Energy Expenditure Clinical Trial
Official title:
Workload of Water Polo Players Following a Phosphorus Manipulated High Carbohydrate Meal
Phosphorus is a widely used sport supplement. Most athletes who use it follow a phosphorus loading approach which consists of a weeklong phosphorus intake of 3-4 gr per day for optimal effect. The ergogenic potential of phosphorus is believed to be related to several factors including its ability to a) enhance ATP availability for energy expenditure and b) increase plasma content of 2.3-DPG (2.3-disphosphoglycerate) that is known to reduce oxygen affinity to hemoglobin and consequently enhances its release in the exercising tissue. Additionally, phosphorus was reported to increase peripheral glucose uptake and thus glycogenesis and glycogen storage. We have recently observed that the peripheral glucose uptake was stimulated by co-ingestion of phosphorus with meal, while pre ingestion failed to do so. Thus it is reasonable to postulate that phosphorus co-ingestion with meal improves ergogenesis through enhancing glycogen storage. The aim of this experiment is to investigate whether acute phosphate supplementation of a glucose load is responsible for the performance enhancement. This may help in explaining the controversies surrounding the impact of phosphorus on performance. A cross over study will be conducted on water polo players. In brief, overnight fasted subjects, will be given glucose load with or without phosphorus. Three hours later their performance will be measured using an ergometer cycling machine.
The use of phosphorus as ergogenic aid has been widely reported and researched (Buck et al,
2013). Most of the research has centered on its chronic intake effect, usually for a loading
period of 3-6 days (Kopec et al, 2015). The benefits of phosphate supplementation on
athletic performance have been attributed to several potential factors, like increased
maximal oxygen uptake and improved cardiac output (Folland et al, 2008). The underlying
mechanisms were hypothesized to be the increased plasma content in 2.3-DPG
(2.3-disphosphoglycerate) which may be a factor in reduced oxygen affinity to hemoglobin and
consequent enhanced release in the exercising tissue (Di Caprio et al, 2015). Other lines of
investigation, which were based on blood analysis and hypophosphatemia's effect on
metabolism (Lichtman et al, 1971), and the rate of glycogenolysis in exercising muscle and
rate of inorganic phosphorus (Chasiotis, 1988), attribute the beneficial effects of
phosphate supplementation to higher extracellular concentration leading to increased ATP
formation. A positive effect of phosphate supplementation was detected independently of
2.3-DPG in a recent study (Czuba et al, 2009). Additionally, increased phosphate
availability was reported to increase peripheral glucose uptake (Khattab et al 2015) and
stimulate glycogen synthesis (Xie et al, 2000). The failure of acute phosphate
supplementation alone, without carbohydrate, to affect athletic performance (Galloway et al,
1996) may be partially attributed to low glycogen availability. We hypothesize that
phosphorus exerts its effect acutely through increasing glycogen content of liver and
muscles. Hence the acute effect of Phosphorus in physiologic doses on athletic performance
may reveal another aspect of phosphate supplementation. If an improvement in work output is
detected, as a significant difference in Metabolic Equivalent of Tasks (METs) and workload
would indicate, it could be interpreted as a result of a higher glycogen formation leading
to increased work output due to muscle signaling (Rauch et al, 2005). The current trial will
allow 3 hours of absorption to estimate the likely benefit of phosphorus supplementation
through enhanced glucose uptake possibly limited by phosphorus depletion under normal
conditions, as noticed in the experiment of Khattab et al. (2015). The risk of change in
blood osmolality due to administration of 100gr of Dextrose usually used in OGTT is minimal
(Finta et al, 1992) .
Methods:
Inclusion criteria: AUB water polo players who are between the age of 18 and 25 years old,
shall be included in the study.
Risk assessment: It should be noted that the university requires a clearance from Family
Medicine following a general health and cardiac screening (ECG) for inclusion on a varsity
team, which indicates that the trial includes no increased risk for the participating
athletes. The health survey filled by the Family Medicine department physician includes
presence of allergies and previous medical conditions.
A cross over study will be conducted on 17 male athletes (all members of the American
University of Beirut's Water Polo Varsity Team), that are known to have similar energy
expenditure and exercise patterns. Overnight fasted subjects will be depleted of glycogen.
Participants will be asked to cycle for 20 min at 65% of each one's VO2max (that is
determined prior to the experiment), thereafter will be given a meal (100g of glucose
dissolved in 300 ml) with 4 tablets of phosphorus (100mg/tablet) or placebo in a random
order.
Three hours later, participants will be asked to cycle for 40 mins, using the nutrition
lab's CPET cyclometer and cardiopulmonary exercise testing machine COSMED at 80% their
maximal heartrate (measured during a water polo training session). The heartrate during the
training will be determined by using a waterproof heartrate monitor, PoolMateHR made by
Swimovate and consisting of a specially designed low frequency detector that will transmit
in water as explained by the makers. Body fat will be determined using the In-Body
Bio-Electric Impedance machine at the nutrition lab. The ergometer will determine the METs
and allow us to detect any potential ergogenic gain.
Procedure:
1. Identification and recruitment of subjects: Subjects will be approached at the swimming
pool where the water polo training takes place. An overall briefing of the study will
be given to the varsity players and if they are interested, then a detailed explanation
will be given.
2. After reading and signing the consent form by both parties, participating athletes will
be asked during their training session to wear a heartrate monitor, PoolMateHR made by
Swimovate, to determine the heartbeat range during a typical training session which
includes warm-up, drills and a water polo game.
3. On the day of the experiment following an overnight fast, the participant will be taken
to the testing facility [Faculty of Agriculture and Food Sciences/Department of
Nutrition and Food Science] where: anthropometric measurements will be taken (height,
weight, WC), in addition to a body composition analysis using bioelectrical impedance
analysis (BIA) where the individual will stand on a digital scale which runs an
electrical current through the body in order to determine its composition (bones, fat,
muscles, water, and their specific distributions)
4. The participant will be asked to cycle on the ergometer for 20 minutes at an average of
65% of the maximal heartrate that is determined during training, wearing the
mouthpiece, to be familiar with the process. Afterwards, they will be served a flavored
drink containing 100 g of glucose dissolved in 300 ml of water, with either 4 pills
each containing 100 mg (total 400 mg) of phosphorus or placebo.
5. The participant will be asked to sit in a relaxed position and not to perform any major
physical activity. Three hours later, he will be asked to cycle on the ergometer for 40
minutes at an average of 80% of the determined maximal heartrate during training while
wearing the breathing mask.
6. The METs and workload will be measured using the CPET.
Analysis of Results:
Statistical Method:
Sample size was determined using the formula for two paired samples: n ≥ (σd /δd)2 (Zα+Zβ)2
which is reversely correlated to size effect, and directly correlated to Power. Since
supplementation is relatively safe, especially at the low doses we use, and because any
improvement is valuable, we opted for a Power between 70 and 80%.
Time trial results will compare workload and METs of two samples using a t-test, to estimate
the effect of acute phosphate supplementation on glycogen replenishment. The hypothesized
increase in workload after phosphate supplementation will be interpreted as the result of
glycogen signaling leading to higher output as per the suggestion of glycogen signaling
experiment (Rauch et al., 2005).
;
Status | Clinical Trial | Phase | |
---|---|---|---|
Completed |
NCT02544009 -
Quantifying the Persistence of Metabolic Adaptation and Weight Regain Following Extreme Weight Loss
|
||
Completed |
NCT05998096 -
A Randomized Study to Examine the Ability of a Caffeine-Based Energy Drink to Impact Energy Expenditure, Fat Oxidation, Reaction Time, and Other Perceptual Indicators
|
N/A | |
Suspended |
NCT00823329 -
Calorie Balance Monitoring and Analysis of Body Composition and Hydration Status
|
Phase 0 | |
Completed |
NCT01317732 -
MOTIONPOD (TM) Validation and Calibration Study
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT00781586 -
Efficacy of ONE A DAY Weightsmart Advanced Versus Caffeine and Placebo on Energy Expenditure, Thermogenesis and Perceived Energy Levels in Women.
|
Phase 4 | |
Completed |
NCT04389736 -
Effects of NMES on Energy Expenditure, Glycaemia and Hormonal Responses to Glucose Ingestion
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT02790255 -
BRown Fat Activity Measurement With Infrared imaginG tHermography andThermogenesis - the BRIGHT Study
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT02272166 -
Effects of Propofol on Early Recovery of Hunger After Surgery
|
Phase 4 | |
Completed |
NCT00995579 -
Assessment of Energy Expenditure by Indirect Calorimetry for a Daily 10,000 Steps Goal
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT03378115 -
Energy Cost of Posture Maintenance, Ethnic Differences and the Influence of Metabolic State
|
||
Recruiting |
NCT06432517 -
Sources and Mechanisms of Energy Compensation
|
N/A | |
Not yet recruiting |
NCT06320951 -
VITAL-IMPACT: Improving Cardiometabolic Health in Black Individuals Through Therapeutic Augmentation of Cyclic Guanosine Mono-Phosphate Signaling Pathway
|
Phase 2 | |
Completed |
NCT05412511 -
Metabolic Cost of Medicine Ball Training
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT05412498 -
Metabolic Cost of Battle Rope Training
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT02118662 -
Energy Expenditure During Seated, Seated Cycling, and Treadmill Walking Work Conditions (EE-Work)
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT03602144 -
Breakfast and Muscle Health in Children
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT01029236 -
Evaluation of Metabolism-Boosting Beverages
|
N/A | |
Terminated |
NCT00586807 -
Metabolic Response to Infliximab in Pediatric Ulcerative Colitis
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT04818905 -
Helichrysum Italicum Infusion Ingestion in Humans
|
N/A | |
Completed |
NCT03603041 -
Nutrition, Body Composition, and Sleep
|
N/A |