Clinical Trial Details
— Status: Withdrawn
Administrative data
| NCT number |
NCT03595072 |
| Other study ID # |
17-0578 |
| Secondary ID |
|
| Status |
Withdrawn |
| Phase |
|
| First received |
|
| Last updated |
|
| Start date |
July 1, 2023 |
| Est. completion date |
January 1, 2025 |
Study information
| Verified date |
June 2023 |
| Source |
University of Colorado, Denver |
| Contact |
n/a |
| Is FDA regulated |
No |
| Health authority |
|
| Study type |
Observational
|
Clinical Trial Summary
This study will investigate whether a Vagal Nerve Stimulator (VNS) causes measurable
desynchronization and reduces epileptiform activity, such as spikes and seizures, in
electrocorticograms (ECOGs) recorded by a Responsive Neurostimulator (RNS) in patients who
have both devices implanted.
Specific aims of the study:
1. Evaluate the change in frequency of epileptiform discharges during active VNS
stimulation compared to interstimulation baseline periods
2. Evaluate the change in frequency of seizures during active VNS stimulation compared to
interstimulation baseline periods
3. Evaluate the change in the number of RNS activations during active VNS stimulation
compared to interstimulation baseline periods
4. Evaluate the change in synchronization of background ECoG (electrocorticogram) during
VNS stimulation compared to interstimulation baseline periods.
Description:
Drug resistant epilepsy, is defined by the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) as
"the failure of adequate trials of two tolerated and appropriately chosen and used AED
(Antiepileptic drug) schedules (whether as monotherapies or in combination) to achieve
sustained seizure freedom." About a third of epilepsy cases are drug resistant and are
considered for non-pharmacologic treatment. Surgical removal (resection) of the seizure focus
is the treatment of choice in drug resistant epilepsy with focal onset. However, curative
surgery is not always feasible, e.g. if it would lead to unacceptable deficits, or if there
are seizure onset areas in both sides of the brain. In addition, depending on the
circumstances, patients treated with surgery do not become seizure free in about 10-80% of
cases, depending on presence or absence of a lesion and location of the seizure focus. Other
surgical options include implantation of neuromodulatory devices, such as Vagus Nerve
Stimulator (VNS) and Responsive Neurostimulator (RNS).
IIa. Vagus Nerve Stimulator (VNS) Brain surgery was the only surgical option for some
patients in this drug-resistant patient population until 1997 when the VNS was approved by
the FDA. VNS is approved for use as an adjunctive therapy in reducing the frequency of
seizures in adults and adolescents over age 12 diagnosed with medically refractory partial
onset seizures (FDA 1997). The vagus nerve and its centers (nuclei) in the brainstem have, in
general, an inhibitory effect on organs. VNS therapy can suppress seizures by sending mild
pulses of electrical energy to the vagus nerve in regular intervals. The default setting of
stimulation are cycles of 30-seconds "on" and 5-minutes "off". These stimulation pulses are
supplied by a thin, round battery-containing device which is placed under the skin on the
left side of the chest, like a pacemaker, with wires connecting the generator to the vagus
nerve on the left side of the neck. VNS is not likely to stop seizures (seizure freedom rate
with VNS added range from 2-9%), but it provides a ~50% chance of cutting the seizure
frequency in half (Ben-Menachem 1999, Scherrmann 2001,Morris 1999, Kuba 2009).
IIb. Responsive Neurostimulator (RNS) The RNS was FDA approved in 2013. The RNS System
provides responsive cortical stimulation through an implanted programmable neurostimulator
connected to depth and/or subdural cortical strip leads targeted to the seizure focus. The
RNS device continually monitors brain activity (electrocorticography [ECoG]). It is
programmed by the physician to detect seizure patterns and provide appropriate electrical
stimulation within a few seconds of the seizure onset. RNS was approved by the FDA for use as
an adjunctive therapy in reducing the frequency of seizures in individuals 18 years of age or
older with partial (focal) onset seizures who have undergone diagnostic testing that
localized to no more than two epileptogenic foci, are refractory to two or more antiepileptic
medications, and currently have frequent and disabling seizures (FDA 2013). The generator of
the device is implanted in the patient's skull and wires connect to the leads in or on the
brain (see Figure 2). Depending on where in the brain it is implanted, RNS is associated with
seizure free intervals of 6 months in 26-29% of patients and of 12 months in 14-15% of cases.
The rate of seizure freedom is relatively low, compared to resections, but the chance of a
marked (~70%) seizure reduction is high (Geller 2017, Jobst 2017).
IIc. No studies to date have investigated the effect of VNS stimulation on the more recently
FDA approved RNS. The initial RNS feasibility study listed VNS as an exclusion criteria as it
was not clear how the two devices would interact. However, before RNS was available, patients
with a seizure focus or several foci that could not be surgically removed, were implanted
with VNS. Therefore, in the current post-approval phase of RNS treatment, many patients
already have a VNS which has not brought the hoped for seizure relief. Across centers it has
been standard practice to implant RNS in patients who have a VNS, and to keep the VNS turned
on, if the patient reported clinical benefit. Even though there are no guidelines, the
rationale for not removing a VNS before RNS implantation appears to be as follows:
1. The devices are not linked or physically close together and are not enabled to
communicate with each other.
2. Current delivered by either device penetrates only targeted tissue in the immediate
vicinity of the electrodes and is not able to reach the other device.
3. Each device provides a different mechanism of action and is a separate, independent
modality to influence seizures, similar to medications and VNS being different therapy
modalities that act in a complementary fashion.
4. To date, no case of a concerning interaction has been described.
Thus, many patients with drug-resistant epilepsy have both VNS and RNS implanted. So far, the
investigators have no data and no knowledge of how the VNS influences brain activity, as
recorded by RNS, close to a seizure focus. The presence of continually-recording Intracranial
RNS electrodes provides a unique opportunity to study changes in normal and abnormal ECoG
patterns during VNS stimulation.
III. PRELIMINARY STUDIES/PROGRESS REPORT:
VNS continues to be used as an adjunctive therapy as many patients with drug resistant
epilepsy are either opposed to a resection or the invasive surgery required for RNS
implantation, or are not a good candidate for these surgeries based on location and/or number
of epileptogenic foci. VNS was approved by the FDA in 1997 for use as an adjunctive therapy
in reducing the frequency of seizures in adults and adolescents over age 12 diagnosed with
medically refractory partial onset seizures. Data suggests that only 2-9% (Ben-Menachem 1999,
Scherrmann 2001) of patients become seizure free after implantation, but over time 43-49% of
patients experience a >50% drop in seizure frequency (Morris 1999; Kuba 2009.)
In the RNS comparative study - which investigated device efficacy - seizure frequency was
measured for 3 months in both the Treatment Group (received stimulation) and the Control
Group (did not receive stimulation). The Treatment Group had a reduction in seizures of 37.9%
and the Control Group had a reduction in seizures of 17.3%. Seizure frequency was also
measured by determining the number of patients who achieved a 50% reduction in seizures.
After 1 year, almost half of the patients in the treatment group (44%) had at least 50% fewer
seizures. And at 2 years, over half of the patients (55%) had at least 50% fewer seizures.
Seven-year follow-up showed up to 70% seizure reduction, and up to 15% of patients reported
seizure free periods of 12 months (Geller et al 2017, Jobst et al 2017).
VNS was an exclusion criterion in the RNS clinical trial to avoid any interference of the
devices. Of all patients enrolled in the study, 32% had previously used VNS without
sufficient benefit (Bergey 2015). This patient population had the VNS explanted in order to
participate in the RNS trial. Nowadays, after approval of the device, 27% of patients who
receive a RNS also have a VNS (unpublished data collected by Neuropace® the company
manufacturing the device, personal communication). In clinical practice, there is no
contraindication to combined neurostimulation using VNS in addition to RNS.
To date, no head-to-head comparison studies have been done that compare efficacy of RNS
compared to VNS.
The effect of VNS stimulation on the RNS recordings (ECoGs) will be determined during one
clinic visit scheduled for RNS assessment and interrogation. ECoGs with brain activity during
VNS stimulation and in-between stimulation - baseline - intervals will be recorded, stored,
and later analyzed. During this visit, as an exception to standard of care, the regular,
patient-specific VNS "on-" and "off-times" will be turned off and VNS stimulation will be
triggered by the investigator using a magnet that activates the VNS for the set time of 30
seconds (see detailed protocol below.) This will represent a temporary change in a patient's
VNS settings for the time of the recordings, but at the end of the visit, the stimulation
"on" and "off" times, will be returned to the previous home settings. These VNS changes are
unlikely to affect the patient's seizure control, as VNS effect on seizures is a result of
months and years of stimulation. Though, just like at home, the patient is expected to feel
the VNS "on-time" as a sensation in the throat, often described as "tickling", which may
prompt clearing the voice or a cough, as well as a transient hoarseness.
A stimulation time of 30 seconds was chosen for stimulation duration as the typical default
setting for VNS stimulation is 30 seconds and many patients are treated at default settings.
A period of 30 seconds before and after stimulation was chosen as recording time to allow for
at least 1 min between stimulations which is standard of care. Since the purpose of this
study is to compare the effect of active VNS stimulation on the brain and ECoG to intervals
without VNS stimulation, the investigators chose timing that would allow for maximum number
of stimulations/recordings within a clinic appointment that is within the standard of care in
terms of frequency of stimulations
D. DETAILED PROTOCOL FOR RESEARCH DATA COLLECTION IN CLINIC:
1. RNS recording equipment (so-called "wand") used to connect to the device through the skin
and collect data will be secured to the patient's scalp over the implanted RNS computer. This
will be done using a velcro cap provided by the RNS Manufacturer (NeuroPace®). Connection
will be made with device and real-time ECoG data visualized on laptop. Clinic appointment
will proceed as per standard of care.
1a. Electromyography (EMG) electrode will be in place over left side of neck close to the VNS
contacts. This electrode will be able to detect muscle signal and artifact related to VNS
stimulation which will confirm successful VNS activation when triggered.
2. VNS will be interrogated using a handheld interrogation device. Stimulation parameters
will be recorded and output current will be turned to zero. VNS magnet stimulation duration
will be set to 30 seconds (rationale, see above) with pulse width and output current at the
patient's baseline stimulation settings. All settings will be within accepted ranges for
standard of care.
3. ECoG recording will be initiated on laptop, by turning on "Real-time ECoG"
4. Thirty seconds into the recording, the VNS will be triggered with magnet stimulation which
will produce a 30-second vagus nerve stimulation ("stim"). 30 seconds later, the recording
will be stopped and stored.
4a. This will generate a 30 sec pre-stim, a 30 sec stim, and a 30 sec post-stim recording.
5. This will be repeated 30 times per patient for a total of 30 VNS stimulations or up to 45
minutes of patient time
6. At the end of the appointment, VNS will be returned to its scheduled stimulations with any
adjustments needed as would be part of standard of care.
