Reducing the Carbon Footprint Through Education on the Effects of Inhalation Anesthetics on Global Warming

Anesthesia Clinical Trial

Official title:

Reducing the Carbon Footprint of Operating Rooms Through Education on the Effects of Inhalation Anesthetics on Global Warming

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

• NCT number: NCT06084039
• Other study ID #: 05-2023-067
• Status: Completed
• Start date: August 1, 2022
• Est. completion date: September 25, 2023

Study information

• Verified date: October 2023
• Source: Pusan National University Yangsan Hospital
• Contact: n/a
• Is FDA regulated: No
• Study type: Observational

Clinical Trial Summary

Inhalation anesthetics, such as desflurane, are identified as contributors to global warming, with the European Union planning to ban desflurane in 2026 due to its impact. The World Federation of Societies of Anesthesiologists (WFSA) has published guidelines to reduce air pollution related to inhalation anesthetics. Inhalation anesthetics account for a significant portion of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) emissions in hospitals and surgery. Various anesthetics have different global warming potentials (GWP100), with desflurane having the highest GWP100. Nitrous oxide and isoflurane, although having lower GWP100, can also impact the environment negatively. Studies have shown that educating anesthesia staff about the environmental impact of desflurane and nitrous oxide can lead to significant reductions in their usage, resulting in lower CO2e emissions and cost savings. However, in some regions like Korea, awareness of the environmental impact of inhalation anesthetics is limited. The authors plan to analyze the impact of education on anesthesiologists regarding inhalation anesthetics and assess changes in their usage and CO2e emissions in clinical settings. The goal is to demonstrate that education can positively influence environmental outcomes and reduce economic losses.

Description:

Environmental issues are a global concern and a problem that everyone must solve together. Recently, there have been efforts to reduce carbon footprint in the medical field. In the field of anesthesiology, as it became known that inhalation anesthetics have a significant impact on global warming, the European Union officially declared in 2022 to ban the use of the inhalation anesthetic desflurane from 2026. Additionally, the World Federation of Societies of Anesthesiologists (WFSA) published guidelines on the use of inhalation anesthetics to reduce air pollution in 2022.

Inhalation anesthetics are known to account for 0.01-0.1% of the total carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) contribution to global warming. This is 5% of hospital CO2e and 50% of surgery-related CO2e. Only 5% of the inhalation anesthetic is metabolized in the patient's body, and the remaining 95% is discharged through the anesthetic gas scavenging system of the anesthesia machine and released into the atmosphere without any additional post-processing. Representative inhalation anesthetics that are currently widely used include nitrous oxide (N2O), sevoflurane, desflurane, and isoflurane. Comparing their global warming potential (global warming potential 100, GWP100; which indicates the degree of greenhouse gas effect compared to CO2 over 100 years), nitrous oxide 298, sevoflurane 130, desflurane 2540, and isoflurane 510. Among these, desflurane shows the highest GWP100 and is presumed to be due to its high minimum alveolar concentration. In addition, nitrous oxide and isoflurane have relatively low global warming potential, but they can destroy ozone and, in particular, nitrous oxide has a half-life of 114 years, so it can stay in the atmosphere for a long time and affect global warming.

Several studies have reported significant reductions in CO2e and medical costs along with a reduction in the use of these two anesthetics after educating anesthesia staff on the use of desflurane and nitrous oxide. In one study, desflurane usage was reduced by 95.63% and CO2e was reduced by 87.88%. In another study, desflurane use was reduced from 8.3% to 0.3%, CO2e was reduced from 1,681 to 10, and medical costs were saved by $200,000 over 3 years. In Korea, sevoflurane and desflurane are the most used, but the impact of inhalation anesthetics on global warming is not well-known to clinicians, and there are no related studies.

After educating anesthesiologists about the impact of inhalation anesthetics on global warming, the investigators analyzed the use of inhalation anesthetics and changes in CO2e before and after education in actual clinical situations to determine whether education alone could reduce their use. In addition, the investigators aim to show that this can have a positive impact on global warming and economic losses.

Education on the effects of inhalation anesthetics on global warming was conducted for every anesthesiologist in our hospital, and only medical records were reviewed retrospectively to confirm if there were any changes in choice of inhalation anesthetic, and fresh gas flow before and after receiving the training. Inevitably, patients for whom general anesthesia was performed by untrained anesthesiologists about the effects of inhalation anesthetics on global warming were excluded from the analysis. This is an observational study because there is no intervention applied to the patient, and patients not included in the study are also administered general anesthesia using the same method.

Recruitment information / eligibility

• Status: Completed
• Enrollment: 4478
• Est. completion date: September 25, 2023
• Est. primary completion date: February 28, 2023
• Accepts healthy volunteers: No
• Gender: All
• Age group: N/A and older

Eligibility

Inclusion Criteria:

• Patients who underwent surgery under general anesthesia performed for 1 month before and after education on the effects of inhalation anesthetics on global warming

Exclusion Criteria:

• Surgery performed under regional anesthesia

• Surgery performed under total intravenous anesthesia

• When the type of inhalation anesthetic is changed during surgery

• Short surgery within 1 hour

• In case of anesthesia by an anesthesiologist who did not attend the education on the effects of inhalation anesthetics on global warming

Related Conditions & MeSH terms

• Anesthesia
• Respiratory Aspiration

Locations

Country	Name	City	State
Korea, Republic of	Pusan National University Yangsan Hospital	Yangsan

Sponsors (1)

Lead Sponsor	Collaborator
Pusan National University Yangsan Hospital

Country where clinical trial is conducted

Korea, Republic of, 

Outcome

Type	Measure	Description	Time frame	Safety issue
Primary	Concentration of inhalation anesthetic used to maintain general anesthesia	It is calculated using the average value of the inhalation anesthetic concentration and fresh gas flow rate during the entire anesthesia time, excluding 15 minutes after the start of general anesthesia and 15 minutes before the end of anesthesia. The formula for calculating the total amount of inhalation anesthetic is as follows.; Total amount of inhalation anesthetic used (mL)=([(Fresh gas flow rate (L/min)*1000)*(concentration of inhalation anesthetic (vol%))]/ Density (kg/cm3))* duration of anesthesia (hrs); Amount of sevoflurane used per hour (mL); ([((MW (kg/mol)*(FGF (L/min)*1000)*(concentration of sevoflurane (vol%)/100)/24400)/1000]*60)/ Density (kg/cm3); [(200 *(FGF*1000)*(vol%/100)/24400)/1000]*60/ 0.00152; Amount of desflurane used per hour (mL); ([((MW (kg/mol)*(FGF (L/min)*1000)*(concentration of desflurane (vol%)/100)/24400)/1000]*60)/ Density (kg/cm3); [(168 *(FGF*1000)*(vol%/100)/24400)/1000]*60/ 0.001465	Total time for general anesthesia, up to 24hours
Primary	Fresh gas flow rate used to maintain general anesthesia	It is calculated using the average value of the inhalation anesthetic concentration and fresh gas flow rate during the entire anesthesia time, excluding 15 minutes after the start of general anesthesia and 15 minutes before the end of anesthesia. The formula for calculating the total amount of inhalation anesthetic is as follows.; Total amount of inhalation anesthetic used (mL)=([(Fresh gas flow rate (L/min)*1000)*(concentration of inhalation anesthetic (vol%))]/ Density (kg/cm3))* duration of anesthesia (hrs); Amount of sevoflurane used per hour (mL); ([((MW (kg/mol)*(FGF (L/min)*1000)*(concentration of sevoflurane (vol%)/100)/24400)/1000]*60)/ Density (kg/cm3); [(200 *(FGF*1000)*(vol%/100)/24400)/1000]*60/ 0.00152; Amount of desflurane used per hour (mL); ([((MW (kg/mol)*(FGF (L/min)*1000)*(concentration of desflurane (vol%)/100)/24400)/1000]*60)/ Density (kg/cm3); [(168 *(FGF*1000)*(vol%/100)/24400)/1000]*60/ 0.001465	Total time for general anesthesia, up to 24hours
Secondary	CO2e (total carbon dioxide equivalent), driving equivalent (equivalent driving distance, distance traveled by car to generate the same amount of greenhouse gases), and medical costs incurred due to the use of inhalation anesthetics	Based on data examined from medical records, CO2e (total carbon dioxide equivalent), driving equivalent (equivalent driving distance, distance required to drive to generate the same amount of greenhouse gases), and medical costs incurred due to inhalation anesthetics were calculated by Anesthesia cost calculator (https://jscalc.io/calc/do45BOJVrzXMaEGC). The formulas for calculating CO2e (total carbon dioxide equivalent), and driving equivalent are as follows.; CO2e (kg) =130 * 200* ((FGF*1000)*(concentration of inhalation anesthetic /100)/24400/1000)*60* duration of anesthesia; driving equivalent (km) = CO2e *3.922	Total time for general anesthesia, up to 24hours