incomplete Distal Renal Tubular Acidosis
Completed NCT01650935 - Comparison of DASH With Oxalate Restricted Diet on Urine in Recurrent Stone Formers With Hyperoxaluria N/A
Completed NCT01295879 - Vitamin D Repletion in Stone Formers With Hypercalciuria Phase 4
Recruiting NCT05014178 - Kidney Sodium Functional Imaging
Not yet recruiting NCT06199102 - The High Initial Dose of Monitored Vitamin D Supplementation in Preterm Infants. N/A
Recruiting NCT04374188 - Efficacy of Ciprofloxacin Therapy in Avoidance of Sepsis in Patient Undergoing Percutanous Nephrolithotomy N/A
Recruiting NCT04367155 - Efficacy of Tranexamic Acid on Blood Loss During Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy. N/A
Recruiting NCT05701098 - SOUND Pivotal Trial - (Sonomotion stOne comminUtion resoNance ultrasounD) N/A
Recruiting NCT04389853 - Mini-PNCL vs fURS in Management of Nephrolithiasis N/A
Completed NCT03348228 - Effect of Hydroxycitrate on Urine Chemistry N/A
Completed NCT05350423 - Trial Assessing Renal Damage During Ureteroscopy N/A
Completed NCT03454139 - Subcostal TAP Block For Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy N/A
Recruiting NCT02279927 - Prospective Comparison Between Different Laser Settings for Ureteral \ Kidney Stones Treatment During Ureteroscopy N/A
Completed NCT02276924 - Diagnostic Relevance of Laser Confocal Microscopy for the Screening of Upper Urinary Tract Tumors N/A
Completed NCT00159393 - Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy: A Registry and Database