Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

CITT-ART is a multicenter study (8 locations around the United States) of 324 children ages 9 to <14 years with symptomatic convergence insufficiency (CI). The purpose of this study is to see if office-based therapy for convergence insufficiency (CI) improves reading ability and attention. CI is an eye-teaming problem where the eyes would like to drift outward when reading or doing close work. When eyes drift out, double vision can happen. To prevent double vision one must use extra effort to keep the eyes from going out. This extra effort can cause symptoms that can interfere with reading and working comfortably at near. These symptoms often include eyestrain, blurred vision, headaches, double vision, and loss of place when reading or performing tasks at near. In a prior study we found that therapy improves these symptoms. In this study we are looking at whether the therapy improves reading and attention


Clinical Trial Description

Following the success of the NEI-funded Convergence Insufficiency Treatment Trials (CITT), the next logical and important research issue is to determine if the successful treatment of symptomatic convergence insufficiency (CI) (i.e., improvement of symptoms and ophthalmic signs) impacts function (reading and attention).

It is well documented that children with symptomatic CI report significantly more symptoms when reading and doing close work (e.g., blurred vision, headaches, double vision, loss of concentration, frequent loss of place, trouble remembering what was read), manifest more academic-impairing behaviors (e.g., difficulty finishing assignments), and score worse on parent ratings of attention compared to children with normal binocular vision. Because reduction of symptoms and adverse academic behaviors are established outcomes of successful treatment of CI, we propose to test the hypothesis that resolution of these symptoms and behaviors leads to improved reading performance and attention. Previous studies have found improvements in reading comprehension reading speed and accuracy after successful treatment of CI. In a recent pilot study, investigators also found significant improvement in reading comprehension and attention after 16 weeks of successful treatment of symptomatic CI with office-based vergence/accommodative therapy; however, there was no control group. To definitively determine whether the successful treatment of symptomatic CI positively impacts reading and attention requires a placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial.

Objective: We propose a multicenter, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial (RCT) of 324 children ages 9 to <14 years (Grades 3-8) with symptomatic CI. [we will restrict recruitment to children who do not have significant single word reading deficits.] Participants will be randomized to 16 weeks of treatment with either [a] office-based vergence/accommodative therapy with home reinforcement (OBVAT) or [b] office-based placebo therapy with home reinforcement (OBPT). Outcomes (reading and attention) will be assessed after 16 weeks of treatment. In addition, we will test the long-term effects on outcomes at 1 year after treatment completion. All analyses will test the null hypothesis of no difference in outcomes between the two treatment groups.

Specific Aim 1 - Reading Performance: To compare reading comprehension outcomes for children with symptomatic CI who receive 16 weeks of OBVAT and OBPT treatment. The primary outcome measure of reading performance is the Wechsler Individual Achievement test (WIAT-III) reading comprehension subtest score. In secondary analyses, we will examine the effects of the treatment on word reading, pseudoword decoding, oral reading fluency, and listening comprehension. We also will examine the correlation of changes in CI symptoms and ophthalmic signs with reading outcomes. Analysis of the 1-year follow-up data will be used to determine if any gains in reading performance observed after 16 weeks of treatment are sustained.

Specific Aim 2 - Attention: To investigate the effect of treatment on teacher- and parent-rated measures of attention for children with symptomatic CI who receive 16 weeks of OBVAT and OBPT intervention. The primary outcome measure of attention is the score on the Strengths and Weaknesses of ADHD Symptoms and Normal Behavior Scale (SWAN). In secondary analyses, we will examine the effects of treatment on a second parent-rated attention scale called the SNAP. We also will examine the correlation of changes in CI-symptoms and ophthalmic signs with attention outcomes. Analysis of the 1-year follow-up data will be used to determine if any gains in attention observed after 16 weeks of treatment are maintained.

Scientific and Clinical Impact: The relationship between the treatment of symptomatic CI and its effect on reading and attention in children is unknown. The results of the proposed study will contribute to a better understanding of these relationships and help to resolve controversy surrounding this issue. The results will have important implications for educators, psychologists, eye professionals, and other health care providers who care for children with reading and attention problems and guide hypothesis development for future scientific investigations on evidence-based relationships between visual disorders and other developmental disorders in children. ;


Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT02207517
Study type Interventional
Source Salus University
Contact
Status Active, not recruiting
Phase Phase 3
Start date May 2014
Completion date November 2020

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT03248336 - Objective Assessment of Disparity Vergence After Treatment of Symptomatic CI in Children N/A
Recruiting NCT05262361 - Persistent Post-Concussion Symptoms With Convergence Insufficiency N/A
Terminated NCT03123822 - Spectacles Lens in Concussed Kids N/A
Completed NCT00472407 - Screening for Convergence Insufficiency in School-age Children
Completed NCT00347945 - Randomized Trial of Treatments for Convergence Insufficiency Phase 3
Completed NCT05070767 - Neurolens Headache Study N/A
Completed NCT03319966 - Eyetracking and Neurovision Rehabilitation of Oculomotor Dysfunction in Mild Traumatic Brain Injury
Recruiting NCT04691427 - Effectiveness of Virtual Reality Vision Therapy - VERVE Early Phase 1
Terminated NCT05087563 - Neurolens Convergence Insufficiency Study N/A
Completed NCT02607384 - The Baltimore Reading and Eye Disease Study N/A
Completed NCT00347581 - A Randomized Trial of Base-in Prism Reading Glasses Convergence Insufficiency in Children Phase 3
Recruiting NCT05603962 - The Effectiveness of Visual Training in Convergence Insufficiency Patients N/A
Completed NCT01515943 - Convergence Insufficiency Treatment Study (CITS) N/A
Recruiting NCT05877560 - Non-invasive Brain Stimulation for Treating Symptomatic Convergence Insufficiency N/A
Recruiting NCT05948046 - The Health-Related Quality of Life of the Patients With Symptomatic Convergence Insufficiency
Active, not recruiting NCT00338611 - Convergence Insufficiency Treatment Trial (CITT) Phase 3
Recruiting NCT05012384 - Effect of Vergence Exercises for Patients With Convergence Insufficiency After Concussion. N/A
Recruiting NCT05761106 - Effect of Exercises on Convergence Insufficiency in Individuals With Temporomandibular Disorders N/A
Completed NCT02510040 - A Prospective Observational Study of Adult Strabismus
Recruiting NCT05311917 - Home Vision Therapy and Prism Prescription in Presbyopic Persons With Convergence Insufficiency N/A