Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

NCT number NCT05367999
Other study ID # STH20060
Secondary ID
Status Completed
Phase
First received
Last updated
Start date February 9, 2022
Est. completion date June 30, 2023

Study information

Verified date January 2024
Source Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
Contact n/a
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Observational

Clinical Trial Summary

BACKGROUND: Transient loss of consciousness (TLOC) - defined as spontaneous disruption of consciousness not due to head trauma and with complete recovery - has a lifetime prevalence of 50%. It is one of the commonest neurological complaints in primary and emergency care. Over 90% of TLOC is due to either syncope, epilepsy or dissociative seizures (DS, also known as 'Psychogenic Nonepileptic Seizures'). The rapid and accurate distinction of these diagnoses is vital to allow appropriate further management but at least 20-30% of patients are not managed optimally or misdiagnosed. We have previously demonstrated that, in patients with established diagnoses of epilepsy, syncope, or DS, an automated classifier using only information from 36 questions based on patient experience and lay witness reports (the initial Paroxysmal Event Profile, iPEP) could accurately diagnose 86.0% of patients (with 100% sensitivity and 91.7% specificity for syncope) AIMS: To calibrate the iPEP for discrimination between syncope, epilepsy, and DS in patients newly presenting with TLOC, validate its performance in an independent sample, and to explore acceptability of the use of such a tool to people with TLOC and witnesses. METHODS: Nested qualitative-quantitative prospective single-centre development and validation of the iPEP in patients presenting to Emergency Departments, syncope or epilepsy clinics with first presentations of TLOC, with semi-structured interviews conducted with a purposive sample of participants from the quantitative study. The iPEP will be calibrated using a previously-described procedure for variable selection and training of Random Forest (RF) classifiers, and validated with assessment of overall classification accuracy, alongside sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and area under receiver-operating curve for each of the three target diagnoses. Performance will be evaluated against a benchmark set by results from previous research in patients with established diagnoses of epilepsy, syncope, and DS. OUTPUTS: Results will be submitted for publication in academic and professional literature. If performance from feasibility can be replicated in validation, the iPEP will be suitable to begin process of registration as a medical device for implementation in clinical pathways to minimise inappropriate referrals and treatment, streamline patient pathways, and enable earlier ordering of appropriate investigations to ensure prompt and appropriate diagnosis and management. If pilot performance could be replicated in this population and proportional savings from current estimated costs of misdiagnosis achieved, this could potentially save £63.9 million of annual UK healthcare expenditure.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Completed
Enrollment 186
Est. completion date June 30, 2023
Est. primary completion date June 30, 2023
Accepts healthy volunteers No
Gender All
Age group 16 Years and older
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria: - Patients first presenting with TLOC - Referred to secondary care for diagnostic evaluation OR given firm diagnosis of syncope in accordance with European Society of Cardiology guidelines for syncope presentations not requiring further investigation - Adult over the age of 16 years - Able to complete iPEP questionnaire independently - Participants do not need to be native English speaker but do need to have sufficient English language ability to complete iPEP without support Initial Exclusion Criteria: - Unable to give informed consent to participation in research - Unable to complete iPEP independently - Previous specialist (neurological or cardiological) assessment of TLOC Criteria for exclusion from analysis: - No firm clinical diagnosis of TLOC (and its cause) at end of 6-month follow-up period - Mixed diagnosis of multiple TLOC-causing disorders at end of 6-month follow-up; we exclude these participants from analysis as they would not have a single reference standard diagnosis, thus their inclusion in development may reduce model performance (since their questionnaire answers will describe multiple different kinds of episode), and in validation there is no principled way to assess performance of the prediction model if they have more than one reference diagnosis. A previous study of patients with suspected seizures in this population found that only 1.1% of patients could not be given a single aetiological diagnosis, so we do not anticipate this resulting in many exclusions.4 - Evidence of previous specialist (neurological or cardiological) assessment of TLOC.

Study Design


Intervention

Diagnostic Test:
initial Paroxysmal Event Profile
The initial Paroxysmal Event Profile (iPEP) was derived from the paroxysmal event profile (PEP) and paroxysmal event observer (PEO) to provide a diagnostic tool aiming to differentiate between the most common underlying reasons for TLOC presentations: syncope, epilepsy, and dissociative seizures. The iPEP is a 35-item questionnaire developed from the PEP and PEO.5,25 The 5-point frequency scales used in response to each symptom in the PEP and PEO have been replaced with a binary 'present'/'not present' classification in recognition of the fact that the target patient group may have experienced only one or a few episodes of TLOC.

Locations

Country Name City State
United Kingdom Northern General Hospital Sheffield South Yorkshire
United Kingdom Royal Hallamshire Hospital Sheffield South Yorkshire

Sponsors (1)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

Country where clinical trial is conducted

United Kingdom, 

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Other Participant experience A purposive sample of participants who have consented to be contacted about the additional interview study will be invited to participate in the nested qualitative research. Those consenting will take part in a semi-structured interview by telephone or in person. To help inform future adaptation and implementation of the iPEP, participants' feedback and views on how to communicate the decision aid results will be explored. All interviews will be audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. The data will be analysed using NVivo, and thematic analysis undertaken to identify recurring views and opinions. 6-month follow-up
Primary AUC for syncope We will compare classifier-predicted diagnoses against final diagnoses obtained by expert consensus review of medical records. We will define performance in terms of AUC for cardiogenic syncope. 6 months post-presentation
Secondary Overall classifier accuracy We will compare classifier-predicted diagnoses against final diagnoses obtained by expert consensus review of medical records. We will define performance in terms of classifier accuracy, and sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values for other diagnoses (i.e., epileptic/dissociative seizures). This will enable direct comparison with current rates of misdiagnosis. 6 months post-presentation
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT04534777 - Multimodal Neuroprognostication in Disorders of Consciousness
Completed NCT03504709 - REsting and Stimulus-based Paradigms to Detect Organized NetworkS and Predict Emergence of Consciousness
Recruiting NCT05823454 - Consciousness-specific Brain Network Connection of Propofol Sedation and Prolonged Disorders of Consciousness
Recruiting NCT04978857 - Feasibility Study of Virtual Reality to Promote the Awakening of Patients in a State of Minimal Consciousness N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT05670873 - Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Disorder of Consciousness in Acute Severe Cerebrovascular Disease Patients N/A
Terminated NCT03023657 - Detection of Arousal With Facial Micro-expression in Severe Brain-damaged Patient N/A
Completed NCT04435301 - Oscillatory Acoustic-electric Stimulation in Patients With Disorders of Consciousness N/A
Completed NCT05802524 - Neurophysiological Evaluation of Residual Cognitive Functions in Patients With Severe Alterations of Consciousness
Not yet recruiting NCT04248946 - Neural, Behavioural, and Clinical Effects of tDCS in PDOC; Feasibility Study N/A
Completed NCT04476589 - Prognostication of Recovery in Early Disorders of Consciousness After COVID-19
Completed NCT04687397 - Behavioral Signs of Consciousness Recovery in Patients With Disorders of Consciousness (DOCSIGNS)
Recruiting NCT04411719 - Outcome Prediction in Patients With Acute Disorders of Consciousness
Recruiting NCT04065386 - Transcutaneous Auricular Vagal Nerve Stimulation for Post-coma Patients With Disorders of Consciousness N/A
Completed NCT03341325 - Neurovascular Reactions to AAT in Patients With DOC N/A
Withdrawn NCT03475537 - tDCS in Patients With Disorders of Consciousness N/A