Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

The investigators hypothesize that injection of saline to the upper eyelids prior to lidocaine/adrenaline injection will reduce pain of the local anesthetic in comparison to injection of lidocaine alone.


Clinical Trial Description

Purpose:

To carry out a prospective randomised controlled clinical trial to compare the efficacy of saline injection prior to the injection of Lidocaine/Adrenaline in reducing the pain of local anaesthetic injections into the upper eyelid.

Hypothesis:

Injection of saline to the upper eyelids prior to lidocaine/adrenaline injection reduces the pain of anaesthetic injections in upper eyelid surgery.

Justification:

In many surgical procedures performed under local anaesthetic, the most frightening and painful aspect of the procedure for patients is the anaesthetic injection, and various techniques have been advocated to address this.

Simple measures that reduce the pain of anaesthetic injection and are widely practised include administering the injection slowly and using a fine-bore needle (30 Gauge). Other techniques that have been shown to be effective include warming or buffering the local anaesthetic. The use of 0.9% bacteriostatic saline solution in conjunction with lidocaine has been demonstrated to significantly reduce patients' perceived pain during the injection and operative procedure in eyelid surgery. Cooling the skin immediately prior to treatment has been shown to reduce the pain of dermatological laser procedures although this might be difficult to perform around the eyes because of the risk of injuring the cornea. Similarly, topical anaesthetic agents, such as EMLA (eutectic mixture of local anaesthetics) cream, which are applied to the skin one hour prior to injection are commonly employed for use on the limbs of infants and children but are not safe for use around the eyes since inadvertent ocular application causes corneal de-epithelisation.

Sedative agents, such as midazolam may be useful in anxious patients, but this requires the input of an anaesthetist and it is often difficult to finely control the level of sedation; it is usually preferable not to have patients sedated during eyelid surgery when patient cooperation is required intra-operatively to assess the height of the eyelids, for example in ptosis surgery.

The investigators have noticed in clinical practice that whenever the investigators injected saline into the upper eyelids prior to the injection of the mixture of lidocaine/adrenaline the patients reported of no pain. The investigators assume that by using the isotonic saline cells in the tissue are not harmed and a minor effect of anesthesia is achieved. The anesthetic solution injected later on is diluted, however the eyelid is properly anesthesized.

Research Methods:

The study will be a prospective, interventional, randomised, controlled clinical trial.

All patients who fit the inclusion criteria will be offered participation in the trial on the day their surgery is booked. They will be given an information leaflet about the trial, explaining the aim of the study without describing the effect of the saline injection prior to the anesthetic solution injection in order to reduce the risk of biasing their perception. They will be advised that non-participation will not affect their care in anyway.

The intervention is of no risk to the patient and will not affect the surgical procedure in any way. Any questions that the patient has will be addressed beforehand and they will be required to sign a consent form prior to inclusion in the trial.

They will be advised beforehand that they will be required to verbally rate their pain score on a scale of 0 to 10 immediately after both sides have been anaesthetised, with 0 being no pain and 10 being the worst imaginable pain.

All participants included in the study will undergo bilateral surgery and will therefore act as their own controls: Saline will only be injected prior to the injection of the anaesthetic into one side. The test and placebo will be randomly assigned to either the first or second eyelid; the right eyelid will be injected first in all patients, as is routine practice. Computer-generated sequential binary randomisation will be used. Allocation will be concealed from the surgeon until immediately prior to the anaesthetic injection.

All anaesthetic injections will consist of xylocaine 1% with 1:100,000 adrenaline and will be administered through a short 30 Gauge needle at a constant slow speed at multiple (6-7) sites along the upper lid by a single oculoplastic consultant.

Patients' verbal pain scores will be elicited and documented immediately by the oculoplastic fellow.

Planned sample size On a scale of 0 to 10 a difference in pain score of 1.5 may be considered to be clinically significant. The power calculation for a paired t-test with 90% power and p=0.05 demonstrated that a sample size of 80 patients to be more than sufficient to detect a significant difference.

The results will be submitted for publication in a peer-reviewed ophthalmological journal and presentation at international ophthalmological meetings. ;


Study Design

Allocation: Randomized, Intervention Model: Single Group Assignment, Masking: Open Label, Primary Purpose: Treatment


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT01239498
Study type Interventional
Source Sheba Medical Center
Contact Ido Didi Fabian, MD
Phone +972547830444
Email didifabian@gmail.com
Status Recruiting
Phase Phase 4
Start date November 2010
Completion date December 2011

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT00864656 - Eyelid Position Interdependence in Involutional Ptosis Patients Submitted to 10% Phenylephrine N/A
Recruiting NCT02959697 - Subconjunctival Injection of Local Anesthetic in Anterior Blepharoptosis Repair N/A
Recruiting NCT02501187 - Risk of Dry Eye Post Different Surgeries for Blepharoptosis Repair N/A
Completed NCT00793988 - Vibration-Assisted Anaesthesia Phase 4
Completed NCT02367677 - Digital Photographs to Evaluate Blepharoptosis N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT05358977 - Fibrin Sealant in Eyelid Surgery Phase 2/Phase 3
Completed NCT01848041 - Safety and Efficacy Study of RVL-1201 in Acquired Blepharoptosis Phase 1/Phase 2
Completed NCT01350024 - Comparison of Postoperative Pain With Two Different Types of Local Anesthesia in Surgery for a Drooping Eyelid N/A
Completed NCT06047418 - Blepharoptosis in Indonesia: A 5-Year Multicenter Study on Characteristics and Surgical Evaluation
Active, not recruiting NCT03149367 - Surgical Management of Blepharoptosis N/A
Completed NCT03565887 - Study of Safety and Efficacy of RVL-1201 in the Treatment of Blepharoptosis Phase 3
Recruiting NCT01968174 - Astigmatic Changes Secondary to Eyelid Surgeries N/A
Completed NCT03536949 - Study of Safety of RVL-1201 in Treatment of Blepharoptosis Phase 3
Active, not recruiting NCT04678115 - Clinical Trial Comparing Two Non-Surgical Treatments for Severe Blepharoptosis N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT04235803 - Telemedicine Follow-up for Routine, Low-Risk Oculoplastic Surgery N/A
Completed NCT02988856 - Magnetic Correction of Eye Lid Paralysis N/A
Terminated NCT03239418 - NMES to Improve Eyelid Functions in Cranial Nerve (CN) III and VII Palsy N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT02638610 - Assessment of Changes of Periocular Skin Sensation Following Eyelid and Ocular Surface Surgeries N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT05945615 - Oxymetazoline Drops for Acquired Blepharoptosis From Synkinesis Phase 3
Recruiting NCT06292182 - Red Light Ptosis Proof-of-Concept N/A