Outcome
Type |
Measure |
Description |
Time frame |
Safety issue |
Primary |
Incidence of inpatient post-operative delirium as measured using the confusion assessment method (CAM) |
|
Day 1 post-operatively |
|
Primary |
Incidence of inpatient post-operative delirium as measured using the confusion assessment method (CAM) |
|
Day 2 post-operatively |
|
Primary |
Incidence of inpatient post-operative delirium as measured using the confusion assessment method (CAM) |
|
Day 3 post-operatively |
|
Primary |
Performance on the Mini-Mental Status Examination (MMSE; Folstein MF, Folstein SE et al. 1975). |
A 30 point scale pre-operatively and at follow-up 7-8 years later. |
8 year follow-up |
|
Primary |
Performance on the Executive Clock Drawing Task (CLOX 1 & 2; Royall, Cordes et al. 1998). |
A 24 point scale pre-operatively and at follow-up 7-8 years later. |
8 year follow-up |
|
Primary |
Performance on the Controlled Oral Word Association Test (COWAT; Benton, A.L. Hamsher, K. Sivan, A.B. 1983). |
A test which measures both phonemic and semantic fluency. One point is awarded for each word generated (within the task parameters) within one minute. A total of five categories are assessed. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 7-8 years later will be compared. |
8 year follow-up |
|
Primary |
Performance on the Stroop Colour and Word Test (Golden 1978). |
This test features 100 items, the score reflects how many words were correctly identified in 45 seconds. A total of five categories are assessed. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 7-8 years later will be compared. |
8 year follow-up |
|
Primary |
Colour Trails 1&2 (D'Elia, Satz et al. 1996). |
Performance is measured in the time taken (seconds) taken to successfully complete this test. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 7-8 years later will be compared. |
8 year follow-up |
|
Primary |
New York Paragraph Recall Test (Kluger, Ferris et al. 1999). |
This test is scored based on the number of correctly recalled sections of the story. There are two recall conditions - immediate recall, assessed immediately following the reading of the paragraph and delayed recall, performance assessed five minutes following conclusion of the story. Each condition can earn a maximum of 21 points. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 7-8 years later will be compared. |
8 year follow-up |
|
Primary |
Weighted Composite Summary Cognitive Measure at 7-8 year Follow-up |
This weighted composite summary cognitive measure will be calculated based on the work of Inouye et al (Inouye, Marcantonio et al. 2016). This will be calculated (using outcome measures 4-9 above), for two time points 1) using preoperative scores and 2) using follow-up study visit scores. With the follow-up study visit scores being our primary outcome measure. The cognitive tests used in this study are similar to those utilised by the General Cognitive Performance score (Jones, Rudolph et al. 2010) and in deriving these scores we intend to use locally available normative data from representative samples, namely the Irish longitudinal studies (The Northern Ireland Cohort for the Longitudinal Study of Ageing (NICOLA) and The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing (TILDA)). |
8 year follow-up |
|
Secondary |
Performance on the Mini-Mental Status Examination (MMSE; Folstein MF, Folstein SE et al. 1975). |
Performance on this 30 point scale pre-operatively and at follow-up 6-12 weeks later will be compared. |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
Performance on the Executive Clock Drawing Task (CLOX 1 & 2; Royall, Cordes et al. 1998). |
Performance on this 24 point scale pre-operatively and at follow-up 6-12 weeks later will be compared. |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
Performance on the Controlled Oral Word Association Test (COWAT; Benton, A.L. Hamsher, K. Sivan, A.B. 1983). |
A test which measures both phonemic and semantic fluency. One point is awarded for each word generated (within the task parameters) within one minute. A total of five categories are assessed. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 6-12 weeks later will be compared. |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
Performance on the Stroop Colour and Word Test (Golden 1978). |
This test features 100 items, the score reflects how many words were correctly identified in 45 seconds. A total of five categories are assessed. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 6-12 weeks later will be compared. |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
Colour Trails 1&2 (D'Elia, Satz et al. 1996). |
Performance is measured in the time taken (seconds) taken to successfully complete this test. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 6-12 weeks later will be compared. |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
New York Paragraph Recall Test (Kluger, Ferris et al. 1999). |
This test is scored based on the number of correctly recalled sections of the story. There are two recall conditions - immediate recall, assessed immediately following the reading of the paragraph and delayed recall, performance assessed five minutes following conclusion of the story. Each condition can earn a maximum of 21 points. Performance pre-operatively and at follow-up 6-12 weeks later will be compared. |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
Weighted Composite Summary Cognitive Measure at 6-12 Week Follow-Up |
This weighted composite summary cognitive measure will be calculated based on the work of Inouye et al (Inouye, Marcantonio et al. 2016). This will be calculated (using outcome measures 11-16 above), for two time points 1) using preoperative scores and 2) using follow-up study visit scores at 6-12 weeks post-operatively. With the follow-up study visit scores being our primary outcome measure. The cognitive tests used in this study are similar to those utilised by the General Cognitive Performance score (Jones, Rudolph et al. 2010) and in deriving these scores we intend to use locally available normative data from representative samples, namely the Irish longitudinal studies (The Northern Ireland Cohort for the Longitudinal Study of Ageing (NICOLA) and The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing (TILDA)). |
6-12 weeks post-surgery |
|
Secondary |
Incidence of mild cognitive impairment and dementia at the time of follow-up study visit |
Diagnosed using appropriate criteria (Albert, DeKosky et al., 2011, McKhann, Knopman et al., 2011). |
8 year follow-up |
|