Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Completed
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT02091674 |
| Other study ID # |
15882 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Completed |
| Phase |
Phase 2
|
| First received |
November 27, 2013 |
| Last updated |
March 18, 2014 |
| Start date |
August 2013 |
| Est. completion date |
March 2014 |
Study information
| Verified date |
March 2014 |
| Source |
Lawson Health Research Institute |
| Contact |
n/a |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
|
| Study type |
Interventional
|
Clinical Trial Summary
To determine the efficacy and safety of hyaluronic acid (AdantTM, Tedec-Meiji Farma SA) for
acute ankle sprain, a single-site, open-label, controlled trial will be conducted.
The study will be conducted in a sport-medicine clinical research center in London, Ontario,
Canada. The eligible patients will be 18 years of age and older, have first or second degree
lateral sprain within 48h of the start of the treatment, and moderate or severe pain (>45mm
on 100 mm pain visual analogue scale /VAS). Exclusion criteria will include bilateral ankle
sprain, ipsilateral knee trauma, prior sprain in the past 6 months, use of NSAID prior to
entry, intra-articular ankle injection in the prior 6 months.
The patients will receive standard care (RICE and rescue analgesics), and a single 2.5cc
Adant periarticular ankle injection following provision of informed consent and collection of
baseline data. NSAIDs, corticosteroids or topical analgesics will not be allowed.
Assessments will be done at baseline, days 8, 30 and day 90. Efficacy measures will include
patient's pain VAS on weight bearing (0-100mm) and walking 20m (0-100mm), patients' global
assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical scale), patients' assessment of normal
function/activity (5 point categorical scale), physician's global assessment of ankle injury
(5 point categorical scale), patients/physician satisfaction assessment (10 point categorical
scale), time to return to pain-free and disability-free sport and adverse events as per WHO
definition.
It is expected that the Hyaluronic acid injections will decrease pain and swelling, promote
healing, improve time to return to sport and increase mobility.
Description:
Ankle sprains are among the most common of all sports injuries, with approximately two
million people per year seeking medical treatment (1, 2, 3). An epidemiological study of
professional, competitive, and recreational athletes found a prevalence of ankle sprain as
high as 73% (4). Data from the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2000
Emergency Department (ED) Summary listed about 1.375 million ED visits in the US due to ankle
sprains which represent about 1.3% of ED visits (5).
Ankle sprains most commonly affect the lateral ligament complex. The lateral ligament complex
of the ankle consists of three separate ligaments: anterior talofibular, posterior
talofibular and calcaneofibular. The anterior talofibular ligament is usually the ligament
affected although in more severe injuries the calcaneofibular ligament may also be involved.
Varus or inversion sprains include a spectrum of severity. Symptoms may include pain,
swelling, tenderness and functional loss. Ankle sprains are classified as first-, second- or
third-degree ankle sprains. A first-degree sprain represents a partial tear of a ligament
with mild tenderness and swelling, a second-degree sprain represents incomplete tear of a
ligament with moderate functional impairment, pain and swelling, and a third-degree sprain
represents a complete tear and loss of integrity of a ligament and presents with severe
swelling, ecchymosis, loss of function and mechanical instability (6, 7). The assessment and
treatment of an ankle injury may be performed by emergency and primary health care physicians
as well as orthopaedic and trauma surgeons (8).
The emphasis of therapy in ankle sprains is centered on reducing the inflammation and pain
rapidly following injury (7, 9). Guidelines for the treatment of acute ankle sprain from the
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons recommend initial rehabilitation program (up to
three weeks) with NSAIDs (non steroidal anti inflammatory drugs), RICE (rest, ice,
compression and elevation) as well as protected weight bearing, early mobilization and
isometrics (10). Conservative treatment may limit disability to an average of 8 days for a
grade 1 and 15 days for a grade 2 (3). Failure to provide adequate therapy can limit a
patient's efforts in rehabilitation and prolong the recovery period. In a study of ankle
sprain, pain and dysfunction was found to persist 6 to 18 months (average 12.8 months) after
initial ankle sprain in 73% of patients, with 40% reporting inability to walk one mile, and
11% continuing to use medications for ankle symptoms (11). In a long-term follow-up study,
nearly 40% of patients reported residual long-term symptoms and dysfunction 6.5 years after
initial ankle sprain (12). Also, long-term symptoms of ankle sprain have been noted by 40% of
athletes 6 months after acute injury (6).
NSAIDs effectively reduce the inflammation, pain, and disability associated with acute ankle
sprain (13, 14). The rationale for their use includes 1) pain control, 2) anti-inflammatory
effect to allow early activity and 3) decrease inflammation to speed healing directly.
However, NSAIDs are nonselective and may cause significant adverse events including UGI
intolerance and serious events such as ulcers and bleeding.
Hyaluronic Acid is a naturally occurring biological substance which has shown to have a
positive effect in viscosupplementation therapy. As it relieves pain and stiffness related to
osteoarthritis, it may have a similar effect on the ligaments affected by acute ankle sprain
in regards to anti-inflammatory effects. This would promote the mobility and decrease the
pain associated with acute ankle sprains. Hyaluronic Acid has no effect on UGI and platelet
function compared to traditional NSAIDs as it works locally within the site of injection.
2.0 RATIONALE
Previous studies conducted on joints affected by osteoarthritis have shown that hyaluronic
acid significantly reduced swelling, increased mobility and decreased pain. Based on those
results, the investigators believe that a patented hyaluronic may show efficacy on increasing
mobility and reducing pain on the acute ankle sprain.
3.0 OBJECTIVE
The aim of this non-controlled study is to evaluate the efficacy and of hyaluronic acid
(Adant) in the treatment of acute ankle sprain. It is expected to decrease pain and swelling,
promote healing, improve time to return to pain and disability-free sport and not increase
adverse events compared to standard care and placebo.
4.0 STUDY DESIGN
This is a single-site, open-label, non-controlled trial on the efficacy and safety of Adant
in patients with acute ankle sprain.
The study will include a screening phase where patients will be assessed based on selected
inclusion and exclusion criteria. Prior to enrollment, patients will undergo a screening
assessment that will include a physical exam. A diagnosis of first or second-degree ankle
sprain will be made. Pain severity will be assessed using a Pain Visual Analogue Scale (VAS).
After enrollment, patients will be administered Adant (within 48 hours of injury).
The Assessments will be done at baseline, days 8, 30 and 90. Efficacy measures will include
patient's VAS of pain on weight bearing (0-100mm) and walking 20m (0-100mm), patients' global
assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical scale), patients' assessment of normal
function/activity (5 point categorical scale), physician's global assessment of ankle injury
(5 point categorical scale), patients/physician satisfaction assessment (10 point categorical
scale), time to return to pain-free and disability-free sport and adverse events as per WHO
definition.
5.0 ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA Before starting the screening assessment, each patient must be given
a complete explanation of the purpose and evaluations of the study. Subsequently, the
patients must sign and receive a copy of an informed consent document that was approved by an
ethics board. Once informed consent has been obtained, the eligibility of the patient will be
determined and Screening Phase assessments will be performed followed by the Treatment and
Follow-up Phase assessments.
6.0 SCHEDULE OF TIME AND EVENTS The study will consist of a screening phase, a treatment
phase and a follow-up phase as described below.
Screening Phase:
On the Day 1 (within 48 hours of the injury), the patient will undergo an examination to
assess whether they meet all the inclusion criteria and none of the exclusion criteria after
signing the informed consent. The screening assessment includes a physical exam at which time
a diagnosis of first or second-degree sprain will be made. An x-ray of the ankle joint will
be performed to exclude other pathologies at the discretion of the study physician (ie to
exclude fracture). Patients will assess pain on a Visual Pain Analogue Scale (VAS) on weight
bearing and after walking 20 m. Patients will rate pain on a 100 mm VAS, with 0 representing
no pain and 100 representing maximal pain. Patients' global assessment of ankle injury (5
point categorical scale), patients' assessment of normal function/activity (5 point
categorical scale) and physician's global assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical
scale) will be performed. Time to return to pain and disability-free sport will be determined
in days from review of a patient diary. After enrollment, patients will administered Adant.
Treatment Phase:
One injection of Adant will be given on Day1.
Injections will be performed using previously (15) described syringes affixed to a 27-gauge,
1-inch needle. Skin will be prepped using betadine 1%. Injections will be delivered by the
study physician using a standard approach along the anterior talofibular ligament, using
clinical landmarks. The injection (2.5 mL total) will be delivered during a single
penetration along three planes (steps 1-3): anteroposterior, medial, and lateral to the
proximal ligamentous landmark (Fig. 1). All study physicians will attend a training session
to ensure standardization of injection technique, including video review of a sample of three
randomly selected patients during the study.
Patients will assess pain on a Visual Pain Analogue Scale (VAS) on weight bearing and after
walking 20 m. Patients' global assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical scale),
patients' assessment of normal function/activity (5 point categorical scale), and physician's
global assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical scale) will be performed.
Follow-up Phase:
Follow-up examinations will be completed at Day 8 (± 2 days), Day 30 (± 2 days) and at Day 90
(± 7 days). Patients will assess pain on a Visual Pain Analogue Scale (VAS) on weight bearing
and after walking 20 m. Patients' global assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical
scale), patients' assessment of normal function/activity (5 point categorical scale), and
physician's global assessment of ankle injury (5 point categorical scale) will be performed.
Also, patients/physician satisfaction assessment (10 point categorical scale) and review of a
patient diary for adverse events and return to pain and disability-free sport will be
performed.
During the study, including the follow-up period, the patients will receive usual care
including RICE (crutches, cane, ankle brand tape, air cast are allowed) and analgesics. The
analgesics use (Tylenol 500-1000mg daily) will be recorded in the patient's diary. No NSAID,
corticosteroid or topical analgesics will be allowed during the study. ASA at the dose of 325
mg and less for cardiovascular prophylaxis will be allowed.
7.0 STUDY SUPPLIES Under no circumstances shall any of the investigational material supplied
for this study be used other than as directed in this protocol. All investigational syringe
(used and unused) will be accounted for by the study coordinator.
7.1 Adant
Adant will be supplied in a single-dose syringe containing HA in enough excipient to make a
total volume of 2.5 mL (25mg in 1% solution). Syringes will be stored at room temperature
(10º-30ºC).
7.2 ACCOUNTABILITY OF STUDY SUPPLIES
Each syringe used will be entered in a Study Product Dispensing Log. It is the responsibility
of the Investigator to ensure that all supplies are accounted for throughout this trial.
The Study Coordinator will record in the CRF, the date of each injection, product lot number,
and the number of syringes used.
8.0 OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS 8.1 SAFETY ASSESSMENTS During the treatment and follow-up phases, in
order to evaluate safety, the following assessments will be conducted on all patients that
receive at least one dose of study product.
- Adverse events (throughout the study)
- Vital signs
8.2 EFFICACY ASSESSMENTS
The primary efficacy parameters are as follows:
- VAS of pain on weight-bearing (day 8)
- VAS of pain on walking (20 m) (days 8)
- Patient's global assessment of ankle injury (day 8)
The secondary efficacy assessments are as follows:
- Patients assessment of normal function/ activity (days 8, 30, 90)
- Physician's global assessment of ankle injury (days 8, 30, 90)
- Patients and Physicians Satisfaction Assessments (days 8, 30, 90)
- Time to return to pain and disability-free sport (days 8, 30, 90)
9.0 REPORTING OF ADVERSE EVENTS
An adverse event is defined by the ICH as "any untoward medical occurrence in a clinical
investigation subject administered a pharmaceutical product and that does not necessarily
have a causal relationship with this treatment. An AE can therefore be any unfavorable and
unintended sign, symptom or disease temporarily associated with the use of an investigational
product, whether or not related to the product".
A serious AE is any untoward medical occurrence that at any dose; (1) results in death, (2)
is life threatening, (3) results in inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing
hospitalization, (4) results in persistent or significantly disability or incapacity or (5)
results in congenital anomaly or birth defect.
Investigators will report immediately all SAE to the Ethics Review. The investigator should
fill in a SAE report (see CRF) within 24 hours.
10.0 STUDY SITE TERMINATION AND SUBJECT DISCONTINUATION
A site may be terminated for the following reasons:
- Failure of the site to recruit enough patients
- Failure of the site to comply with the protocol
A subject may be discontinued for the following reasons:
- Failure of a patient to comply with the protocol
- Serious adverse event
11.0 DATA COLLECTION AND PROCESSING
All data will be recorded in the CRFs and collected by the Clinical Trial Study Monitor
during scheduled visits. The CRFs will be designed to assist the Investigator with protocol
compliance and to facilitate collection, interpretation and analysis of data. The CRFs must
be kept up to date and completed as specified. Data reported in a case report form (CRF)
should be consistent with source documents. Any change or correction to a CRF should be
dated, initialed and explained. CRFs will be monitored to ensure that the clinical trial is
conducted in accordance with the protocol, GCP and the applicable regulatory requirements.
12.0 STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Patients 18 years of age and older who provide written informed
consent and who meet the inclusion and exclusion criteria will be entered into the trial.
Statistical analysis will be based on the intent to treat population and the efficacy
evaluable population. The first population is defined as subjects who will receive any dose
of Adant, and the second efficacy-evaluable population is defined as the subjects who
completed Day 8 of the study. Efficacy and safety variables will be analyzed using
appropriate statistical methods. The data will be summarized in tables listing and all
statistical analysis will be performed and data appendices will be created using the SAS®
system.
The study populations will include: the intent-to-treat population defined as all subjects
who receive the study treatment and have at least one efficacy assessment at Day 8; the
safety population who will be all patients who receive the study treatment whether or not
they have any efficacy assessments; and the per protocol population who receive the study
treatment and complete all efficacy assessments. The primary efficacy endpoint is the
decrease in pain on weight-bearing by Day 8. Other endpoints will be analyzed based on
patient's VAS of pain on weight bearing as well as walking, the patient's global assessment
of ankle injury, the patient's assessment of normal function/activity, the physician's global
assessment of ankle injury, and finally, time to return to pain and disability-free sport,
the patient and physician's satisfaction assessment.
The safety analysis will be done on the intent-to treat population. AEs will be listed
individually and summarized by body system and preferred terms within a body system. Safety
parameters will also include vital signs.
13.0 CLINICAL STUDY ADMINISTRATION
Informed consent:
The written informed consent to be provided to patients should adhere to GCP and to the
ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects as defined in the
Declaration of Helsinki. Prior to the beginning of the trial, the written informed consent
must have been approved by the ethics review board.
Written informed consent must be obtained for each patient prior to performing any
screening/baseline evaluation. One copy of the informed consent will be given to the subject,
and another will be retained by the Investigator.
Any revision to the written informed consent must be approved by the ethics review board.
Furthermore any communication between the investigator and the ethics review board should be
documented.
Study documentation:
The investigator should ensure the accuracy and completeness of the data reported in CRFs.
The investigator should maintain the essential documents for the conduct of a clinical trial
as specified by the GCPs and for as long as required by the applicable regulatory
requirements.
