Clinical Trials Logo

Clinical Trial Summary

Children without consistent access to sufficient and nutritious food show sustained disadvantages. To improve food security, households utilize three types of coping strategies- participating in governmental feeding and financial assistance programs; obtaining food from nongovernment providers; and using individually developed strategies. To understand the interdependencies among strategies and decision-making processes used to select them, the investigators conducted a two-phased, mixed-methods study using a socio-ecological theoretical framework. First, employing a cross sectional, observational design the investigators administered in-person surveys to 320 adults in very low food secure (VLFS) households with children. Over 1 year later, the investigators repeated select questions and conducted in depth interviews with a cohort (n=28) of participants. Descriptive statistics defined magnitude of associations among strategies. Following bivariate analysis, the investigators assessed interdependencies and factors affecting relationships with log-linear models. The investigators analyzed interviews using an hierarchically ordered, analytical coding structure. With Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), the investigators developed typologies of VLFS and created models treating food security as an outcome. The association of soup kitchen use and nutritionally risky behavior was altered by Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). Food safety-related risky behavior level related to intensity of food pantry use by participation in school food programs. Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) did not affect the association between soup kitchen use and risky food safety behaviors. Key interview constructs included becoming and being short of food; coping strategies; decisions used to inform choice of strategies; and managing a devalued social status. Improved income stability was a necessary condition for improving food security.


Clinical Trial Description

Food insecurity is a serious issue facing households in the United States. In 2012, the time this study was begun, the U.S. Department of Agriculture reported that almost 15% of U.S. households and one in five households with children were considered to be food insecure. Over one third of these experienced very low food security (VLFS), with multiple indicators of disrupted eating patterns due to inadequate resources. These statistics are of particular concern because children without consistent access to sufficient and nutritious food show sustained disadvantages, including effects on cognition, academic performance, long-term nutritional status, and psychosocial development. To improve their food security, households utilize three types of coping strategies- (1) participating in federal feeding and financial assistance programs ("safety net"), (2) obtaining food from nongovernment Emergency Food Providers (EFPs), and (3) using individually developed coping strategies. The objectives of this study related to developing a better understanding of the coping strategies that VLFS households with children use to ensure that their households have sufficient food. Specifically, the study addressed two main research questions: What are the interdependencies among three types of coping strategies: participating in federal feeding and financial assistance programs ("safety net"), obtaining food from EFPs, and using individually developed coping strategies. What decision-making processes do people in VLFS households with children use when selecting coping strategies to ensure that their households have sufficient food? The investigators conducted a two-phased mixed-methods study of coping strategies used by VLFS households with children <18 years in North Carolina (NC), using a socio-ecological theoretical framework to guide their hypotheses, methods, and analyses. For phase I, the investigators employed a cross sectional, observational design. The investigators used a two-stage sample to recruit 320 clients of service providers who offer assistance to people with limited resources within eight NC counties with the highest food insecurity rates. Trained interviewers administered in-person a survey interview asking clients socio-demographic questions and about their use of three categories of coping strategies. Using a longitudinal design, more than a year after Phase I, in Phase II, the investigators completed in depth interviews with a cohort (n=28) of Phase I participants, selected using maximum variation sampling. During the largely unscripted interviews, participants were asked a select number of close ended questions from Phase I, including the 18 item food security module, to assess changes over the past year and permit comparisons between times one and two. To address the first question, two by two and multi-dimensional contingency tables were constructed to analyze the interdependencies among the three types of coping strategy outcomes. Descriptive statistics (odds ratios, counts and percentages) were performed to define the magnitude of the association among coping strategies. Fisher's exact tests and Chi-square statistics were then employed to assess the statistical significance of the interdependency among the outcomes. To further determine the interdependencies among the three coping strategies, and to assess how individual and household-level factors affect those interdependencies, the investigators employed log-linear models. To address the second research question, the investigators formulated a hierarchically ordered, analytical coding structure that reflected key decision-making constructs (e.g., knowledge of coping strategies, perception of risk of accessibility and availability of coping strategies, barriers to participation in "safety net" programs) and examined the results in terms of the key constructs. Lastly, responses to both sets of questions were jointly reviewed using Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), a mixed-methods analysis technique. The investigators implemented a conventional, crisp set for (1) developing typologies of households and individuals experiencing very low food insecurity, and (2) exploring pathways to improving food security status among participants in the follow-up interviews. All procedures involving human participants was reviewed and approved by RTI International's Institutional Review Board (IRB). ;


Study Design

Observational Model: Case-Only, Time Perspective: Cross-Sectional


Related Conditions & MeSH terms


NCT number NCT02767141
Study type Observational
Source RTI International
Contact
Status Completed
Phase N/A
Start date May 2012
Completion date December 2014

See also
  Status Clinical Trial Phase
Recruiting NCT06313112 - Impact of Food Insecurity on Utilization of Maternal Healthcare Services and Birth Outcomes in Slums in Pune, India
Completed NCT03436589 - The Indiana SNAP-Ed Long-term Study N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT06298253 - Behavioral Economics to Implement a Traffic Light Nutrition Ranking System: Study 2 N/A
Completed NCT03026608 - Green Cart Program Evaluation N/A
Recruiting NCT06019624 - Fresh Takes!: An Evaluation of the Impact of Receiving Fresh Food Boxes N/A
Recruiting NCT05745376 - Addressing Disparities in Food Access Among Young Children in Louisiana: A Farm to ECE Approach N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT05601804 - TARGETing Healthy Weight Loss in the Context of Food Insecurity
Active, not recruiting NCT05048836 - Healthy Food First N/A
Completed NCT02835989 - Community Paramedicine at Home N/A
Not yet recruiting NCT05978843 - Comparison of Produce Prescription Benefit Dosage N/A
Active, not recruiting NCT00821366 - Effective Aids Treatment and Support in the Free State (FEATS) Phase 3
Active, not recruiting NCT05424367 - Food Environment, Food Insecurity, and Health Behaviors in NH Hispanics
Completed NCT03847662 - Scaling up Small-Scale Food Processing to Promote Food Security Among Women Farmers in Rural Vietnam
Not yet recruiting NCT05854212 - Behavioral Economics to Implement Nutrition Ranking in Food Pantries N/A
Withdrawn NCT04017624 - Fresh Truck Pilot to Reduce Food Insecurity in a Medicaid ACO N/A
Completed NCT05076487 - Effects of Episodic Food Insecurity in African American Women With Obesity
Terminated NCT04968496 - Biobehavioral Mechanisms of Food Insecurity N/A
Completed NCT02925429 - PostNAPS: FI, Nutrition, and Psychosocial Health Among Women of Mixed HIV Status and Their Infants in Gulu, Uganda
Completed NCT02095613 - Tailored Nutrition and Food Security Interventions in Comprehensive HIV Care N/A
Completed NCT03363048 - Grocery Assistance Program Study for Families N/A