Fish Consumers Clinical Trial
IConsumption of fish provides a vital contribution to the survival and health of a significant portion of the world's population. Lipids in fish foods consist mainly of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) such as eicosapentaenic acid (EPA, C20:5n-3) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA C22:6n-3) which belongs to the physiologically important group of n-3 fatty acids. The increase of unsaturated fatty acids, along with the reduction of saturated fats, supports the lowering of blood cholesterol in humans and causes a positive impact on human nutrition. Polyunsaturated fatty acids (omega-3 fatty acids) plays a role in preventing heart disease and has anti-inflammatory and anti-thrombosis effects and these fatty acids cannot be synthesized and they must be obtained through diet. These nutritional benefits of fish consumption is mainly attributed to the effect of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids , which are thought to have several potential cardio protective actions. This research is focused mainly identify highly consumed food fishes available in Batticaloa district( fresh, lagoon and sea water ) and their consumption pattern (cooking methods) of local community and by cardiovascular patients (CV) . Secondly Omega-3- Polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) and tocopherol content (Vit E) in the fresh fish and dried or smoked fish of the highly consumed food fishes would be assessed and the relationship between fish consumption and its PUFA and Vit E content would be known. Also research will focus how lifestyle, socio-demographic factors' influences on the Cardiovascular diseases among community.
1. Introduction
Consumption of fish provides a vital contribution to the survival and health of a
significant portion of the world's population. Lipids in fish foods consist mainly of
long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) such as eicosapentaenic acid (EPA,
C20:5n-3) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA C22:6n-3) which belongs to the physiologically
important group of n-3 fatty acids. The increase of unsaturated fatty acids, along with
the reduction of saturated fats, supports the lowering of blood cholesterol in humans
and causes a positive impact on human nutrition. Polyunsaturated fatty acids (omega-3
fatty acids) plays a role in preventing heart disease and has anti-inflammatory and
anti-thrombosis effects and these fatty acids cannot be synthesized and they must be
obtained through diet. These nutritional benefits of fish consumption is mainly
attributed to the effect of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids , which are thought to
have several potential cardio protective actions. This research is focused mainly
identify highly consumed food fishes available in Batticaloa district( fresh, lagoon
and sea water ) and their consumption pattern (cooking methods) of local community and
by cardiovascular patients (CV) . Secondly Omega-3- Polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA)
and tocopherol content (Vit E) in the fresh fish and dried or smoked fish of the highly
consumed food fishes would be assessed and the relationship between fish consumption
and its PUFA and Vit E content would be known. Also research will focus how lifestyle,
socio-demographic factors' influences on the Cardiovascular diseases among community.
2. Justification Since the consumption of marine fish have high omega-3 fatty acid and
showed the reduction of death by CVD, there is no record about the content of omega-3
fatty acid in fresh and brackish water fishes and effects on consumption of fresh and
brackish water fishes by South Asian population. Nearly 50 % of population of Sri
Lankan consume Inland fishes and it is not known the lipids content, omega-3- fatty
acids and tocopherol in muscle of these fishes. This would be first study to understand
the content of type of lipids , omega-3 fatty acids, tocopherol and the relationship
with fish consumption and CVD. This research will identify the formula of cooking and
consumption method of fish.
3. Over all Objectives i) Identification of highly consumed food fish varieties (fresh,
marine and lagoon) in the district and consumption rate.
iii) Quantifying the Omega-3 -Polyunsaturated fatty acid and Tocopherol content of
flesh of selected highly consumed fishes.
iv) Compare the lipid profile of the randomly selected CVD patients and apparently
healthy subjects and to relate it to PUFAs content of fish v) Assess all the factors
related with fish consumption and CVD and to finding a new method of consumption of
fish.
4. Literature Review Consumption of fish provides an important nutrient for 135 billions
of people worldwide and thus makes a very significant contribution to nutrients (FAO,
2010). Fish consists of polyunsaturated fatty acids in the form of arachidonic acid,
eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid (Kinsella et al.1990). Marine species
have high level of PUFAs and those species are less likely consuming by the poor and
low income people. And Small pelagic forage fish species have rich PUFAS and they are
cheaper and preferably consumed by them (Tacon and Metain, 2009). Increasing
consumption of omega-3 fatty acid can benefit health by reducing Cardiovascular
diseases (Udani and Ritz, 2013). Kinsella (2005) reported that the increase of
unsaturated fatty acids along with the reduction of saturated fats , supports the
lowering of blood cholesterol in humans. Din et al., ( 2004) stated that the fish
consumption were mainly attributed to the effect of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids
which are thought to have several potential cardio protective actions. It was observed
that Greenland Eskimos exhibited significantly lower rates of mortality from coronary
heart disease (CHD) compared to Danes due to high intake of fish which are rich of
omega -3 PUFAs (Menotti et al, 1999 Heidel et al ., 2007). However, Coronary heart
disease is still the leading cause of death and disability in the world. Well known
risk factors for heart diseases include age, sex, smoking, diet, physical inactivity,
high blood pressure, diabetes and high cholesterol level and some more factors
associated such as life style, social class, income and occupational factors comprising
job stress, combustion products and environmental factors (Yasunori Suematsu et
al,2013). The consumption of fish and fish products is recommended as a means of
preventing cardiovascular diseases and greatly increased over recent decades in many
European countries (Cahu et al .,2004). Modification in the fatty acids profiles by
different culinary technologies in cooking fish for consumption alters the nutritive
value of final product is major importance of human health. Therefore, the fatty acids
profile in fish varied with fresh, processed and cooked form(Garcia-Arias et al.,
1998).
In Sri Lanka, as per the 2011 health ranking report 11.69% of total population death
reported due to Coronary heart disease and 7.41% hypertension.Some Nutritionally
important fatty acids in seven type of fishes eaten in Sri Lanka has been studied
(Liyanage et al., 1989). And the fish consumption behaviors is determined by many
factors (Pethiyagoda and Olsen, 2012). . Some nutritionally important fatty acids in
seven varieties of fish eaten in Sri Lanka has been studied (Liyanage, et al., 1989)
and the fish consumption behaviour is determined by many factors ( Pethiyagoda and
Olsen, 2012). The peroximate composition of three species of Scomberoides fish from the
Sri Lankan waters was done by (Sutharsiniy and Sivashanthy, 2011b) and stated
Scomberoid commonsonianus is good diatetic species. The total lipid and cholesterol
content of the five commercial important fish species has been assessed by the
((Sutharsiniy and Sivashanthy, 2011a). Wimalasena and Jayasuriya ( 1996) studied the
nutritional analysis of some freshwater fishes in Sri Lanka
5. Methodology 5.1. Study Design Annexure I
. 5.2.Hypothesis of study Omega-3- fatty acid (PUFAs) and Tocopherol content in fish
flesh are high in inland fishes and it prevents CVD diseases as per the interview from
the fish eating people.. However, there are many factors such as life style and
socio-demographic factors and eating methods of fish will be taken into our study since
those are influencing factors of CVD and the Lipid profile of CVD patients and non- CVD
people will be compared with fish consumption. This research is justified as a first
study in Sri Lanka to understand the relationship of fish consumption and its pattern
in naïve and CVD from Eastern Sri Lankan Community 5.3.Study Area
Study is carried out in Batticaloa District from Vakarai to Kalar.
5.4. Study Setting
Study has been planned to collect the information from fish consuming people in the
Batticaloa district randomly representing different ethnicity and religion by
distributing structured questionnairre.
5.5. Study Population
The one fifth (1/5- 2500) of total population in Batticaloa district who consume fish
and shellfish as their major proteinous diet will be the subjects of study. In
addition, a special focus on the people (250) who have cardiovascular diseases who
engaged in treatment.
5.6. Sampling method
The selection of subjects for survey will be done by stratified random sampling with
consideration of population of divisional secretariat (14) proportionately whole in
Batticaloa District. A special focus in the selection of subjects in three DS
secretariat ( Manmunai West, KoraliPattu South and Porathivu Pattu).
Semi-Structured Questionnaire will be used to gather the data with their full
permission of subjects.
Experimental Method- Observation and Analytical Method
Total fat content and Lipid profile of mostly consuming fishes( muscle) by the subjects
( 10) in fresh , processed and cooked form will be taken for analysis in (triplicates)
using standard method. (Annexure2) Omega-3 fatty acids and tocopherol content
(triplicates) will be measured from the same set of fishes. Both analytical methods
will be carried out in ITI laboratory in Colombo .
Lipid Profile of Naïve fish consuming people (as control) and People who are suffering
CVD diseases will be measured and primary data of demographics, history and lifestyle
of the subjects will be studied (. Annexure 2 )
5.6. Inclusive Criteria People (subjects) must be regular fish consumer and mostly
brackish and fresh water consumers.
5.7. Study Period 3 years study starting from Dec 2013 upto Nov 2016.
5.8. Materials Used Annexure 2
5.9. Data Collection
It will be done by three ways: structured questionnaire, primary data, secondary data,
direct interview, Observation data- Market Survey Analytical data- Total lipid content
in fish, Fatty acid content in fish, Omega three fatty acid and tocopherol Lipid
profile of naïve regular fish consuming people (250) and CVD people who are engaged in
treatment .
Lipid profile for selected subjects (naïve) after 6 month of fish consumption lipid
profile will be tested.
Blood (2ml) will be collected from the subjects for the lipid profile analysis with
their consent.
( This procedure will be done once the ethical clearance certificate issued)
5.10 Data Analysis SPSS -19 package , EXCEL and SAS ( if needed) for ranking will be
used.
5.11. Study Sensitization This study will reveal the different fatty acids in fish and
the content and these will not be sensitized issue. Since lipid profile of naïve human
and CVD people will be treated confidentially and data will be treated same and after
research . All data will be destroyed.
5.12. Consent Statement- Annexure 3
5.13. Confidentiality Statement Annexure 3
5.14. Work Plan Annexure 4
Annexure 2 Phase I This survey will be specially focused on the relationship between
consumption of fish /food and its preference of quality, the impact of consumer
involvement, role of life styles, experience and habit, quantity intake, time of
consumption, socio-demographic characteristics, health and diet beliefs and
convenience. It would be done among one in 500 people of total population(525142). That
is nearly 1500.
Of the randomly selected people of fish consumers , nearly 250 people (male & female),
aged between 35 to 50 who are engaging in treatment for Cardiac vascular disease (CVD)
, hypertension and stroke in three different national hospitals in Eastern Province.
The daily fish consumption data, type of fish, amount of fish consumption in three
times will be assessed during health survey among patients. During the survey fish
eating frequency, cooking method, special ingredients used to cook fish , how many
minutes they cooked fish, and processing technique will be interviewed.
Phase II By doing Market survey (nearly 5 city markets and 5 local markets) the major
food fishes would be identified taxonomically and fish consumption rate will be
calculated.
Phase III The total fat content subjected to the study will be extracted according to
the Soxhlet protocol (ADAC,1995 ) from the flesh of 10 highly consumed fishes. Total
lipid extraction was made with chloroform methanol (2:1) and according to Folich et al
,.(1957) methodology modified by Bligh and Dyer (1959). Fatty acid methyl esters (FAME)
will be prepared with methanol using BF3 -MeoH complex, as catalyst, according to the
method of Metcalfe et al (1966). Omega-3 fatty acid of the highly consumed fresh,
cooked and dried fish muscle would be analyzed using Gas Liquid Chromatography and the
tocopherol content will be analyzed using High Performance Liquid Chromatography
(HPLC). These would be correlated with consumer preference of fish and CVD. The omega-3
-PUFA and Tocopherol content of all samples would be analyzed at same time. Sample of
ten selected highly consumed fish species will be taken for this study. Lipid profile
of randomly selected (50) CVD patients who will be selected with the help of the
Batticaloa cardiology unit will be taken in our study and it will be monitored monthly
for five months.
Phase IV The correlation between the fish consumption and the cooking methods and life
style of the community and Cardiovascular diseases in the Eastern Community will be
analyzed.
Phase V The nutritional composition of identified of selected highly consumed fish and
existing cooking method would be studied and new method of cooking style formulated and
would be tested and will be introduced among consumers.
;