Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Details — Status: Completed

Administrative data

NCT number NCT03722654
Other study ID # R34MH117212
Secondary ID
Status Completed
Phase N/A
First received
Last updated
Start date September 1, 2020
Est. completion date June 30, 2022

Study information

Verified date August 2023
Source The National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University
Contact n/a
Is FDA regulated No
Health authority
Study type Interventional

Clinical Trial Summary

This study aims to advance the science of mental health services for adolescent externalizing problems (AEPs) by developing therapist training procedures to increase fidelity to evidence-based interventions (EBIs) in usual care. Two widely endorsed approaches are consistently effective for treating AEPs: family therapy and CBT. Importantly, stronger fidelity to core EBIs of these approaches predicts better outcomes in research and community settings. Yet these EBIs are not widely implemented with fidelity. To help close this quality gap in adolescent services, investigators will develop an online intervention to strengthen fidelity to these EBIs in routine care: Measurement Training and Feedback System for implementation (MTFS-I). MTFS-I will target two essential aspects of EBI fidelity: Training components will seek to improve EBI self-monitoring, and a Feedback component will seek to increase EBI utilization. In keeping with NIMH's Experimental Therapeutics paradigm, this study will examine whether an Intervention (MTFS-I) has direct impact on immediate Targets (EBI self-monitoring and utilization). If promising, future R01 studies will examine links among intervention, targets, and ultimate outcomes (AEPs). The MTFS-I package will be an online quality assurance system completed by therapists and supervisors that can be readily sustained in usual care. Two weekly Training components will adapt gold-standard observational fidelity coding procedures to promote improved self-monitoring of the targeted EBIs, and a monthly Feedback component will adapt a measurement feedback system to promote increased utilization of these EBIs in everyday practice. To maximize provider investment, sites will delineate their own fidelity standards for family therapy and CBT and help design feedback report templates. The proposed study will be among the first to (1) test whether training therapists in observational assessment of EBI fidelity increases the accuracy with which they self-monitor use of those EBIs and (2) adapt measurement feedback procedures to track and improve therapist utilization of EBIs. To achieve study aims the investigators will first partner with two community clinics to develop sustainable MTFS-I procedures using a three-phase Pilot process. Investigators will then initiate an experimental Trial during which therapists (n = 32, treating 192 clients) at four different clinics will be randomized to MTFS-I versus no-intervention Control. In both conditions two kinds of data will be collected: therapist-report checklists on use of core family therapy and CBT techniques with adolescent cases and treatment session audio recordings. MTFS-I uptake will be tracked electronically for online components (Aim 1: MTFS feasibility). Session recordings will be coded by observers for three facets of EBI fidelity: adherence (extent of EBI utilization), working alliance, and therapist competence. Observer ratings will measure the strength of EBI self-monitoring (Aim 2: therapist reliability and accuracy) and fidelity (Aim 3 [EBI utilization] & Aim 4 [alliance, competence]). If effective, MTFS-I could be adapted to promote EBI fidelity for a variety of clinical populations and approaches.


Description:

Discovering and disseminating effective methods to improve the quality of available treatment services for adolescent externalizing problems is an urgent public health priority. Despite the strong legislative and policy focus on quality of care evident in the CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2009 and the Affordable Care Act of 2010, comprehensive reports underscore the enduring "quality chasm" between behavioral treatments proven in controlled research versus those commonly practiced in usual care. The quality gap is highly evident for adolescent externalizing problems (AEPs), which encompass serious conduct problems, delinquency, and substance misuse. AEPs are the most common adolescent behavioral issues in specialty care, which follows from high prevalence rates: conduct disorder has a 9.5% lifetime prevalence rate, and 19% of adolescents report past-year illicit drug use with 7% meeting criteria for psychiatric disorder. Yet standard treatment quality for AEPs is considered mediocre to inadequate due to a host of factors headlined by the absence or modest quality of evidence-based services, insufficient provider training, and little quality monitoring. Two behavioral treatment approaches are prime candidates for upgrading the quality of AEP treatment services. Both family therapy (FT) and cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) have excellent efficacy evidence for AEPs in both research and community settings. Each has strong support for treating serious conduct problems, delinquency, and substance use, and each has several manualized versions proven efficacious across the AEP range. Due to this extensive evidence base, there is incentive from clinical providers and payers to deliver these approaches in routine care: Both are now approved for treating AEPs by federal and private insurance plans and by regulatory agencies that govern licensed treatment providers. Notably, therapists report that both approaches are highly valued in everyday practice. By consensus, the most efficient pathway toward improving the quality of mental health services is to increase the adoption and delivery of evidence-based interventions (EBIs) in usual care. However, there is a caveat: For EBIs to be effective in frontline settings, they must be delivered with sufficient fidelity to the principles and procedures of the approaches they represent. This remains a most difficult challenge for which innovative solutions are sorely needed. With regard to AEPs, controlled studies have shown that strong fidelity to the FT and CBT approaches predicts improved client outcomes in both efficacy and effectiveness studies. Yet, at this time, neither FT nor CBT are widely implemented with fidelity in community clinics that treat AEPs. To promote EBI fidelity as a core virtue of the behavioral care system, the study team published a theoretical model in which EBI implementation is recognized as an essential driver of positive client outcomes. This model includes structural characteristics of care that directly influence both implementation and outcomes, as well as outcomes considered relevant within the "quality of care" framework. The middle section depicts elements of implementation that have proven salient for effective EBI delivery, including technical factors (adherence to core treatment techniques, therapist competence) and relational factors (e.g., alliance), given that both are related to outcomes. According to this model and similar others, EBI implementation fidelity is a multidimensional construct with three primary facets: Adherence (extent to which signature EBI techniques are utilized), Competence (skillfulness and responsiveness of EBI delivery), and Alliance (working relationship between provider and client). In AEP research, fidelity-outcome studies consistently find that stronger EBI adherence and stronger alliance predict better client outcomes. Evidence for competence-outcome effects is less consistent, in large part because competence remains difficult to operationalize reliably. According to this framework, innovations aimed at improving service quality should directly target EBI fidelity; stronger EBI fidelity will then boost client outcome.


Recruitment information / eligibility

Status Completed
Enrollment 42
Est. completion date June 30, 2022
Est. primary completion date June 1, 2022
Accepts healthy volunteers No
Gender All
Age group N/A and older
Eligibility Inclusion Criteria: - Therapists treating adolescents aged 12-21 at partnering treatment sites Exclusion Criteria: -

Study Design


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


Intervention

Behavioral:
MTFS-I Installation
MTFS-I Installation will focus on introducing MTFS-I components including weekly training modules and mock video segments to be coded, as well as monthly feedback reports summarizing therapist self-reported FT and CBT implementation in active cases. Facilitation will also be included to review progress and provide regular support.

Locations

Country Name City State
United States Montefiore New York New York
United States Roberto Clemente Center New York New York
United States The LGBT Community Center New York New York

Sponsors (2)

Lead Sponsor Collaborator
The National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)

Country where clinical trial is conducted

United States, 

Outcome

Type Measure Description Time frame Safety issue
Primary Change in EBI Fidelity: ITT-ABP Therapist-Report Inventory of Therapy Techniques for Adolescent Behavior Problems is a 24-item, post-session, therapist-report fidelity tool that meets key criteria for pragmatic measures: relevance to stakeholders, low burden, broad applicability, strong psychometrics, and useful for data-driven decision-making (actionable). It requires 2-3 minutes to complete and was derived from validated observational fidelity tools for manualized treatments via a stakeholder-informed instrument adaptation process. The FT and CBT items each measure the adherence (i.e., thoroughness and frequency) with which each technique was used based on a 5-point Likert-type scale: 0 = Not at all, 1 = A little bit, 2 = Moderately, 3 = Considerably, 4 = Extensively. Conclusion of every session for 1 year
Secondary EBI Fidelity: ITT-ABP Observational Version The ITT-ABP observational version mirrors the therapist-report version, with the addition of two items. To capture Competence, we will use a single item (identical 5-point scoring scale): "Please rate the extent to which you were skillful and responsive in today's session". Competence is difficult to judge reliably even for trained coders. Nonetheless, we have had moderate success in coding Competence with a single item for both EBIs via the observational version of ITT-ABP: ICC = .55 for FT and .56 for CBT, 58. To capture Alliance, we will use the VTAS-R Short Form, a 5-item observational measure of therapeutic alliance, defined as the collaborative working relationship in therapy. The VTAS-R Short Form has likewise shown strong internal consistency, high correlations with the full-length VTAS-R, and predictive validity for retention and clinical outcomes for AEPs. Through study completion, approximately 1 year
See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Completed NCT05071989 - The Influence of Sleep Education With Social Media Reminders on the Sleep Quality in Adolescents N/A
Recruiting NCT05064293 - Assisted Identification and Navigation of Early Mental Health Symptoms in Children N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT05017779 - A Hybrid Effectiveness-implementation Trial of a High School-based Executive Function Treatment for Autistic Youth N/A
Completed NCT03685643 - Study Proposal for Web Based Intervention to Promote the Safe Usage of Dating Applications in Young Adults N/A
Completed NCT03270943 - The S.M.A.R.T. Project: Stress Management and Resilience Training for Teens N/A
Recruiting NCT05525962 - Vulnerability/Resilience Factors Influencing the Developmental Trajectories and Adaptive Methods of Children and Adolescents in Child Welfare System.
Completed NCT03411577 - Development and Testing of a Jamaican Mother-daughter HIV Risk-reduction Program N/A
Recruiting NCT05334381 - Navigating Mental Health Treatment for Black Youth N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT05926141 - Advanced Cooking Education Pilot Study N/A
Recruiting NCT04317547 - Translation Study of a Safe Teen Driving Intervention N/A
Recruiting NCT06001892 - Tennessee Youth Prepared for Success N/A
Enrolling by invitation NCT06127277 - Next4You: A Fully Mobile Relationships Based Program for Youth in Foster Care N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06310434 - Analysis of COMPASsion and Humanisation of Adolescents Facing the End-of-life Processes.
Not yet recruiting NCT05316948 - Mental Health and Sexuality in Adolescents and Young Adults
Terminated NCT02578147 - JUEGA: A Fun Study for Hispanic/Latino Adolescent Girls N/A
Completed NCT02683811 - Effectiveness of the Updated Version of the School-based Program Diario Della Salute (DDS-2) N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT02329015 - Curriculum Evaluation of a Novel Health and Wellness Program Within New York City Schools Phase 1
Completed NCT03482687 - It's Your Game: An Innovative Approach to Preventing Teen Dating Violence N/A
Completed NCT01433679 - The Effect of a Web-Based Behavioral Intervention on Physical Activity Levels in Adolescents N/A
Completed NCT00056953 - Peer Mentors for Adolescents in HIV Affected Families Phase 2